The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 4 · April 1918
4scan
of 29

THE MACCABAEAN

The Conservative Jewish Socialists

IT is no news to our readers that the world of labor, which is acquiring more and more power in political affairs, is favorable to the Zionist cause. This could not be otherwise, for the Zionist cause is based upon the principle of the rights of small nationalities, which has been accepted by all labor and Socialist organizations, even those in Germany and Austria. Gustave Herve, the French Socialist, is an ardent advocate of Zionism. Camille Huysmans, secretary of the Socialist international organization, speaks with enthusiasm of Zionist ideals. Labor parties in convention have invariably included the Jewish nationality specifically as entitled to equal recognition.

The stand of labor was best expressed by the Inter-Allied Labor Conference held in London on February 22d, where the following declaration was adopted:

"This Conference demands for the Jews of all countries the same elementary rights of freedom of religion, education, residence and trade and equal citizenship that ought to be extended to all the inhabitants of every nation. It further expresses the opinion that Palestine should be set free from the harsh and oppressive government of the Turk in order that this country may form a free state under international guarantees, to which such of the Jewish people as desire to do so may return and may work out their own salvation, free from interference by those of alien race or religion."

These sentiments are shared by the leading Jewish Socialist speakers and writers. In fact, every poet of note, every writer of importance, with only a few exceptions, all of whom are Socialists, are also sympathetic to Zionism, if not members of the organization. If a list were made it would include the best Jewish Socialist literary forces.

But there remain a few reactionaries, remnants of the day when it was deemed proper to be hostile to all things Jewish, who persist in their criticisms and partisan arguments against Zionism. They are all included in the group that is still in control of the Forwarts.

They are the men who are more orthodox than the Marxists; they are more goyish than the goy; they stand pat on all Socialist dogmas, especially those evolved forty years ago; they refuse to think of themselves as Jews, although every living Socialist today thinks of them as Jews. We mean the Jewish Socialist who writes and speaks Yiddish, who works only among Jews, who thinks only in Jewish terms and who psychologically and intellectually is a Jew.

In a recent editorial the Forwarts argues that the Jewish workman must be indifferent to Zionism because his interest lies in the class struggle and in his own economic welfare. The history of the Jewish workmen’s movement in New York is the history of trades built up by Jews—Jewish capitalists, middlemen and workmen. There was a time when Jews could not enter new industries, but had to take up only such mercantile enterprises where no capital was required. As Jewish capital entered and took control of certain industries, it became possible for Jewish workmen to find new avenues for their labor, to entrench themselves and through organization to become powerful. This is also true of labor conditions in Russia. The Forwarts has yet to learn that there are classes within the working class, and there may be suppression of proletarians by proletarians. Nationality is protection, and where the work-

man has the protection not only of his government, but also of his nationality, to a certain extent he attains economic equality; at least he is not discriminated against because of his nationality.

The same newspaper argues against Zionism because Palestine may become only another capitalistic state. As well argue against Polish nationality, because the state there established may be a capitalistic state. The Socialist party hopes to establish socialistic republics why not allow for the same possibility in Palestine? The argument against Zionism on this ground is premature and prejudiced. Zionism is not a movement of the bourgeoisie, or of the capitalistic class. It is a movement which engages the attention of persons who are interested in the group known as Jews, and they are all imbued with the same ideal purpose, that the state to be established there shall be expressive of the ideals of the Jewish people, grounded in Jewish tradition, but employing progressive radical weapons in order that what shall be created in Palestine shall be the ideal state in which the highest interests of the individual, as well as of the nationality, shall be protected and furthered.

We are not going into Palestine merely to establish just another state. We are going there to make possible the achievement of the brotherhood of the Jewish people, and the realization of those ideals of the Jewish people of which they have been dreaming and hoping for hundreds of years. Imbued with such motives, it is a bit of narrow-minded prejudice that brings to bear upon the problem the shibboleths of the Socialist movement in its conflict with the economic conditions in the western world. Maybe it will take the Forwarts another twenty years to come to the point where it is as radical and progressive as are all other Socialistic organizations. As it is now, it is the organ of Jewish conservatism, refusing to abandon slogans that were in vogue forty years ago, and which have no application at this time.

Notice to Subscribers:

If your copy does not arrive promptly on the 5th of the month do not assume that it has been lost in transit. With the terribly congested condition of the railroads at this time delays to the mail trains are inevitable. If your copy of THE MACCABAEAN does not reach you on the 5th, wait a few days before writing to us. By that time it will probably be in your hands.

CONTENTS

THE FIRST PASSOVER OF LIBERATION93
THE MONTH94
CONSTITUTIONAL FOUNDATIONS OF THE NEW ZION97
AN IMPORTANT QUESTION101
AVI—MY FATHER104
THE JEWISH PYGMALION109
BEN YEHUDAH—GATHERER OF DISPERSED WORDS111
THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT112