The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 3 · March 1918
70printed page
scan 2 of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

EQUALITY WITH POGROMS

THE representative of the Bolshevik government in London, speaking to a Jewish correspondent, admitted that the Russian revolution has solved the problem of the Jews in Russia. They now have rights and liberties equal to all other citizens of the republic. True to character, Mr. Litvinoff, like all Bolshevik leaders, deals not with facts but with his theories. The proclamations of the Provisional government announced the freedom and equality of all citizens, and the Bolshevik government accepted the precedent, and in theory the Jews now have equal rights and liberties. But in fact they are not free, and persons who speak of the economic revolution should know that the political and civic freedom of the Jews means nothing at all if the Jews, as members of the “bourgeoisie,” are to be crushed and are being crushed by the red forces of the socialistic revolution. The revolution threatens to become the destroyer of a large proportion of the Russian Jews. While Czarism made pogroms as a political measure, the revolution makes pogroms of even a crueler sort as part of its attempt to overthrow the capitalistic system. The news of internal disorder is too confused to enable one to see clearly what is going on in Russia, but whether the pogroms come one way or the other, it is impossible to avoid feeling concerned about the plight of the Russian Jews. As victims of the Red Guard or as victims of organized pogroms initiated by reactionaries—what difference does it make?

ORGANIZING AMERICAN JEWRY

THE response of American Jewry to the Allied Declaration has been more than satisfactory. The area of interest has quadrupled within four months. The Zionist offices have had applications for affiliation from any number of congregations, lodges, social clubs, all of whom, having been organized for other purposes, now wish to include Zionism as part of their program. The desire to be of service is overwhelming, although very few of the volunteers appreciate the difficulties of our problem. But it is a most encouraging sign of the times. In New York, over one hundred and ten Jewish organizations, including all varieties of societies none of whom have ever before been Zionistic, came together and organized a permanent conference to “enlist the moral and financial support of all Jewish organizations in behalf of the Zionist cause.” The Union of Rabbis and Preachers of New York is calling together all orthodox congregations with a view to the same end. There are thousands of such organizations in Greater New York. To take them up individually would entail superhuman efforts, for an army of volunteers would have to be had for the visits and interviews needed to get them to enroll. By having them come together in groups, this large body of Jewish organized interest could easily be diverted into Zionist channels. The same plan should be adopted in other cities.

THE "OPPOSITION"

WHEN wonder when the anti-Zionist rabbis—especially of the reform school—will begin to realize that they are beating their heads against a stone wall protesting against a victorious Zionism? They do not understand that a movement cannot be stopped by mere words. When a Jewish Battalion leaves for the Palestine front from New York, of what earthly use is it to declare

that the Jewish people are only a religious denomination? When the Allied governments publicly state that they are willing to help the Jewish people establish their national home in Palestine, would it make any appreciable difference should a thousand rabbis say that Jewish history shows that it is the Divine intention that all Jews be scattered? When masses of Jews are enthused and inspired by the achievements of the Zionist movement, will the words of a few rabbis avail to damper ardor? If our opponents meant what they were saying, they would have made a counter movement based upon a program of action; they would propose that the Jews become what they say they actually are; and they would not rely wholly upon the opportunities the pulpit gives them to deliver themselves of tirades against Zionism. Dr. Edward Calisch, of Richmond, preaches against Zionism, while in his own congregation leading members are interesting themselves in the Zionist movement. Dr. Calisch is in favor of a Jewish settlement in Palestine, but does not want to have it enjoy political independence. His zeal blinds him to the logical consquence of favoring a Jewish settlement in Palestine. If it has his sanction, why should it not enjoy as much political independence as it can take advantage of? Obviously, such an inconsistent stand will not make an impression upon his congregation, and Dr. Calisch will soon' find himself minus followers even there. A rabbi in Baltimore is using a weekly publication of extremely limited circulation to air his views against Zionism. These views are puerile in the extreme, because they ignore the living forces in Jewish life, and are based upon isolated quotations taken from books; as if one can measure the capacity or strength of a people, or guess where they are driving to, by appealing to the dead opinions of dead men. This rabbi naturally is chagrined to find that: his congregation is gradually slipping away from his guidance and joining the Zionist movement. But really, in the face of what is going on in the Jewish world, are not these men making themselves look ridiculously small by their feeble opposition?

The First Steps in Palestine

THE British government proceeds in regular order to carry out its covenant with the Jewish people. It is not waiting, but acts as if it intended without delay to give wide scope to the Jewish activity in the occupied territory. The Zionist Palestine Commission has been given its passports and a charter of action, and the Anglo-Palestine Company has reopened its doors and is now doing business in Jerusalem and Jaffa. The Zionist ‘Medical Unit has its permit. The government’s funds are deposited in our bank, and the intention seems to be to have the bank recognized as the only official fiscal agency for the remittance of money to Palestine; not only the funds of the Zionist organization, but all Jewish funds intended for Palestine. London will be the central headquarters, connecting with New York, The Hague, Copenhagen; and these combined threads of support will connect with Palestine through London. The Jewish Colonial Trust will be the fiscal intermediary for all parties. On the spot, the Anglo-Palestine Company and the Palestine Commission will act for the direct reconstruction program.

This policy, establishing beyond the shadow of a doubt the earnestness and determination of the British govern-