The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 2 · February 1918
55printed page
scan 31 of 44

THE MACCABAEAN

As soon as the National Departments all over the world are ready with their first surveys, they should elect a uniform number of the members of each country’s committee as members of the International Commission, to meet forthwith. This Commission would be both a deliberative and an executive body. Without too close scrutiny, we can see at once what some of the questions are upon which it would have to reach conclusions before any program

1. What are the Jewish financial resources in each country? ‘2. Where the burden is too heavy—as presumably in Poland? Where it is heavy, but can be borne—as, for example, in France? Upon what lands an additional burden may be imposed—as, we hope, in the United States? Perhaps other under- populated countries, Canada, Argentine, Brazil, Australia, where Jews have settled, might open their doors gladly to some of the Jewish war orphans for the sake of the potential compensation in the increase of intelligent citizenship. 3. Whether any but full orphans without living relatives should be removed from their native land? Whether keeping families intact and pensioning them is preferable to breaking them up, and supporting their children in institutions or foster homes? 4. Whether new orphan asylums should be erected for the children who cannot be transferred from their native land, and who have no natural guardians; and for the children who emigrate, but are not adopted by men and women in the new country? In view of the fact that the problem is one that will diminish from year to year after the close of the war, and will disappear altogether in a decade or so, the Commission may discourage the founding of new institutions, unless a type of structure can be discovered that first can serve as an orphanage, and afterwards can be converted into a sanatorium, hospital, preventorium, industrial school, or home for the aged. 5. Whether other destitute children are to be discriminated against in favor of war orphans and other child sufferers from devastated lands? 6. How much money out of the common fund shall be allotted to the countries of the second category—those which will still have large numbers of children to care for, even after many will have been withdrawn; and to that country whose needs we have left for the close of the discussion?

After the deliberations of the International Commission have resulted in the framing of a plan of action, the committee will have to prepare for the emigration of large numbers of children under proper guardianship, making all the necessary arrangements for their commissary requirements and transportation over land and sea. Perhaps railroads and steamships will place vehicles and vessels at the service of the Commission; for the plight of these poor children, so much more tragic even than the tragedy of most orphans, on account of the horrors they have witnessed, the privations they have endured—the helpless passivity of these little victims waiting wholly upon the mercy of strangers, will surely call forth free-will offerings. After the children who are

transferred from one land to another have reached their destinations, their care, as well as that of the children native in each land, will be entrusted to the respective National Departments of the International Commission. The International body will not, however, disappear. As Guardian of the Children of our People, it will continue to represent all Israel. Every year it will hold sessions of a Congress on Child Welfare, having power over the distribution of a common fund, and therefore inevitably having power to direct policies.

THE PROBLEM IN PALESTINE*

There still remains for discussion the problem of that land which we have not yet mentioned by name, Palestine, the land once ours, whose future may soon again be committed to our care, a land which, at the present moment, engages the attention of statesmen in England, France, America, Italy—even in Germany; the land of which an English publicist recently wrote in Palpctine:

“No power which wishes to be firmly based, can safely set its future against the future of the Jewish nation, and no peace settlement which denies satisfaction to the Jewish national cause has elements of permanence ””

Palestine has long been an impoverished country. Though not poor in resources, these have been neglected and abused. Only in recent years have the new Jewish settlements begun to redeem the soil, and to give a degree of prosperity to the colonies. In the cities, even before the war broke out, there was great destitution. Seven months ago famine had so reduced the population in Jerusalem, that children whose parents had died of starvation were wandering homeless and uncared for through the streets.

Since Palestine is poor in money and in modern agencies for social welfare, yet now requires both money and an elaborate system of relief to cope with its needs, should I not place Palestine in the same category as Poland, Lithuania, Galicia? Should I not advise that as soon as we can reach the children of Palestine, we withdraw as many as possible from that stricken land to happier states? Let us for a moment postpone the direct answer to that question. Let us first try to picture to ourselves what this now desolate Palestine will look like ten to fifteen years hence, if our plausible expectations are fulfilled.

You know that in recent years those parts of the country settled by Jewish colonists— forty settlements in all—had begun to undergo a remarkable transformation from barrenness to fertility, from poverty to varying degrees of wealth. Agriculture and_ stock-raising, forestry and the arts and crafts, were prospering; new markets had been opened up to the trade of the country. New roads, a few new and beautiful suburban villages, had been built by these Jews; kindergartens, schools, high schools, an art school, a music school, a teachers’ institute, vacation courses for teachers, night classes for adults, formed part of a fast-developing educational system. Hebrew journals and newspapers were published. A Health Bureau and a system of district nursing were, and still are, despite the war, en-

* It must be recalled that this article was not written originally for Zionist readers or for publication in the MACCABAEAN. It was composed for a Jewish audience, consisting in large part of non-Zionists, in whom the writer wished to arouse interest in a national Jewish project.

gaged in energetic service. Interesting experiments in land ownership and in the distribution of wealth were receiving a trial. Palestine was no longer merely an old country, it was a rejuvenated land. And it is as a land of promise that many of our people see it. Whether we ourselves be Zionists or not, we must reckon with the fact that the Zionist program has received the support of England, and others of the great Allied Powers. Even Germany, to judge from articles in newspapers and periodicals seemingly inspired by the German Government, begins to regard Zionism with favor. Undoubtedly, after the war, perhaps even before the war ends, if avenues of entry into the land are opened to us, there will be a great influx of young Jews into Palestine; capital, too, will flow into the land, because it is rich in resources that remained undeveloped for reasons no longer likely to he affeartiva

The war benefited Palestine economically in one respect, in that new railroads have been constructed, connecting places that were not linked before. In the course of adding to the Hedjaz Railway, seven rivers that can be used as sources of energy were discovered in the Damascus Valley. There are now electric light and other electrical conveniences in that neighborhood, as also in some parts of southern Syria. Waterfalls near Jaffa promise a source of power for the Jaffa-Jerusalem Railway and the lighting of surrounding districts. Many ship-owners sent their vessels to Palestine before the war broke out; France sent her ships, and the German Levant Line, an Anglo-Egyptian line, and the Compagnie Russe were in regular communication with the country (Palestine, Vol. II, No. 9, pp. 67-69). We Jews may well be hopeful for the future of Palestine, if we take its development during the last fifteen years preceding the war as a gauge of what may happen in the next fifteen years, remembering that whatever was done in the past was accomplished against frightful odds, for the most part by Ghetto Jews unused to physical toil, and that in the future, however hard the pioneer work will be, it will be incomparably easier than the task of the firstcomers. In our days communities develop quickly. How long ago is it that Alaska was to our imaginations only a desolate stretch of ice and snow? In fifteen years after the war ends, Palestine may be a land plentifully reafforested, rich in farms and ranches, factories and mines, garden cities and mercantile centers. It will pulse with life, but: it will not be like any other land we know; for other countries have grown just as they chanced to grow; but the development of Palestine will be according to plans made with foresight, guarding against the misuse of natural resources, providing for posterity by conserving and creating forests where trees are needed, and cultivating the various products of the earth only where the soil and climatic conditions are favorable, preventing unconditional private ownership of land, safeguarding the community against exploitation by individuals—founding the Judenstaat on social justice. These are the ideals that animated the Jews of the new settlements, and this is the vision that inspires those who wish to go to Palestine at the conclusion of the war.