The Maccabaean · Vol. XXXI, No. 2 · February 1918
53printed page
scan 29 of 44

THE MACCABAEAN

of the sex. Possibly boys of a certain age thrive better in an institution than in a private household—as so many boys in England have profited through residence at a large public school under a fine headmaster. On the other hand, to a large extent, the question may be one of supply and demand. Though we should prefer the private foster home for all children, yet we might not be able to find enough Jewish private homes to accommodate all the homeless little ones waiting to be placed. Money enters into the consideration of all these possibilities; but the most important factor, to my mind, is social vision. If we want the right thing, and insist that this is the right thing, in the end we shall get it. It may well be that money would be forthcoming for the utmost reaches of wise and loving care, if our standards were sufficiently high.

You may be surprised to hear me say this, but I do believe that the chief reason why we find it impossible to secure enough money for social work, is that we are not sufficiently insistent on the brotherhood of man. We ourselves are not converts to the belief that all men, and certainly all children, should have equal opportunity. It is Jewish to regard God as our father, “Avinu,” but if God is our father, then indeed we are one family, and every child is our child. I wish. we Jews might lead the world in establishing the same opportunities and the same standards of care for the poor as for those who can pay; but, like all the rest of the world, we still base our estimate of what is needed for the poor on the hypothesis that they are different from us. This is to be seen everywhere, in hospitals, in homes for the aged, in the institutions and foster homes in which children are placed. Our attitude needs to undergo a great shift. We need the shock of realizing that, much as we do, great as are the advances we have made in social work, yet we still penalize poverty. We do not consider that respect for the individual, respect for privacy and comfort and sensitiveness, reverence for each man’s worth as a human being, is life sustaining; and its absence, as it were, starves a man to death. Much as we do for the poor, we shall never do enough until we cease to regard our work for them as a benefaction, and until we look upon it consistently as a duty to our extended family. As soon as we shall conceive of the care of orphans in this way, we shall bring our standards for environment, individual attention, expert supervision, opportunity for self-expression and self-fulfillment to the same level we reach in our demands for the normally placed child. The guardians of the poor make their demands on the public on far too small a scale, because of their own contracted vision of the duties of the city and state. I do not mean that money will be forthcoming as soon as the need for it is acknowledged; by no means; only that it will never come in the right measure until an inward change has taken place in the leaders of social work, and has spread from them to the whole community.

Therefore, when we make our plans for the care of the Jewish war orphans, let us make them irrespective of the money involved, Let us, for the time being, consider only the welfare of the children and the lasting good of the peoples of the world. Let us see clearly what ought to be done. All of it we shall not be able to execute; but our accomplishment should not be circumscribed

France even goes so far as to create an artificial family for children who have no relatives who can take care of them. In every canton of France groups of local citizens, men and women, who seem qualified to befriend or otherwise assist individual wards of the nation, are legally constituted a cantonal section of the national council for the guardianship of war orphans.

by the limits of a wrong and narrow plan. Our plan must be the great boundary toward which action will march out. I shall challenge opposition I fear, when I say: After providing the bare necessities (food, shelter, clothes) for all, it will be better to proceed to help five thousand in the right way than to give muddled, inadequate help to double the number.

Another fundamental issue in child-caring work is the question of subsidizing relatives to maintain the child. America has been anything but maternal in its attitude toward poor mothers. In this country we are often compelled by law, if we wish to draw on public in addition to private funds, to place the child in a foster home instead of leaving it with its own mother or some other female relative, and pensioning this relative for the child’s support. I know of a case in New York City where a poor woman moved from one tenement to another, in order that thereby she might be in the same building and just across the hall from the stranger with whom her child had been placed. Is it not surprising that—at least in New York—we are, as citizens, willing to see families broken up for the want of money, and yet are willing to spend that amount of money in placing the children of these families with utter strangers? It is interesting to note the attitude the French people are taking toward this question. I shall quote certain passages from an article that appeared in The Survey for October 6, 1917, entitled, “France Adopts Her War Orphans,” and written by Mr. Arthur W. Towne:

“There has been some speculation in our own country as to how France would solve its great problem of caring for so many bereaved children, estimated at some hundreds of thousands; as to whether it would probably be chiefly through emigration, the establishment of new orphanages, or the use of private foster homes. Unquestionably any scheme for the wholesale transplanting of French children to other lands will be discouraged; an earnest effort will be made to have these French boys and girls grow up and be trained for useful occupations and good citizenship right in their own communities among their own relatives and friends, just as their fathers and mothers would wish to have done. While the law leaves it open to utilize both institutional and placing-out methods (the committee reports), the debates and the action taken show a preference (in the Senate and the Chamber of Deputies) for the natural environment of family homes.”

“The essential steps taken with respect to each child who has been reported by a relative or a member of the cantonal section as eligible to become a war orphan, start with a hearing by a district court. If the facts in the case fall within the definitions prescribed by the law, the court simply decrees that the war orphan is adopted as a ward of the nation. With this pronouncement the duty of the court ends.”

“Within fifteen days thereafter, upon the request of the child’s surviving parent (if there be one), or upon an order of a justice of the peace, a ‘family council’ is convened.” ... etc... . “This council is ordinarily made up of the child’s close relatives; but, under the new law relating to war orphans, if any of the relatives are incapable or unworthy, the justice of the peace may exclude such persons from the deliberations, and may fill any vacancies by calling for delegates from the departmental office or the cantonal section. Whenever possible, the council appoints the surviving parent, some other near relative, or a testamentary guardian (previously named by the last deceased parent) as the legal guardian of the new ward of the nation. If such a course is impractical, the duty of making the appointment is referred to the departmental office, which may designate one of its own members or any other suitable man or woman. Thus each war orphan has his or her own individual guardian.” ... etc. ... “Upon request of the guardian a departmental office may place any ward in a public or private institution, school, or other child-caring or placing agency, or in a private family. Parental desires as to religious predilections and the means of education are respected.”

At a meeting of the Société d’Economie Sociale, held in Paris in December, 1915, a discussion arose as to whether war orphans should be accorded a special classification, and different treatment from foundlings, destitute children, etc. Who could not be shocked at the idea of assimilating the children of our defenders with these?” said the chief speaker of the occasion. Others dissented from this view, maintaining that all helpless children should receive the best possible care without respect to their antecedents. In England, too, the same question has arisen. At a Conference on War Relief and Personal Service held in London, in June, 1915, a select committee on military and naval pensions, in addition to recommending pensions graduated according to the number of dependents in the family, urged that supplementary pensions be granted in certain cases to prevent widows and orphans from sinking into a lower social scale or adopting definitely lower standards than they had before the war; and then the plea was entered that these methods and standards be carried over to the widows and orphans of civilians.

Enough has now been said to show the kinds of question we shall have to consider when the problem becomes real in America. Certainly, whatever influence we can bring to bear should be in the direction of maintaining natural family ties. In the United States, on account of the insurance of soldiers and sailors according to a measure of justice not equaled heretofore, we may go far toward a solution of the financial problem of the war orphan. Let us hope that here too, in time to come, the country will realize that it owes the same care to all children, whether they come of fighting stock or not. If we Jews in America could detach ourselves from the Jews of the rest of the world, we should say that, unless the war lasts a very long time, the care of the Jewish war orphan would not for us constitute a new problem of very great dimensions. In other highly organized countries, like France, England, Germany, etc., Jews