The Maccabaean
defence of their ancestral soil. To be part of that Army is to be part of the first Jewish army since the death of Bar Kochba at Bethar, the first army proudly to carry the rejuvenated Jewish flag, the first army to be led by Jewish officers.
These Jewish Military Units may open up for us other national opportunities, of which it may be premature to speak, but any one who hesitates to support the enterprise shows by his hesitation a lack of understanding of Jewish national needs. He lacks the national instinct. He is unable to appreciate the fact that the Restoration of the Jews will be brought about only by physical and material readiness to enter any of the many doors that may be opened for our return.
Poale Zion In the Zionist Movement
F the Poale Zion were not pursuing a misguided and mis] chievous policy, on the outskirts of the movement, there would be every reason to welcome the Convention, which it has called for this month, of Jewish workmen sympathetic to Zionism. This policy is fraught with great danger for the Poale Zion as well as for the Zionist movement. It is creating discord, where there should be unity. It is arousing hatreds, where sympathies should be stimulated. It is complicating the problem, instead of simplifying it.
At this time to make Zionist propaganda solely and exclusively from the socialistic point of view, employing the slogans of the socialist propaganda is to mistake the temper of the Jewish people, and to introduce destructive elements. The Poale Zion do not appeal to the national interests of the Jewish workmen. They deliberately and intentionally emphasize the class-struggle, class-interests and class-hatreds.
Party zeal may excuse this attempt to enlarge the influence of radical opinion in the Zionist movement, but it is inexcusable to use this influence to separate the Jewish workman, so far as his interest and the organization to which he is invited to join are concerned, from the movement itself, thus building up an organization, which destroys the unity of the Zionist movement, its unity in aim and its unity in action. In Russia, the Poale Zion decide in advance not to attend the Zionist Congress. In the United States, the Poale Zion pursues a course openly and frankly in opposition to the general Zionist organization. This opposition has nothing to do with administration or personnel or policy, but it is a fundamental antagonism to the very existence of the general Zionist organization. It is Bolshevism in a new situation. It is “the proletarian government” as against “the bourgeois government.” Being in opposition, it seeks to create distrust, suspicion, hatred, all of which, instead of being directed against the common enemy, the anti-Zionist, is directed against Zionists.
This is downright folly and dangerous action. The Poale Zion know well that eventually they shall have to adjust themselves to the majority opinion in Palestine, and that Bolshevism will not be tolerated there. They know well that by themselves they are obviously unable to carry the responsibilities of the movement. Not to help the movement now is to hinder it. Dr. Weizmann is now in Palestine. Whom does he represent? He represents the general Zionist organization. Whose work is he doing? It is the work of the Jewish nationality. While the general Zionists in America and in England and Russia are supporting Dr.
Weizmann and giving him every bit of help they can possibly muster, the Poale Zion are busily engaged making capital out of opposition to the organization which is helping Dr. Weizmann to establish the foundations of the Jewish state. It is not the Restoration Fund that interests them, but the Arbeits Fund, and the Arbeits Fund is to be a weapon with which to fight the general Zionist organization. And whatever strength the Poale Zion are to acquire is to be used not to win success for Zionism, but success for the Poale Zion in a struggle with the Zionist organization.
Probably, they think that by being ferocious and foaming at the mouth whenever a Jewish bourgeois is mentioned, they find favor in the eyes of the leaders of the Jewish workmen. But this is an error. If the Jewish workmen and their leaders are to be won over to Zionism, it will not be because in Palestine the prospect of a fight against the capitalistic system becomes possible. There is a larger fight of this kind going on in America, and they are right here on the spot, and they have some experience in the work. If they are to be interested in Zionism it will be because they see a prospect of establishing a Jewish state, which will release Jewish national ambitions and national hopes.
i 7 77: שי ee יקיוו ee ees ו שיו . צ וה Ae ee קדו ייל קריק ייר Ses ה Unfortunately, therefore, the success of the Poale Zion, at this time and under these conditions, is not clearly a reason for being jubilant. We feel that this is a temporary Poale Zion aberration, an infection of mind superinduced by the Bolshevik tactics in Russia, and the Bolshevik policies that were in the air before the Russian revolution broke. As that radical party disappears, it is likely the Poale Zion will recover their Zionist equilibrium. Until then their movements will be watched with interest and good-will and with anxious thoughts.
The Maccabaean
Vol. XXXI
MAY, 1918
No. 5
Published monthly by the Federation of American Zionists, incorporated. Publication office, 44 East 23rd Street, New York. Entered at the New York Post Office as Second Class Matter. Subscription for one year, $1.50, payable in Advance. Foreign countries, $2.25; Canada, $1.75. Single copy, Fifteen Cents. Subscribers should notify us at once of any change of address.
