The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 5 · May 1918
30printed page
scan 8 of 24
Facsimile · scan 8 of 24
Scan of p. 30
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabaean

every citizen should share in it—share in building the nation's roads, digging the nation's irrigation ditches, shoveling the nation's coal, and so on. Just as there should not be a citizen who at one time or another in the course of his or her school life has not served as policeman and soldier, so there should not be a citizen who at one time or another in his or her school life has not shared in the basic economic activities of the Commonwealth. After school, whatever enterprise or profession is desirable or fit: during school, participation in the indispensable basic activities of the Commonwealth.

5. THE SOCIAL CONTROL OF THE GOVERNMENT OF COMMONWEALTH.

The Commonwealth, then, is to guarantee "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" to its citizens by the national ownership of land, natural resources, machinery of transportation and communication, by the maintenance of the foregoing system of defense and education, and of free co-operative national associations of arts, crafts and professions.

(a) The administration of its government should be in the hands of a group of presidents or chairmen of these national associations of physicians, of teachers, of engineers, of cotton-weavers, of farmers, of oil-makers and so on, duly elected by these associations. At their head would be the president of the Commonwealth, elected by the whole people. The administration would be responsible both to the president and to their several associations. But that responsibility would be inadequate. Human nature being what it is, each association would tend to constitute a vested interest, with a disposition to grow at the expense of its peers. To check this disposition and to keep in the foreground the interest of the Commonwealth as a whole, it will be needful to provide a parliament of a single chamber. The members of this parliament should, like the president, be elected by a majority of all the voters of the nation, but for a period of three years, adequate representation for minorities being, of course, provided for. The president should be elected for a period of seven years and serve only one term. Parliament, however, should serve for no fixed period, but should be required as in England, to go before the country at a general election whenever any issue arises between it and the administration. The important thing is to keep government as flexibly responsive to the public will as possible. The party system of democracies tends to attain such flexibility, but party shibboleths make for rigidity in party alignments. In a Commonwealth, the only issues that can arise, are of measures designed to attain a public end. Wherever a conflict occurs among a people’s representatives concerning a measure, the safe democratic thing to do is to refer it to the people themselves. That is all there is to the “referendum” and the English method of using it is the most successful history knows. Legislative initiative, of course, should also be provided for. A given proportion of the citizens of the commonwealth should have the right to procure legislative consideration of any measure they agree on. .Natives, men and women, who have passed the age of twenty-one are, of course, citizens de facto; and arrangements for the naturalization of citizens de jure can be made according to conditions in the land.

(b) The final element in social control is, naturally, absolute publicity with respect to all the Commonwealth's affairs—its finances, its public works, its defensive and educational system, its foreign affairs. Similar publicity must be required of all the autonomous co-operative associations of which the commonwealth will be a confederation. Without it, the citizens are blind and injustice is inevitable.

6. RESIDUAL PROBLEMS.

Such, if the experience of the past have any meaning, should be the political and economic structure of the New Zion. The indispensable common work of the land will be performed by all men and women in common. Special aptitudes, talents, powers, and the spontaneity of which all human beings possess a spark, will receive the fullest opportunity for development, perfection and service by means of the national system of education, wherein all the children of the state will start on the same level, unhandicapped by the differences of wealth and position that elsewhere vitiate the freest systems. By the organization of national associations of industries, arts, crafts and professions, on an autonomous, democratic and co-operative basis, each association being charged with responsibility for the policy and progress of the industry or craft, an industrial democracy will be created in which initiative and team-play will re-enforce one another. By keeping the agencies of government flexibly responsive to the direct suffrage of men and women by means of the referendum and the initiative, by securing the rights of minorities through proportional representation, political democracy will be safe. And the educational system and the diversion of all social surplus from private to public ends will secure social equality and encourage diversification of individuality.

Many points, particularly the detailed elaboration of the program here proposed, could not be touched on. Others, like the organization of the courts, the handling of offenders, the machinery of national finance, are corollary to the program, and their patterns will get specific determination from circumstances. Still others, like the definition of the conditions of citizenship in the New Zion, of the relation of the Commonwealth with its immediate neighbors and the protecting powers, must wait upon events. At present, the concern is with the indispensable minima which a democratic Peace Conference will demand. The program here offered aims to define these minima.

Between the time of their full establishment and their beginnings a long period may elapse—perhaps a generation —of transition and preparation. During this period the administration of the Jewish homeland may be in the hands of a municipal chartered company or of a board of trustees. A program is necessary to limit and determine their action. Its most inexorably needful item is that concerning ‘the educational system under which the first generation of the citizens of the New Zion will grow up. Take care of education, says Plato, and education will take care of everything else. Whatever events may bring, the secret of its alteration or perfection is to be found in the school. The cornerstone of the excellence of the New Zion will be its school system; and if it fails of excellence, the source of its failure will be its school system. For a state is as its citizens feel and think, and its citizens feel and think as they are taught.