The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 9 · September 1918
89printed page
scan 27 of 27
Facsimile · scan 27 of 27
Scan of p. 89
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

at a time when our national cause faces a great opportunity and a great responsibility. Those who had doubts have had those doubts removed.

We feel profoundly grateful to President Wilson for having disposed of the specious arguments of some Jews against the loyalty of the Zionists just when the last of the tribe were about to convene to give expression to their confused thoughts. We Jews bred on American soil and educated in American institutions have always resented their misinterpretation of what America stands for, as well as their misinterpretation of Zionism. We always felt that they spoke for the alien, half-educated Jew who could not distinguish between the genuine and the spurious Americanism. We always held fast to the ideal aspect of American life, believing that it represented the spirit of America; and when these men sought to bolster up their anti-national reform religion—which was basically in reality a movement to rectify a political situation—it was an offense to every fibre of our being as Americans to hear them speak and to read their heavy, unintelligible, guttural emanations stressed with a foreign accent. President Wilson’s brief letter has. given the quietus to the ignorant blatherings of these misguided Jews.

The Allied democratic nations have recognized the validity of our cause, which has become one of the allied movements, for which the Allies are public sponsors. President Wilson has gone as far as he morally and legally has a right to go as president of the United States in giving expression to his convictions. His convictions echo the sentiments of enlightened America. Of that we have absolutely no doubt.

Disloyalty

THERE have been rumors for several months past that a small group of reform rabbis were about to call a conference to organize the opposition to Zionism alleged to be extant among reform Jews. Intimation to this effect was given in the Jewish Comment of Baltimore, which died soon after. But the idea seems to have lived on. Dr. Philipson of Cincinnati sent out a personal letter, asking a number of prominent Jews to lend their names to a call for a conference to be held in New York in October. Dr. Philipson seemed to have been persuaded to call off the attempt by a letter written by Mr. Jacob H. Schiff in which opposition to Zionism was condemned, and in which Mr. Schiff stated that he believed Zionism to be a movement that will greatly benefit the whole Jewish people. There are rumors, however, that such an anti-Zionist conference will be held under different auspices.

No one expected or expects there to be unanimity of opinion on an important question like the future of the Jewish people. Antagonisms die hard; they engender dogmas and habits of thinking that are with difficulty dislodged. Once a man has publicly declared himself opposed to this or that, it requires a certain intellectual magnanimity to come forward publicly and confess to error. This is one of the unavoidable obstacles to progress; but just because of the opposition superinduced by intellectual habit, the idea which it combats profits through the struggle. Opposition to Zionism seems to have been one of the first dogmas firmly established among reform Jews, who obtained their instruction and inspiration from German rabbis and scholars responsible for the reform movement. Conditions have changed since then; the impractical has become

eminently practical; the political reason responsible for the German reform theory has become obsolete; the world has changed its attitude toward the Jewish people; the French Sanhedrin has passed into oblivion and the ideas it set forth have been repudiated by Jews and by non-Jews; we are living in a new world; but these few Bourbons continue to hug the dead ideas they still think have vitality in them. It is natural and inevitable. Little minds must be ever consistent.

But Zionism has become a program of action; it is the Jewish people seeking to conserve and enhance its future; it is the Jewish people engaged in the reconstruction of its life. It represents a course of action believed by hundreds of thousands of Jews to be imperative if the Jewish people are to survive and to be an influence in the world. Through the Zionist organization the Jewish people are laboring to improve Jewish conditions,—religious, moral, social, material and intellectual. And the Jewish people have come to a virtual agreement as to how the work of reconstruction is to be done. It is to be achieved by establishing in Palestine a national center, in which Jewish life is to be set up and from which the Jewish civilization created shall radiate throughout the world.

That this is the paramount and supreme Jewish interest has been acceded to by the Allied democratic nations; President Wilson has given his endorsement to it; leading statesmen and thinkers and public men have aligned themselves with this interpretation of the Jewish interest. The overwhelming majority of the Jewish people—backed up by what every Jew knows to have been the ideals and hopes of all past generations—have taken their stand with the Zionist movement. The actual work of reconstruction has begun. Palestine has been liberated, and the Jewish people have entered the door of opportunity with the Zionist administrative commission, with the medical unit, with thousands of Jewish legionaries, with the renewal of the activities of the Anglo-Palestine company; and new obligations are arising from day to day.

This being the case, it is no longer a question of what this or that rabbi thinks or feels; whether he likes it or not; it is a settled question, and it is the obvious duty of every Jew, regardless of his private, personal opinion, to adjust himself to the conditions, and not to interfere with the right of the Jewish people as a whole to determine its own future. The formation of an organization or committee to combat Zionism means that it is intended actively to oppose the carrying out of the will of the Jewish people, to destroy, if possible, the program of the Jewish people, to interfere, if possible, with the realization of what it deems its national requirements. Such action, if taken by a German with regard to a German interest or cause, or by an Englishman with regard to an English interest or cause, would be called disloyalty or treason.

We do not regard the tactless Rabbi Frisch as a credible specimen of the genus anti-Zionist, but the charge he made in his telegram to President Wilson is the charge that every anti-Zionist by implication also makes against the Zionist movement.

Granted that according to reform theory, the Jewish people represent a religious sect, then it is the obvious duty of those who stand forth as exponents of that theory to live in accordance with their beliefs. Not being interested in Jewish life in aspects other than those reflecting religious implications, let them proceed to be observers of their faith.