The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 8 · August 1918
54printed page
scan 16 of 24

The Maccabaean

attended the caucus of the opposition to the district plan at the Hotel Schenley on Sunday evening, must have gone away impressed with the fact that a bitter fight was ahead. The opposition seemed so united, so convinced of the justice of its cause, so determined to break the "iron ring" of the Administration, which it thought was encircling it; the air was so charged with electricity; the speakers were so vehement, almost incendiary in their denunciations; and their audience was so inflammable, that even one completely out of sympathy with the opposition could hardly help entertaining a subtle feeling of admiration for the ardor and zeal with which it worked.

On the other hand the Administration was rallying its forces to support the proposed reorganization plan. Every hour of the day, almost every hour of the night was utilized for a feverish activity. The propaganda was conducted everywhere and at all times: in the corridors and lobby of the Convention hall, on the street, in the trolley cars, in the restaurants, in the lobbies of the hotels,—wherever and whenever delegates congregated. On Monday afternoon the clash came, and it came unexpectedly early in the session in the form of a test vote to decide whether the Chairman's action should be sustained in ruling out of order an amendment committing the convention to a referendum on the reorganization plan, in advance of its own deliberations. Zionist parliamentarians are still arguing the question whether or not the Chairman was actually right from the technical standpoint, but that is really of no consequence. What the convention was engaged in was not a parliamentary wrangle but a serious effort to discover the relative strength of the Administration and the Opposition. The victory of the Administration, that came in the form of a sustaining vote, was greeted by prolonged applause and cheering, in the midst of which there could be discerned a spontaneous ovation to Mr. Lipsky.

A BATTLE ROYAL WITH AN UNEXPECTED CLIMAX

All this was only a preliminary skirmish. The real battle came later in the afternoon when the resolution calling for the consolidation was about to be voted on. Step by step the Opposition was forced to retreat, its numbers ever dwindling and its stand constantly weakening. From minute to minute it became clearer that the various constituent elements of the Zionist movement were prepared to sacrifice their long cherished sovereignty for the good of the movement. The openly expressed consent of Hadassah, the eloquent silence of the Middle Western Federation, Young Judaea and other organizations, rendered the position of the one dissenting group increasingly precarious. The Nasi of the Order Sons of Zion, who had moved the adoption of the resolution providing for the consolidation of the Zionist Organization, a little later sought to exclude the Order from the operation of that resolution; but the Zionists of America in convention assembled, proclaimed in thunderous accents that the Order was, is, and shall be an integral part of the general Zionist Organization. Scorning to offer "exemption" to anyone, the convention finally, unanimously adopted the long debated and fiercely fought over resolution. By one of those sudden inspirations that come unexpectedly at dramatic moments, someone who just

Two-fifty-two

then espied Justice Brandeis sitting alone in the gallery above, sprang to his feet, and, waving his hand frantically in that direction, began to cheer.

What happened the next instant will long be remembered by all present as one of the most wonderful and stimulating experiences through which they had ever passed. The whole Convention, 500 strong, sprang to their feet and broke into a demonstration of unequalled fervor and earnestness. They shouted Hadad until they were hoarse. They applauded, they sang, they stood upon the seats and wildly waved their hats, they called Brandeis by name and made the heavens ring with their cheers. It was as though a hurricane, elemental in its might, had swept through them. And it was those few moments more than anything else that occurred throughout the Convention that served to create the new "Zionist Organization of American." The conferences, the resolutions, the constitution, the motions, and the amendments, all these but supplied the body; it was that historic demonstration that breathed a soul into the clay. The congratulations, the Mazel Tovs, the shaking of hands that followed were but the external expression on the part of the delegates of the new unity, solidarity, and mutual trust which had taken complete possession of all.

STRIFE AND HARMONY.

One may continue to cite instance after instance of the same character—they were plentiful in the Pittsburgh Convention—but let me record only one other of the most impressive and most touching moments in the Convention: = the adoption of the “District Plan.” Never had a fight been carried on more systematically and tenaciously, and never more fairly and honorably than on that memorable Wednesday afternoon. As the debate progressed it became increasingly evident that the “district plan” would be adopted, not by the sheer numerical strength of the Administration, nor by effecting compromises between the opposing elements, — but simply by a clarifying of the problem and its projected solution. One by one, some foremost leaders of the “Anti-district” forces declared themselves no longer opposed to the plan “as now presented.” When the final vote was taken it was seen that the Administration had won again by an overwhelming majority. And again the delegates experienced one of those rare moments that thrill and elevate. One after another the “conquered” warriors of the “lost cause” asked for the privilege of the floor, and with voices tense with emotion pledged themselves to stand by the Organization and its chosen leaders and to throw themselves whole-hearted and unreservedly into the heavy work of reconstruction which now lies before us. And to crown all, a motion originating with the “opposition,” to make the vote on the reorganization unanimous was carried by acclamation.

We, the soldiers in the ranks of Zionism, are now about to carry into execution the decisions arrived at in Pittsburgh. In our difficult work we will have the ever-present inspiration, the Great Convention, under the spell of which we are still living. We are strengthened, enriched by the priceless legacies of that Convention: solidarity, discipline, and unswerving fidelity to the Zionist cause and the Zionist Organization.

August, 1918