The Maccabaean
be determined upon, nevertheless, I felt that now, not only are the results important, but also the process, the manner in which the results are attained. Great happenings which have historic significance always depend on their manner as well as on their matter; and of this there could be no doubt: that the Joint Conference in Pittsburgh, as well as the sessions of the Provisional Committee in which there participated, even though nominally, representatives of the Mizrachi Zionists in America, are historic because whether for good or ill, the fact is that Zionism and its realization are now dependent almost wholly on America—or American help, American co-operation.
ZIONISTS MATURE DESPITE POOR LEADERSHIP
In my experiences during the "Pittsburgh Week," I must declare that as guest I had more satisfaction and found more significance than as participant. As a guest of the Convention of the Federation of American Zionists, I found with pleasure that the national organization had greatly grown during the past year, and that this growth was not only quantitive but qualitative, and what is more important, that the delegates to the Convention generated their emotions and devotion out of their own selves because, simply, they had no one from whom they might derive it. Ordinarily, at Conventions as well as at Zionist Congresses, there occur, first of all, sublime moments which awaken and inspire the emotions and sentiments of the participants for the whole period of the gathering and very often, also, for some time to come. At this Convention all this was absent, and perhaps the opening sessions on Sunday even detracted much warmth and energy.
To the credit of the American Zionists, however, be it said, that this unfortunate circumstance turned into good fortune. When after such an unsuccessful Sunday there came such splendid and worthy sessions of the entire week, it is proof that the American Zionists have become mature, they are able to follow their path even though their leaders do not illuminate it for them. And just because the greater part of the sessions were taken up with "dry" matters, and the delegates made just estimate of their importance, of the significance of organization in the present stage of activity, is proof of the fact that American Zionism is no longer a fashion or a side-issue. It has become what it should have become—a portion of the being, of the soul, an all-pervasive and matured inner purpose.
THE NEW OFFICERS
Another important circumstance must be mentioned in connection with the Convention of the National Organization, its new officers. According to my information of this country, and my knowledge of the situation in American Zionism, I hardly believe that better or more suitable officers could have been chosen. I wish, however, to dwell in particular on two of them. I mean, first of all, the election of Judge Mack as president of the National Organization. No one will object if I will say that the actual leader of the strongest and most important Zionist body at the present time should have been a man who is for a longer period familiar with Jewish life and more deeply articulated with the Jewish spirit. In the present circumstances of American Zionism, Judge Mack is undoubtedly the most suitable president of the Zionist Organization. In the election of Judge Mack, the trend of American Zionism was indirectly proclaimed, the tendency towards "open
doors" and broad fraternization, because Judge Mack is a man whose Zionism is not a sword with which to hurt, but a flower with which to attract. Judge Mack is a president who desires not only to "parade" but also to work, and to work in all sorts of necessary undertakings, big or little, and at the same time to attract others to this work.
The second choice which I consider as very important is that of Miss Henrietta Szold as secretary for Education. It is important because for that position there is needed—and this is not generally understood—a person not only with an education of the head, but one also with an education of the heart, and there is needed for this work a person who through his educational activity should create not only new values but also strengthen the old ones, who should not make a fetish out of education in and for itself, but should understand that education, in whatever form, it may be, is only a means to the end, and the end in this case is to create good, loyal and devoted Jews who must understand and value the past and strive and struggle for the future. Such a person Miss Szold really is. She is not only thoroughly Zionistic, but also deeply national, and may serve as a model of how in America, even a woman may attain to a knowledge and understanding and appreciation of the Jewish spirit. And it is also significant that in the "Zionist Cabinet" in America a woman is on equal plane with the men, a woman, also, who richly deserves it, and whom some men might take as their model.
JOINT SESSIONS INADEQUATE—THE "PRINCIPLES"
Unfortunately, I was not satisfied in those matters in which I was a participant. The Joint Conference, as well as the meeting of the Provisional Committee, were far from the high level where they should have been. The Joint Conference should have been a Zionist Congress in miniature. It was believed that those matters that could not now be considered in a Zionist World Congress should be considered and determined upon here in America by the Zionists and Mizrachists, who are here working together. To this end there should have been special papers to illumine cer-’ tain points touching on general Zionist questions in Palestine. With the exception of Prof. Amram, none of -the other speakers read any papers even though they had to prepare for it in advance.
It is true that at the joint sessions there were adopted the well-known “principles” which are supposed to make the Pittsburgh Convention as historic as the first Basle Congress, where the Basle Program was adopted. I must say, however, that of that I am very much in doubt, not because the “principles” are not good. On the contrary, I personally believe that a large part of my comrades in the Mizrachi, myself among them, are thoroughly in agreement even with the social clauses in the Principles. We are not even envious of the Poale-Zion, who are able to say that their program was adopted “en bloc,” because the truth is, that the Mizrachists are much more Poale-Zionistic in social questions than the Poale-Zionists are Mizrachists in religious questions. I have no regrets over the fact that the Joint Conference, in the five clauses, adopted the Poale-Zionistic program in maximum, while the Mizrachi program was adopted in the preface only in minimum, because I know that, unfortunately, the “general Zionists” always look upon the Poale-Zion as progressivists who cannot be kept pace with, and at the Mizrachi as retroeressivists who cannot be left behind. . . . I look
