THE MACCABAEAN
moderates of Europe, regretfully rejected as unattainable by the liberals. Nowhere but at Rome, consecrated by the traditions of two thousand years, could the capital of the new kingdom be placed.
As a poetical aspiration, the age-long Italian hope of union and independence had been sympathetically viewed by the liberals and the educated classes of Europe, especially by Englishmen who, since the days when “Sir Thomas Wyat th’ elder and Henry Earle of Surrey tasted the sweete and stately measures and stile of the Italian poesie” had been closely in touch with the poetry, art and culture of Italy. English sympathy, as expressed by her poets, by Browning and Mrs. Browning and Swinburne, by her great politicians and statesmen, Lord Palmerston and Gladstone, and by her reception of Mazzini and other great Italian exiles, had been of the greatest importance in the completion of the Italian struggle. In the international conferences that finally admitted Italy into the family of the great powers, England’s voice and the weight of her influence were of paramount importance. Those who feel that with all her mistakes, England is the land of liberty and of free institutions, find it singularly appropriate that today England should be the means of conquering Palestine and restoring it to the Jewish people.
It has frequently been stated that Italian nationalism begins with the post-Napoleonic period. It is, of course, true that the beginnings of concerted action for Italian independence date from that time, but only as an attempt to realize a hope that ran through eight centuries of Italian history. The concept of political unity was not new in Italy and was kept alive principally by the poets and 6 littérateurs. Philosophers, poets, politicians conserved perpetually the remembrance of the black day when in September, 476 C. E., Odoacer put an end to the Roman Empire. Rome as the center of an Italian world bounded by the natural boundaries of mountains and sea, under a native ruler, freed from the dominion of the Church which, losing its simplicity, had lost its authority—this is an ideal whose beginnings can be clearly seen in Dante and which runs unbrokenly through the poetry of the succeeding ages. Sanctified by the pious associations of centuries, the movement took on a distinctly religious color. Curiously enough, there was developed the idea of a Liberator, of a Redeemer, of a Messiah, of a strong invincible figure who should draw to himself the strength of Italian authority, concentrate in himself the lofty strength of Italian ideas and end forever in Italy the domination of the stranger. From Dante on, the “Liberator” became a symbol in Italian poetry. Dante saw in the adored person of Henry VII of Luxemborg the “Messo di Dio,” the Divine Redeemer. Petrarca heard the voice of the Redeemer not from church or throne but from the Campidoglio. In Cola di Rienzi, the archzologist become Tribune of the People, he saw the liberator who would lead “the city of Rome and Holy Italy to a unanimous, peaceful, holy union.” Disappointed in Cola, Petrarca turned to Carlo IV, to Robert of Naples, to the liberty-destroying Condottieri, the Este, the Gonzaga, the Visconti, the Scaligeri, seeing in the power, though it were that of a tyrant, the power of the native Italian Prince as opposed to the usurping power of the foreign Prince, and proclaiming always the power of the Roman people to maintain its great inherited tradition. Disappointed at every turn, the Italian hope still persisted until it was fulfilled at last in the person of Victor Emanuel, who com-
bined in himself the qualities of personal bravery, romantic charm and Italian devotion to the national cause.
This view of the sacredness of the Italian cause was held notably by Mazzini, to whom the task of liberating Italy was of distinctly religious character. Everywhere throughout his writings, especially in his famous essay “Faith and the Future,” this religious character is marked. “The following little work,” he writes, “was a portion of that European Republican Apostolate I endeavored to substitute for the French Apostolate. . . . Its object was to insist upon the necessity of investing that European Republican Apostolate with a religious character.” “The Republican party has nothing to alter either in its language or bearing. Any change introduced from any mere idea of tactics would lower it into a political party. Now, the Republican party is not a political party, it is essentially a religious party. From the days of Spartacus it has had its dogma, its faith, its martyrs; and it ought to have the inviolability of dogma, the infallibility of faith, the power of sacrifice and the cry of action of martyrs. Its forgetfulness of this duty, its imitation of monarchy or aristocracy, its substitutions of negations for positive belief, these are the things that have so often caused its overthrow.” And again he writes, “Political parties fall and die, religious parties never die until after they have achieved their victory, until their vital principle has attained its fullest development and become identified with the progress of civilization and manners. Then and not before then does God infuse into the heart of a people or the brain of an individual strong in genius and in love, a new idea vaster and more fruitful than the idea then expiring. The center of faith is moved one degree onwards, and only they who rally round that center constitute the party of the future.” “God and the people” was the Republican cry. This distinctly religious understanding of the Italian national movement made Mazzini and his disciples unalterably opposed to securing through the tortuous ways of diplomacy the rights due “God and the people.” An Apostolate, he called his view of Republican propaganda— the duty of preaching a divinely ordered gospel not to be achieved by the soiled hands of European potentates, but by the initiative and the holy association of the people. True, Mazzini did not believe, as do some religious Zionists, that the redemption would be ordered without the intervention of man. Mazzini vigorously recommended revolutionary activity, universal insurrection of the people; but he opposed the political methods of Cavour as vigorously as religious Zionists opposed the methods of Herzl and the new Zionist organization. Even after years of failure, Mazzini was not prepared to favor Cavour’s methods of securing through the medium of practical politics and diplomacy the holy aims of the sacred cause. Mazzini and the religious Zionists, Cavour and Herzl, represent the everopposing forces of those who sought to accomplish their ends through ideal means, and those who sought to accomplish them through practical means. Cavour and Herzl believed in the practical, recognized way of bringing their national needs before the Councils of Europe. They knew that idealistic aspirations that did not interfere with trade rights and commercial treaties could be depended upon to elicit the sympathy and admiration of a small group everywhere in Europe. But they also knew that only as a part of world politics, from the determining point of view of self-interest, could the powers of Europe be brought to consider the national aspirations of small and unimportant
