The Question of Organization
JUSTICE BRANDEIS ON THE UNIT ORGANIZATION PLAN
(The following is an abstract taken from remarks made by Mr. Justice Brandeis at a meeting of the Provisional Zionist Committee, held Sunday, May 25th.
A number of us have talked the district plan over, including Mr. Kaplan and Mr. Shulman of the West, and several of us here. There are several points on which we were all agreed. There is one point on which we felt there ought to be elaboration. What I say now is merely to call attention to this point. All with whom I discussed this matter were acreed on the following:
www או = halite wee, US -+10 שקדרדוד * First—That we should have one central organization of which every Zionist in the country should he a member.
OE SI ODI EA AES Second—That this organization should have a new name to distinguish it clearly from the ——s. . . . various organizations that exist today. That is, it should not be Federation, or Hadassah, or Sons of Zion, or Knights of Zion, or Young Judza or Mizrachi or Poale Zion, but simply a Zion Organization of America. I don’t mean to give it that particular name, but merely to indicate that it should be an organization bearing in some form notice to the world that a wholly new organization has been created.
.--- nn nnn ee en EEE EEE Third—There must be a local organization to which members of the Zion Organization may locally-leek. The number of these local organizations would depend largely upon the number of important centers in which Zionists live. In New York, for instance, one such local organization would not suffice. In all, there might be need in the whole country of several hundred local organizations.
Fourth—There should be regignal organizations, each of which would comprise all the district or local organizations. In a particular territory, for instance, in New England, all the district organizations would be comprised in one regional organization. Now, how many of these regional organizations there should be and how they ought to be grouped, presents questions which must be worked out in detail.
There is a separate question in regard to them in which we did not get far in our discussion, as to just what ought to be the basis of co-operation between these larger regional organizations, and the central organization. That is a subject which requires careful study.
Assuming the establishment of this central national organization of the local district organizations, and of the regional organiza tions with the proper distribution of powers and duties, we have now 10 consider what the functions of the various now existing organizations shall be. Everybody who now is or hereafter becomes a Zionist, must, in crder to establish his political status as a member and voter in the Zionist Organi-. zation, become a member of the central body.. Thereby he will likewise become a member and vote in the district and the regional organizations, just as an American becomes a citizen of the United States and of his state
and of his city. And such membership in the central organization is essential to becoming a member of the Societies of which I am about to speak, his membership in a Zionist gate or lodge or club, society or association in which he may choose to express his Zionist interest and work for the cause. For instance, we have a society of Zionist engineers. They must be members of the central organization, but they may work in such way as they see fit, according to their especial interest, to attain as a special group Zionist aims. Others, all members of the Central Organization, will work especially with reference ta the Young Judea problem. Other groups will work especially with reference to the development of women’s activities. Others in relation to land develonment.
Fifth—To such groups as now exist locally or nationally, and, to such as may hereafter be formed—to each will be given the opportunity of working out its own problem under its own management; but all in relation to the great end which the central organization will subserve. Each group must be certified by the central organization; that is, must be registered as a society, whether it be a local society like a gate or camp, or a national society, like the Order Sons of Zion today, which, I understand, has its camps in thirteen states. The order, for instance, would still exist for its special purposes, social and insurance; but it would pay no per capita or shekel tax. Instead, its members would have paid their dues to the central, regional, and district organizations. Its members would devote themselves to those things which especially interest the Order Sons of Zion, just as those who are Young Judæans would devote themselves to the kind of problem which now occupies the attention of the members of that body. The central organization would use these societies and groups for propaganda or for working out their particular problems, but they would not exist as political organizations, and would not do the business of the Zionist Committee. Each would help in its own way the work of Zionism, just as in the United States today we have political parties, societies and churches working for the needs of the United States and for the needs of the states and cities in which their members live. Our political parties have no standing in the sense of being a part of the government, but they are voluntary organizations of people, citizens of the United States, who are working to advance the interest of their country in the way they think will help most. The great religious organizations of America, some national and some local, are working at those things which they deem most important for the development of the country. Other organizations are devoted to our educational needs, others to professional matters—as our lawyers’ organizations and physicians’ organizations. Each one of these thousand and tens of thousands of voluntary groups is working in that line which it thinks most important or to which for some reason its members want to give their special efforts
on the things to which they want to direct the state. It is on the American form of organization that we are preparing to build the American Zionist organization. It will give political unity and efficiency to the Zionist government, and, at the same time, the fullest and freest play to the development within the Zionist organization of all efforts, be they political, religious, educational, economic or social, to which the members want to give their special thought and energy. We believe that this new plan will make possible the real unity and a real working together of all of the Zionist forces in the United States, not only of those east and west and north and south, but equally to those who put special emphasis upon one phase of Zionist life, whether it be economic like the Poale Zion, or religious like the Mizrachi, or those devoted to insurance, like the Order Sons of Zion.
The plan which I was discussing is a plan which does not look to the dissolution: of organization. What Miss Szold said about the dissolution of Hadassah may have contributed to a misunderstanding. Miss Szold came to the conclusion that the separation of men and women in Zionism is highly undesirable, and that Hadassah has served its purpose. But the same is not true of political parties. You will have a need of parties in America as long as we have a democratic state. You cannot possibly organize the people of a community without parties. We shall have need of religious. organizations as long as people feel that religion is a need, and particularly if they differ as to what religious beliefs will best satisfy the need. And so in our Zionist state we shall need both religious and social economic organizations. Our purpose is to simplify the methods of conducting the organization, but this plan is not designed to reduce the work of the several societies or to reduce the effort or to limit thé way in which their work shall be done. On the contrary, it is to free you from unnecessary hampering limitations, to release your energies and the energies of the various organizations, so that you may devote yourselves to that work without which our Zionjst organization cannot exist.
* * *
CONGENIALITY IN SOCIETIES
By MORRIS KAUFMAN
In the April issue of THE MACCABAEAN there was an editorial on reorganization; and a model constitution with an explanatory letter, also published in the April MACCABAEAN, was sent out by the Federation of American Zionists to the societies and individual workers, discussion on which was invited.
The proposed constitution, among other innovations, calls for the creation of District Organizations, and only such hodies would be , recognized by the Federation. While not prohibiting the existence of individual societies this constitution prescribes such a lot of regulations and formalities, as will make their carrying on of Zionist work well nigh