The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 5 · May 1918
44printed page
scan 22 of 24

The Maccabaean Editorials

American Patriotism and Zionism

THE argument advanced because the Allied governments are favorable to Zionism, therefore opposition to Zionism is pro-Germanism, is strenuously objected to by many anti-Zionists and non-Zionists. Granted that this argument is a bit far-fetched. The Allied governments may believe in national self-determination, but it is conceivable that there are Jews opposed to the self-determination of the Jewish nationality in favor of a Jewish State in Palestine. One may work to defeat Germany and yet not be in agreement with the plan of the Allied governments to liberate the Jewish nationality. But the situation reveals one point, which is overlooked by anti-Zionists. If it is admitted that the Allied governments have made the liberation of the Jewish nationality one of their aims, how can it be said that Zionism is not compatible with American patriotism? Political conditions make it so that the Zionist is working with the interests of the Allied governments, and the non-Zionists or anti-Zionists—within his individual rights—is working against those interests, in so far as they relate to the Jewish nationality. If Zionism is good enough for the leading statesmen of the Allied governments, for the Allied nations, an American Jew who is a Zionist is certainly not chargeable with being a disloyal citizen.

Change of Sentiment

FOR some time after the beginning of the war, the East Side of New York was under the influence of misguided leaders and theorists, who made clear thinking and straightforward action impossible. This blight has been dissipated. The Third Liberty Loan drive was a tremendous success on the East Side. The change in sentiment came some time before. But now it may be said without exaggeration that the East Side is at one with the rest of the country in devotion to the cause of the Allies. On all sides one sees evidence of this fact. Patriotic airs in the theatre are greeted with tumultuous applause. Speeches of the five-minute men are received with enthusiasm. The Yiddish press is unequivocally serving the cause in every direction. During the Liberty Loan drive, street meetings were attended by crowds, and all classes and elements of the population were actively interested in the success of the loan on the East Side. Mothers do not stand in the way of the enlistment of their sons, and the depression that was evident at first has passed away in the feeling that this is a war in which every Jew must have a share, and for which every Jew must make sacrifices.

Palestine Problems at Pittsburgh

THE work of Palestine restoration is proceeding under the leadership of Dr. Weizmann. The Zionist Commission will be called upon, in the course of its activities, to make important decisions, some of them of wide-extending significance. There has been no Zionist Congress since 1913. No Zionist legislation had been enacted which had

June, 1918

in view present conditions. Under the circumstances, we rely upon Dr. Weizmann’s judgment, feeling that he understands the national will. But it would be helpful to him and beneficial to the work he has to do to have, as far as possible, the expression of Zionist opinion on some of the broad questions he shall have to deal with. At the Pittsburgh Convention, some of these questions will be presented, and appropriate formulas of opinion will be articulated, so that Dr. Weizmann may know from us what we have in mind with relation to the general problems he is dealing with. A special conference will be held in Pittsburgh to consider the Land Question, Public Utilities, the Hebrew University, and other outstanding problems, that have had some consideration in the past, but which now demand intelligent discussion, general education, and the expression of proper judgments. It is this conference that will make the Pittsburgh Convention the most important gathering of Zionists ever held. For the first time we shall grapple with the practical questions involved in the building of the Jewish state. \

The American Jewish Committee

THE American Jewish Committee has finally, not without some hesitation, adjusted itself to the facts of Jewish life. At a meeting held last month, it gave its “whole-hearted sympathy” to the cause of a home in the Holy Land for the Jewish people. It expressed its profound appreciation of the British Declaration, and welcomed the opportunity it afforded to realize the aim as there set forth, “under such protectorate or suzerainty as the Great Powers may determine.” Attached to these sentiments are conditions that somewhat limit the broad sweep of interest expressed, which may be taken, however, merely as an attempt to adjust the new policy to previous expressions of opinion on the part of leaders of the Committee. Magnanimity should have dictated approval of the British Declaration without reservation, but mortal man has his failings, and the American Jewish Committee is only human. Having for a number of years opposed the principles for which Zionism stood, it could not now easily sweep all former judgments aside and reverse itself completely. We shall be satisfied with action taken by the American Jewish Committee in harmony with its latest pronouncement, and forget for the time being the interpretation it gives of its own resolution. The Jewish people are called upon to take action in consonance with the responsibilities imposed upon them by the British Declaration. Actions speak louder than words. The Zionist organization has assumed large obligations in Palestine, and is now at work solving the problems of Jewish settlement and national re-establishment. The co-operation of all who favor what is being done is sincerely desired. No one has ever questioned the probity of the members of the American Jewish Committee. Having endorsed Zionism, we have no doubt they will find in the Zionist organization opportunities for national service, of which they may be relied upon to take full advantage.

One-forty-three