The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 9 · September 1918
78printed page
scan 16 of 27

The Maccabaean

is created by the consent of the parties. Having this example before us in our own country, where after a century and a half of national existence the tendency toward assimilation should have been marked and strong, we can readily understand how difficult of solution this problem will be in the new Palestinian State where the various elements of society will differ in race, religion, language, social outlook, education and tradition.

CO-OPERATIVE LIFE AS A LEGAL BASIS

Another factor which will have to be considered is the change of the basis of modern thought from the individualistic to the co-operative view of society. To the Jews, this does not represent a change. It is but a return to the fundamental views expressed in the Bible. But as the Jews have been living: for so many centuries in a society domi- . nated very largely by the Roman, Feudal and English laws of property and contract, of liability and right, all of which systems of law emphasize individual right rather than the collective interest of society, there will probably take place a mental readjustment facilitated by the fact that in a new land co-operation will necessarily be normal, and not merely the result of the great European experiment of the last millennium.

THE DANGER OF DOGMATISM

In considering these many difficult problems, we should move with the greatest caution and deference for the opinion of others. Dogmatic assertion can only increase the difficulty. In one aspect it seems futile for us to discuss the nature of the Parliament and the form of government of the established Jewish State, for these are not our problems nor the problems of our day. But, although the consideration of such problems may not be a contribution to the amelioration of present conditions, the academic discussion of any problem concerning Palestine may have its use hereafter, provided that our expressions of opinion are free from dogmatism and are tendered tentatively and modestly in the name of a sacred cause and toward the consummation of a great hope. Nothing can be more offensive at this juncture than dogmatism in relation to Palestine, whether it be the dogmatism of the theologian, of the historian, of the philosopher or of the student of society. Above all it must be remembered that studies of the customs, needs and feelings of the Palestinians themselves must be made by competent, careful students in order that the legal studies may be more than mere theoretical suggestions.

THE OLD JEWISH LAW IN THE NEW JEWISH STATE

To what extent can the Jewish Law be adapted to the needs of the people of the Jewish State in Palestine? Upon reflection it will be seen that the law of the new state will probably be something quite different from the old Jewish law. For the Jewish State will be a modern creation whereas the Jewish law is a system that comes down to us out of remote antiquity, developed originally out of tribal custom, codified in partin the Torah, developed as a common law, much of which has been preserved in Mishnah and Talmud. Torn from its connection with the land of Israel and carried away into exile it has had a curious life during the centuries of the Diaspora, growing like plants underground cut off from the healthful influence of

Two-seventy-six

sunshine and rain, wind. and weather. The Jewish law developed into a pallid plant kept alive under abnormal conditions and adjusting itself to an abnormal life. It is to be transplanted into the open. How much of it will survive? All investigators will seek to find the permanent elements in the Jewish law and each one following his own theory will travel a different path. Through such investigation, and the criticism that would be its natural concomitant, some outline may be obtained of the probable development of the old Jewish law in the new Jewish State. This is a field for jurists rather than for theologians. For though seemingly the relation of law and religion is very intimate in the Jewish system of thought, the problems here suggested are legal and not theological. They should be treated inductively rather than deductively, and it seems certain that contributions of value can only come from those who, whether lawyers or theologians, base their views upon history and reason and not merely upon authoritv.

As long as the Jewish law was developed normally in the old land, social justice was the dominant principle guiding the judges in their interpretation. The result was a constant, healthy, normal change in the law reflecting economic and social views and conditions. When the law was cut off from the land and developed in the schools, it became scholastic, dogmatic, more and more rigid and unyielding corresponding to the cramped, unhealthy life of the exiled people. Good law arises out of forensic rather than scholastic discussion.

LIFE KNOWS NO UNCHANGEABLE LAWS; . WHAT IS ORTHODOXY?

If the law is to enter upon a new phase of living development under restored normal conditions, it must in the nature of things speedily outgrow the limitations placed upon it by the conditions of ghetto life, and the question will naturally present itself how can the law be changed? Is it not a dogma of the Jewish law that it is sacred and unchangeable? Yet the same sacred code that says, “Thou shalt not add thereto nor diminish from it,” also says “Thou shalt come unto the judge that shall be in those days,” and “according to the law which they shall teach thee, and according to the judgment which they shall tell thee, thou shalt do.” The very law book which proclaims its own immutability, recognizes the authority of those who may change it. Life laughs at authority. Life is only another word for that necessity which knows no law and, therefore, whether their sanction be divine or human authority, rules must yield to human needs. Lawyers do not and cannot recognize the existence of a perfect law forever unchangeable. Old law has to be reappraised again and again and re-expressed to meet new conditions. Life is the dictator of the law and forever refuses to respect the dead letter of the past. Orthodoxy in thought is merely a method which has been evolved for the purpose of restaining the tendency to translate new ideas into practice too quickly, before society is quite ready to accept them. Orthodox thought, therefore, is constantly changing, slowly but surely taking the place formerly occupied by radical thought as the latter becomes accepted and moves on to a more remotely advanced position. It is a common but erroneous idea that orthodoxy in thought is the acceptance of the oldest authoritative views. True orthodoxy in thought is not the acceptance of the oldest but the acceptance of the very

September, 1918