moreover, a theoretic right to be so included; for the original promise to Abraham included the land from the Nile to the Euphrates (Gen. XV, 18-20), a promise repeated more explicitly in Exodus XXIII, 31, Deuteronomy XI, 24 and Joshua 1, 4. Any definition of the borders of Palestine based only on the text in Numbers and excluding all land east of the Jordan is unsatisfactory, as it is in conflict with both the theoretic and the historical boundaries of T.....t-k. 21]
But we are grateful for this study made by the late Mr. Isaacs. Its main thesis, that the area of Palestine to the north should be twice as large as we usually reckon it, may not have been proved by him conclusively and indisputably. But it is both interesting and stimulating and is worthy of further study. This further investigation must be based less on fragmentary descriptions of the local survey by travelers than on actual survey of the land; for, whether it weaken or strengthen some of the author’s identifications, without this fuller knowledge, further discussion must remain merely academic. * * *
YEAR BOOK OF THE CENTRAL CONFERENCE OF AMERICAN RABBIS. Volume XXVII, 1917.
The Central Conference of American Rabbis is an organization of almost two hundred and fifty American ministers who are pledged in greater or less degree to Reform Judaism. Its function is to confer annually and to appoint committees on Religious Text-books, Synagogue Pensions, the Hebrew Union College, Tracts, Arbitration, Church and State, Civil and Religious Marriage Laws, Contemporaneous History, Archives, Co-operation with National Organizations, Descriptive Catalog, Finance, Investments, etc., etc., which committees report to the Conference on their deliberations or activity during the year. These reports, together with the discussion on them, and the special papers presented to the Conference are all gathered together and published in the year book issued by the Conference.
The 1917 year book is largely of ephemeral interest, though the papers on “Love, Human and Divine,” by Rabbi Samuel S. Cohen, and on “Freedom of the Will in Talmudic Literature,” by Rabbi Louis L. Manor, are theological studies of more permanent value. A study of Heinrich Graetz, the historian, by Dr. Gotthard Deutsch, begins well, but degenerates into an exhibition of an eagle catching flies.
But one report in the volume will stand for years to come as a monumental record. It is that portion of the year book which preserves for posterity the debate on Zionism provoked by the president, Rabbi Rosenau, of Baltimore. In his presidental message, he asserted that Rabbis whose lips are to guard knowledge and from whose mouth the people are to seek the Jaw, have no place in a movement in which Jews band together on racial or national grounds and for a political state or even a legally assured home. In these words, he clearly denied the right of any Rabbi, both the Orthodox Rabbi from whose mouth the people actually do seek Torah, and the Reform Rabbi whose activity is anything but giving Torah, to identify themselves in any way with Zionism. In the light of the religious mission of Israel, he called on the Conference to publish a statement that it looks with disfavor upon any movement the purpose of which is other than religious.
This tenth recommendation in the President’s message was crystallized by the committee on the President’s message into the following memorable report: “We hereby reaffirm the fundamental principle of Reform Judaism, that the essence of Israel as a priest-people, consists in its religious consciousness, and in the sense of consecration to God and service in the world, and not in any political or racial national consciousness. And therefore, we look with disfavor upon the new doctrine of political Jewish nationalism, which finds the criterion of Jewish loyalty in anything other than loyalty to Israel’s God and Israel’s religious mission.” The readers of the MaccaBAEAN may wish to know who were the signatories to this report, which as recently as July 3, 1917, publicly declared that modern Zionism finds the criterion of Jewish loyalty in anything other than loyalty to Israel’s God and Israel’s mission. The list is interesting, including as it does both avowed enemies of Zionism, and some whom we had believed to be sympathetic towards it. The signers of the report were Leo M. Franklin, David Alexander, Henry Berkowitz, Hyman G. Enelow, Solomon Foster, Louis Grossman, Joseph Krauskopf, Joseph Kornfeld, Clifton Harby Levy, Alexander Lyons, Isaac Landman, Harry H. Mayer, Morris Newfield, David Philipson, Charles A. Rubenstein, Marcus Salzman, Samuel Schulman, Joseph Stolz, Joseph Silverman, Samuel Sale and Abram Simon. To almost every one of these Rabbis in Israel, the Talmud and similar sources of the life of the Jewish spirit are sealed books. The work of these Rabbis among the rich and assimilated keeps them removed as far as the poles from the throbbing heart of the Jewish people and true Jewish life. It is not to be wondered that this ignorance of Judaism and Jewish life gave its assent to that preposterous “therefore,” to that inconceivable adjective “new,” and to the whole perversion of Zionism which the report reveals.
