Volume XXXI
DECEMBER, 1918
No. 12
The Polish Question
THE representatives of the Poles, who have been serving the cause of Poland in this country, mistake entirely the criticism of the Polish situation by those interested in the well-being of the Polish Jews. It is quite clear that it is to the interest of the Poles not to indulge in pogroms or anti-Jewish violence at a time when they are appealing for justice to the representatives of the nations at the Peace Conference. One need not be a keen psychologist to understand that the Polish representatives are chagrined to learn of excesses committed against Jews by their Polish compatriots, which embarrass them in their negotiations with the free nations that have been friendly to their cause.
But the Jewish point of view implies that the pogroms that are reported now are merely the natural consequence of the Polish boycott, the anomalous position the Jews have occupied in Poland, and the inevitable anti-Jewish hatred that has been engendered by several generations of discrimination and social and economic disabilities. We are dealing with facts and not with the causes of the facts. We are concerned with the future and not with the past, and therefore it is in order to say to the Polish representatives that guarantees should be given to the Polish Jews which will assure them of freedom to maintain their economic and political existence, and of protection from the government which it is aimed to set up in Poland. It is folly for the Polish representatives to expect that the brethren of the. Jews of Poland in other lands, will be strongly interested in assisting in the establishment of the state of Poland, and leaving to the Polish people and their anti-Jewish representatives the free disposition of the Jewish question. The time to give the legal and moral guarantees is now, and not later. The time for the Polish representatives to secure justice for the Jews is now, before the constitution of the state is fixed, and not later when international interference with internal matters will be very difficult if not impossible.
It will not do to repudiate the reports that have come here from Warsaw by claiming that the pogroms are due to conflicts between Ukranians and the Poles, and that the Jews may have been hurt between the two forces. The conflicts between the Ukranians and the Poles are also not good evidence of the ability of the Poles to adjust their interests with their neighbors in an amicable manner. But where there is so much hatred of Jews, first because they are Jews, then because they may be Ukranians or Russians, and third because they may be middle-class men or capital-
ists, pogroms are only natural, and no amount of disclaimer will do away with facts that have been verified from several sources.
It is obviously the duty of the Polish representatives to be frank and above-board and to take action to protect Polish interests by proceeding at once with the consideration of plans to protect the rights of the Polish Jews. Any other policy is certain to lead to a misunderstanding of their purposes and the loss of friends who are sincerely interested in the establishment of a free, but a tolerant Polish state.
The American Jewish Congress
THE American Jewish Congress will convene in Philadelphia on December 15th, and there is an end to the heated arguments that filled the air demanding the immediate convening of the Congress. Much of the heat was produced by anxiety based upon unfounded fears, and our friends the Poale Zion are no doubt again claiming the honor of having rushed forward with demands no one ever had any intention of refusing to comply with.
The Congress will meet at an opportune moment and will be in a position to render positive service to the Jewish cause. Difficulties would have been encountered by the Zionists had they not secured in advance the endorsement by the Administrative Committee of the proposal that the Congress shall be free to revise its program in the light of new political conditions, These difficulties being disposed of, the Congress is now in a position to deal with the British Declaration, with the new political alignments in Middle Europe, unhampered by phraseology in the compromise agreement, which might have placed the nationalist elements at a decided tactical disadvantage.
The Congress will doubtless act at once to meet the situation arising out of the fact that the Peace Conference will be in session and will, we feel sure, not lose a moment’s time with the election of a delegation to proceed at once to Europe, properly instructed, in order to act in co-operation with the Jews of all other lands for the best interests of the Jewish people. This is a paramount duty. All other questions become secondary. The American Jewish Delegation will have a tremendous responsibility and a task which will require the utmost political sagacity and knowledge. To guide it in its policies, it should not be burdened with detailed instructions, for to a large extent, what it will do will have to be achieved in co-operation with the representatives of the Jews of other lands.