The Reorganization of the Zionist Movement in America
The Baltimore convention of the Federation of American Zionists turned over to the incoming executive committee the report of Dr. H. M. Kallen on organization, with instructions to devise a new constitution which would reorganize the Zionist movement in America with a view to doing away with duplications and confusion of authority and jurisdiction. A special committee of the Federation executive committee, consisting of Morris Rothenberg, chairman; Mr. Abel, Mr. Lipsky, Miss Seligsberg and Miss Szold, worked for several months on the problem and recently reported a new constitution, which has been approved by the whole executive committee. It was voted to submit the proposed constitution to the societies for discussion and later to bring it before the next annual convention for adoption.
The District Organization
The fundamental change contained in the constitution is the creation of geographical districts and the recognition of only one organization in each district for all purposes of regular Zionist activity. This is based on the conception of a political organization intended to embrace Jews of all classes and shades of opinion. It is, therefore, important to make it possible for every individual sympathizer to join an organization which is not confined to either sex, age, social leanings or cultural inclinations.
Under the present “society” system, it has been possible to utilize propaganda activities for purposes of organization to but a very slight extent. We have been collecting Shekels in large numbers at a considerable cost and effort, but were unable to enroll the Shekel payers in the ranks of our membership, because of the lack of an organization where any Shekel payer could at once be fittingly placed. For the same reason we were compelled to allow the most successful and enthusiastic mass meetings to close with hardly any gain in membership, frequently even without as much as an appeal for membership having been made. The district system will enable us to enroll at once any man or woman of Shekel-paying age who is willing to join our ranks. Each one will be placed in the organization of the district where he or she resides. At our mass meetings we will make a call for membership and immediately assign every candidate to his home organization.
Under the present system our societies have developed into social cultural or religious groups, each of them appealing to a limited class of its own and thoroughly disinterested in the general problems of organization. In view of the limited choice for membership and the constant losses by removals and_ withdrawals, an abundance of enthusiasm and leisure is required for any society to maintain itself, and many of them have perished at that. The district system brings to the organization the strength of every Zionist in the district, thus enabling it to maintain itself easily and to grow constantly on the inexhaustible supply of human energy in the district. Such an organization could never die, after once taking root in the district.
Under the present system, members who have outgrown their societies, or moved to a distant section of the city or to some other city, are frequently lost not only to their society but to the organization at large for the lack of convenient organizations to receive them. Membership losses from these causes alone number in the thousands. No such losses will occur under the district system, since the district organization will be the "Society for All," which no one could outgrow, and wherever one may move to, he will find a similar district organization ready to receive him.
Under the present system the society groups frequently tend to accentuate social, intel-
lectual and other differences among the Zionists, to the detriment of the cause. The District system will make for the fusion of our forces, for closer acquaintance and a better understanding between the heterogenous Zionist elements. This is bound to react beneficially upon the intellectual and moral status of the organization.
Pe a Se eee לויט The small membership of the average society does not permit the employment of paid secretaries or clerical help. Much of the work thus remains, undone. The District system will result in large organization units, which will בב קת וק "ירת 1 ה ל וק 1 שיר tener SGD Seer) [MMe [ate
not have to depend on voluntary work alone. Under the present system the active member is not supposed to work in his immediate neighborhood, but rather among the elements congenial to those of his Society. Since those elements are usually few and far between, one has no sphere of activity in the real sense of the word, and many who would otherwise be active are thus condemned to inactivity. He who is supposed to work anywhere usually works nowhere. Under the District system everyone will be supposed to work in his immediate neighborhood, with no restrictions as to classes and elements. Thus everyone who has the least inclination to be active, will have his field of activity right before him. In order that the principle of neighborhood work may be fully utilized, the District Organization is authorized to divide its territory into as many branches as may be needed.
Under the present system the Zionist worker is frequently a stranger in his own neighborhood, in which ‘he is interested cnly in so far as it offers candidates for “his” particular society. Under the District system the interest of the Zionist worker will extend to all of his neighbors, each of whom will be a prospective member of “his” District Organization. This “neighborhood work” will establish close relations between the workers and the District and will prove very beneficial in all activities where the people at large are appealed to for help.
Under the present system our workers as a rule do not come in contact with antagonistic forces. They prefer to work among friendly elements, whether in or out of the district, along the line of least resistance. Under the District system the “neighborhood work” is bound to bring out all the antagonism to Zionism which might have been slumbering in the District, and the natural desire on the part of our workers to combat it. This would indeed lead to the “conquest of the communities.”
The District Organization is not aiming at the extinction of all Zionist clubs, societies, and other groupings. Zionist groups engaged in special Zionist activities may not only be permitted to exist, but shall also be encouraged and assisted in every way, provided everyone of their members is also a membez of his District Organization, which will be the only organization officially recognized for all common activities. my ו 1 ₪ הצ ד דר . ae
ihus, ali Madassah societies, the camps of the Order Sons of Zion, the Hebraic societies,
and in fact all societies that have some good reason for a separate existence, will continue to function, each one for its speciiic purpose, except that their members will be required to join their respective District Organizations, and pay to these District Organizations the Shekel, the Federation tax and the small sum of $1.00 a year for the District work. It will be noted that this places upon members of special societies an additional burden of only $1.00 a year, since the Shekel and Federation tax have to be paid under the present system as well. In cases where even this small additional burden will prove too heavy. a special refund oar enheidy mav he arrangced far
refund or subsidy may be arranged for. The now existing territorial organizations, as the Federated Zionists of the Middle West and the like, will in no way be affected by the new system, except for having to inaugurate the same system within their territories.
The small dues, in addition to the all-embracing character of the District Organization, should facilitate the enrolling of almost every Shekel payer in the District as a member thereof. Capable workers are frequently found among those who are unable to pay large dues. It is expected that the resultant increase in membership and workers will justify the small dues. The Palestine work and other extraordinary activities will have to be taken care of by special assessments or contributions.
The Administrative Committee
The Federation executive has had repeatedly the experience of working with and without an administrative committee. It is now of the opinion that an Executive Committee which meets only once or twice a month cannot possibly take proper care of the large and complicated affairs of the Federation, and must, therefore, of necessity either leave many things to the discretion of one or two persons in the office, or leave them undone altogether. A small administrative committee, which should meet as frequently as necessary, and may consist of paid members if it need be, is the only way to secure an efficient and well-balanced administration of the affairs of the Federation. In view of the heavy responsibility that would rest on such a committee, its members should be elected by the Convention.
