The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 2 · February 1918
54printed page
scan 30 of 44
Facsimile · scan 30 of 44
Scan of p. 54
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

must already have a greater burden than we shall be called upon to bear in the maintenance and education of war orphans; we may have to help them with money, and earnestly hope that —as I shall attempt to show later on—we may be reciprocally helpful with ideas; but, otherwise, the people of all the countries of the group I placed in the first category, the socially resourceful countries, will probably be able to provide for all their children within the bounds of their own land. It is not so with the countries of the second group, Russia, Poland, Galicia, Serbia, Roumania, etc. These are not likely to be able, even with grants of money from outside sources, to provide proper refuge and maintenance for all the orphaned Jewish children within their own bounds.

THE PROBLEM IN POLAND AND OTHER COUNTRIES OF THE SECOND GROUP

We know that, before the war broke out, about half the Jews of the world lived in those regions that now, equally with Belgium and northern France, have suffered devastation indescribable. Communities have been scattered or completely demolished. Children by the thousand have been left wandering in the forests and on the mountains. In some places they have been gathered into so-called schools —schools that are hardly more than shelters and feeding-stations. In Warsaw, out of ninety thousand children, only twenty-one thousand have homes (Am. Jew. Chron., Nov. 16, 1917). Must we wait until the war is over before we set our minds to work upon the problem of how to help them, and before we act energetically toward its solution? It is true that we have been sending money for the relief of Jewish war sufferers to Russia and Poland and elsewhere. But, even if we contributed every dollar that is needed, I doubt whether these countries could adjust themselves quickly enough to care for all their orphaned children. Before communities could be reconstructed, so as to bear the entire strain of caring for all their unproductive social elements, the aged, the wounded, the sick, the insane, the incompetent, the children —before that time the children would have perished. You in Baltimore know what it meant to rebuild a part of the city that had been destroyed by fire. Other cities—San Francisco, Salem, Dayton—have had similar experiences. But all of these had highly organized relief brought to them at once. Nor were all their own existing agencies destroyed. The identity, the civic personality, of these cities was not lost; and the normal condition of the whole country helped to restore them to comparative well-being. But, suppose towns and villages to be wiped out or held by enemies; suppose the whole country to be in a desperate condition, sometimes in a state of anarchy. Money alone, and wise plans added to money, would not then solve the problem of what to do with those for whom there was no shelter, no proper environment, no means of education.

I am not about to propose that from any country the entire burden or even its major part be removed. Looking at the world as a whole, however, and correlating this particular problem to the needs of humanity and to the needs of the Jewish people, I am led to the conclusion that one of the things we must do is to remove at least some of the orphaned Jewish children from lands that are not now equipped to care for them. Some such transporting of children has already taken place.

A few days after the outbreak of the war, the National Association for War Orphans was organized in France. In May, 1915, it admitted motherless children of mobilized Italians resident in France, but in November of that year, it decided to admit children to be brought to France from Serbia. It instituted a system of placing ten children in one household, preferably in the home of a war widow, having regard to the grouping and placing of children according to religion. This immigration of Serbian children was, of course, on a comparatively small scale. But that it is possible to move children from place to place in large numbers is borne out by the fact that over one million children were moved from Berlin and other large German cities to rural regions for the summer of 1917. The maximum board paid was 12 cents a day; there were many free homes. Families caring for the children received testimonials for patriotic service (Survey, June 23, 1917). This does not help us to solve our own problem; it merely encourages us to see what we can do. "Which children shall we transport, and whither shall we bring them, and how are we going to do it?" you will ask. Before I attempt to answer these questions, and before I proceed to a discussion of the relief measures I would apply in the country placed in the third category, I must spend some time in explaining exactly what I had in mind when, at the beginning of this paper, I referred to a possible "instrument of salvation."

THE TECHNIQUE OF RELIEF

I foresee at the end of this war a world-wide Jewish organization administering the work of reconstruction and relief; one portfolio in its cabinet, so to speak, will be given to a secretary of child-welfare. But, before that time comes, I believe that we, in this country, should inaugurate a part of his work. It seems to me that without delay an International Commission in behalf of Jewish War Orphans should be provided for, with headquarters, at least temporarily, in the United States, and departments in every country of the world. The initial financial support for the vast undertaking of this Commission would logically come from the ten million dollar Jewish War Relief Fund now collecting, supplemented by moneys collected in other countries, probably to be used within those countries for local child-care. The whole international fund might be called The Fund for the Children of our People. At once, the professional men who direct the leading child-caring bureaus in this country ought to elect a committee of their number to constitute the professional section of the American Department of this Commission; and parallel to this group there would have to be a financial section, consisting of Jews possessing large fortunes. In order to launch the work, the American Department should promptly enter into communication with Jewish leaders in finance and specialists in child-caring work elsewhere, even in countries only indirectly affected by the war, requesting them to organize corresponding departments of the International Commission. It would be the duty of every department to make a swift, general survey of the local Jewish child population, and of available local resources. It would have to draw up a provisional classification of children, into half-orphans with mother living, with father living, full orphans with some living relatives, orphans without any living rela

These first surveys should contain approximate numerical data relative to the groups of children and to the capacity of existing orphanages in each country, and of temporary shelters, foster homes, and adoption bureaus; also the extent to which the government and private aid are coping with the need, or can be counted upon to do so. It will hardly take long for the various countries to furnish these particulars, for presumably the facts are already fairly well known to relief agencies in each land.

While the information is collecting, vigorous propaganda should be made in America for the adoption of Jewish war orphans from devastated lands; and a bureau should be opened to which particulars about persons willing to adopt children should be sent, and from which investigations of the names of these adults might proceed. Thousands of Jews who were, for some reason or another, not able to take children into their own homes, could well afford and would be willing to pay for the support of a child in someone else’s home for a period of years. These, too, could register at this bureau. It would seem that a special committee on legislation and legal adjustments might have to be appointed, to facilitate the entry into this country of children for whom no adoptive parents could be found, but for whom orphanages and placing-out bureaus might provide. Possibly our country would admit these children in large numbers only if we Jews guaranteed that we would bear the cost of the children’s maintenance. We might be the readier to do this in view of the fact that Jewish immigration has been greatly reduced ever since the war broke out, and will probably remain at a low figure for a long time after the war, perhaps permanently. The consequent diminution of the number of adults requiring relief may partly compensate us for the increase in the number of children to be cared for. You may have observed that I said that the Jews might have to guarantee the maintenance of these children; I did not add education to maintenance, because I think the public schools may be reckoned with to provide the children’s schooling. I assume that, if adult immigration drops low, America will not be reluctant to assure herself of an increase in the population, coming from adopted citizens educated in and by America, A committee on legislation and legal adjustments might concern itself not only with negotiations with the government, but also with the enactment of legal provisions for a sort of semi-adoption of children. I believe there are many people, in particular many single women, who would pledge themselves to adopt one or two children, if only they could financially afford to do so—professional or business women who have pleasant homes, or women of leisure with only very modest incomes. Now, if such persons could have a legal guarantee that, after one or two years’ trial, a child placed with them would be theirs forever, that there would be no further outside control or interference, that they would receive “mothers’ pensions,” so to speak, from a placing-out bureau until the child reached a certain age limit—under such conditions, I make bold to prophesy that thousands of childless couples and of single women would come forward to take homeless little ones into their homes. The American Department of the proposed International Commission, along with its other duties, would have to prepare the way for such legalized semi-adoption. .