Zionism and Our Reform Rabbinate
By RABBI MAX. HELLER
THE attitude of American Reform Rabbis towards the Zionist movement during these twenty years of its existence presents a complicated bit of psychology which I have neither the ability nor the time to more than sketch in its barest outlines. To the student of human nature it appears, on the one hand, as a mere confused mosaic of personal equations; on the other hand, as a shifting and changing of philosophical tendencies and historical currents. While you are viewing mental processes in familiar individuals, you see the results largely in terms of personal temperament and inborn predilection, or else of despotic environment; once you compare and classify, you become aware of the pendulations of conservatism and progress, of the play of natural law, of the effect of growth and stagnation.
ea A ee aa ee When Zionism first appeared, it aroused the strong (but not intolerant) opposition of Dr. Isaac M. Wise and won the enthusiastic adherence of Drs. Bernard Felsenthal and Gustave Gottheil. All of them were consistent and ardent followers of Reform Judaism; all of them patriotic American citizens. Of the three, Dr. Felsenthal had stood nearest to the great. German protagonists of Reform; of the three, Dr. Wise had laid the most powerful stress on the Americanization of Judaism, though Dr. Gottheil had been an active factor in the social, civic and human activities of the metropolis. To Dr. Wise the philosophy of Zionism spelled heresy against his 1848 cosmopolitanism; he expected the world to embrace Judaism within a half century; he refused to see any significance in the persistence and ~steady expansion of prejudice; he viewed the question altogether on its occidental side. Dr. Felsenthal and Dr. Gottheil arrived at Zionism from opposite directions; the former saw Judaism as a psychological phenomenon, a national consciousness which must be re-rooted in a soil; the latter kindled to the Zionist vision along the sentimental and sympathetic side of his personality. There were other prominent Reform rabbis whose Anti-Zionism was due, principally, to their German rearing, to their affiliations with the German Reformers and to their own intellectual or temperamental inability to modify outworn dogma in deference to new facts and developments; still others who were “practical” enough to discern intuitively that an idealistic movement of this kind, supported largely by “dreamers” and by the masses of the poor, was certain to meet with the scorn of the “hard-headed” business-man and to arouse the apprehensions of the blatant patriot.
Dr. Wise lived only for three years after the rise of Zionism. In the course of that brief time he was instrumental in having the rabbinical convention of Montreal and the congregational council at Richmond adopt vehement Anti-Zionist resolutions which met with no opposition whatever; in the seminary, however, of which he was the founder and animating spirit, he exercised not the slightest pressure upon the three or four professors who favored Zionism; on the contrary, with his inborn liberality, he extended to one of them the opportunity for championing Zionism in the Conference year-book.
By the time Dr. Wise's successor came to the helm of the seminary, the situation had begun to change. Meantime
some alumni had returned, from postgraduate courses in Germany, strongly impregnated with Zionist enthusiasm; as the proportion of Russian-born or Russian-descended pupils steadily rose in the college (one recent graduating class was altogether of East-European derivation), as Zionism became more aggressive, a clash was bound to come: three Zionist professors severed their connection with the institution. Since then, Zionism in the Hebrew Union College has led a precarious, largely subterranean, existence. The frowning-down policy from above has naturally tended to make it tempting, as forbidden fruit, to the rebellious, to commend it to the mentally independent, among the students; on the other hand, to the obsequious, to those ambitious for favor and recognition it served as a pointed hint with regard to the exercise of discretion. There are still men on the teaching staff whose sympathies are with Zionism; but these sympathies are kept under prudent restraint. Some three or four years ago some of the students committed a breach of discipline, when they felt that their academic liberty had been curtailed, in connection with a Zionist speaker; as a consequence, a modus vivendi was devised by which Zionists and Zionism secured certain limited rights of presentation by and before the students. It is possible that in recent years a majority of the students has inclined towards Zionism; in fairness it must be conceded that numbers of them abandon their Zionist ideals after the rude contact with the world of matter-of-fact people and of ruthless competition.
I have hastened ahead, in order to present a reasonably complete sketch of consecutive phases at the nursery of the Reform Rabbinate. In the rabbinical conventions Zionism was little heard of after the Montreal and Richmond exorcisms; a revival of interest was not noticeable until the year 1907 (Frankfort, Mich.), when the present writer, by appointment, led a Round Table discussion on the “Compatibility of Zionism and Reform Judaism.” That the discussion of such a subject should have been assigned to an avowed Zionist, that the same convention should, then, have elected him Vice-President of the Conference, even while he was, at the same time, Honorary Vice-President of the Zionist Federation, will go far towards proving the almost complete absence of partisan animosity at the time. The temper of the discussion, though participated in by the bitterest opponents of Zionism, was altogether unruffled and amicable.
Two years later, when the present writer was to be elected to the Presidency of the Conference, the waves began to run higher. There were desultory protests against the policy of entrusting the leadership of a Reform Rabbinical conference to a Zionist of conservative leanings. There was an abortive attempt to muzzle the candidate as to Zionism, by private understanding; after his election there were a few resignations, largely colored by private motives; but these temporary ripples were soon smoothed, when it was found that there was no disposition, on his part, to hurl Zionist firebrands into a peaceable assembly.
A rather unexpected and, in a way, amusing incident was furnished at the first convention under Zionist presidency (at Charlevoix, Mich.) by the noble liberalism of one of