The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 9 · September 1918
69printed page
scan 7 of 27
Facsimile · scan 7 of 27
Scan of p. 69
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

barriers between Jews and non-Jews are automatically raised. Strange enough, although the assimilative tendencies in the army would seem overpowering, the Jewish consciousness of the soldier is strengthened rather than weakened. Because of his close contact with non-Jews, a contact which may have been utterly foreign to him in civil life, he is thrown back all the more forcibly upon Jewish ideals and customs. He does not conceal his nationality—in fact, with a refreshing lack of self-consciousness not frequently encountered in the world outside, he frankly and naturally carries his Jewishness.

In those rare instances where Jews do try to conceal their identity they usually suffer almost to the extent of becoming hunted beasts. One example will suffice to illustrate this statement: A soldier—let his name be Abraham Elliott Cohen for the purpose of this story—an avowed assimilationist, is said to have petitioned the commanding general that, in violation of the military regulations, he be permitted to be registered in the army records as A. Elliott Cohen. He received his letter a few days later endorsed with military brevity, “Returned—disapproved.” Unfortunately for Cohen, the nature of his request leaked out, and now all his soldier acquaintances (such are life’s little ironies!) greet him as “Abe.” And, though he refuses to answer to this greeting, he is, of course, now farther than ever from being able to hide his identity.

The Jewish soldier knows that the present war is being fought to protect the rights of small nationalities and he knows, or is willing to learn, that the Jews constitute one of the oldest of all nations. Secure in the pledges of the Allies for the restoration of a Jewish Palestine, he will fight the battles of America with redoubled vigor and ambition. Since the Balfour declaration, he feels that this war is as much his as anybody else's; he sees that almost every nationality on earth is engaged in it; he feels that we are also in it, that we ought to remain in it, and that there are ideal as well as material gains to be derived from it. The idea of a Jewish Palestine is as thrilling to him as the vision of a restored Belgium to a Belgian.

THE DUTY OF THE ZIONIST ORGANIZATION

But the Jewish soldier must be sought out; the hardships of military life utterly preclude his taking the initiative in Zionist work. There is but one direct road to him for the Zionists—that of the printed word. The men in the camps are now reading books they would never have dreamed of reading before. How eagerly would they satisfy through books their newly aroused interest in Zionism! Pamphlets, books, newspapers and magazines are sorely needed. Literature for the special use of soldiers should be printed, and we should know that there are organized means of keeping in communication with us. The Zionist organization will make a great mistake if it does not very soon realize that it should issue publications for the soldiers, and in large quantities. Nothing short of seventy-six-mile super-cannon loads of literature will do. The army men who are coming

back will be important factors in determining the social and national politics of the regenerated world; and they should now be kept in close touch with all happening in the Zionist movement. The Zionist organization, therefore, should follow the Y. M. C. A. in distributing, at all American camps, khaki-bound, handy-sized copies of pamphlet literature on Zionist theory and history, contemporaneous Zionist achievements, the Jewish Legion, and related subjects. Wherever such pamphlets do not already exist they should be written especially for that purpose. I feel certain that Herzl's "Jewish State," Pinsker's "Auto-Emancipation," Miss Szold's "Recent Jewish Progress in Palestine," the English pamphlets of Sacher, Simon and their colleagues, if distributed at the camps in quantities, would be devoured by the soldiers. Particularly should Zionist organizations see that miniature Zionist libraries are provided in special sections of the buildings so that the soldiers who desire to read them will know where to find them. If lists of Zionist literature were sent to the American Library Association, that organization doubtless would attempt to furnish such books for all the camp libraries.

In addition to supplying the soldiers with literature, the Zionists of nearby centers should arrange to have meetings at the several camps. These meetings should be real events in camp life, and, consequently, should not be held too frequently to weaken their effect; a meeting every two months would suffice. The speakers at the meetings, moreover, should be men of at least local, if not national, repute. They should preach Zionism, not try to organize societies. Zionist societies in camp, trench, or on shipboard are thoroughly impractical because of the constant change of membership which would be consequent upon the movement of troops.

A GOLDEN OPPORTUNITY FOR ZIONISM

As we have seen, the Jewish League for Welfare Work in the Army and Navy has not accomplished what might have been expected of it. The Zionist organization should feel equally, if not more, guilty in not having even made an effort in this direction. By overlooking the army the Zionists have missed a golden opportunity. They should hasten to retrieve their mistake. Individual Zionists ought to become Jewish Welfare Workers. The Zionist organization ought to open a special bureau to take charge of the war activities outlined—the distribution of literature and the arrangement of meetings.

Some day, when the world is safe from the Prussian boot, many of us will return to the old life. We want to find it a better and happier life for the Jewish people. And it would be an injustice and a mistake for us to be permitted, during these days, when we are withdrawn temporarily from our ordinary spheres of activity, to forget what is going on in Jewry and Judaism. We are, just now more than ever, susceptible to Jewish, and particularly nationalistic, influences. Let the Zionist organization but do its share, and I can promise that we will do ours.