THE MACCABAEAN
VOLUME XXXI
Published monthly by The Federation of American Zionists, a corporation. Publication office, 44 East 23d Street, New York. Entered at New York Post Office as Second Class Matter. Subscription for one year, $1.50, payable in advance. All foreign countries, including Canada, $1.75. Single copies, fifteen cents. Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address. Board of Editors—LOUIS LIPSKY, Editor-in-Chief; SAUL J. COHEN, BERNARD G. RICHARDS and MEYER WEISGAL, Secretary.
THE MONTH
THE CARNEGIE HALL DEMONSTRATION
TWO historic demonstrations—one in London, the other in New York—gave striking evidence of the depth of feeling stirred in the Jewish masses by the British Declaration. The London Opera House meeting was participated in by the British government. This was politically possible in London. In New York, however, without official governmental co-operation, the meeting drew forth one of the most enthusiastic crowds ever gathered in the great metropolis. It was a people’s mass meeting, with all elements of American Jewry present. Several thousand people were turned away, unable to get into the packed auditorium. Inside, when sentiments of loyalty to the Allied cause were expressed, when the future of the Jewish state was described, when the sacrifices of our pioneers were mentioned, the cheers were spontaneous and overwhelming. There was no make-believe about the patriotism displayed. There was not a Jew present who was not thrilled by the sight of the Jewish flag unfurled side by side with the Red, White and Blue. For the first time in American Jewish history, the Jewish flag stood on the basis of equality with the American flag, speaking to the Jewish heart of a noble future, of consecration to national ideals. There may have been a doubt at some time of the responsiveness of the Jewish heart to Zionism. The Carnegie Hall demonstration put a quietus upon all such feelings.
A SPECIES BECOMING EXTINCT
NUMBER of our readers urge us to take notice of several discordant opinions that have been emitted in the midst of the overwhelmingly favor able sentiments that have been expressed anent the British Declaration. Such notice at this time would be in derogation of Zionist dignity and out of keeping with the seriousness of the occasion. There was a time when the retort courteous, or otherwise, was obligatory upon Zionists and Zionist organs. There was a time when replies to denunciation of the American patriotism of Zionists was an unpleasant part of Zionist service. We were forced to argue about all the implications of Zionism. By this argument we occasionally made converts to Zionism. But the time has past for such diversions. The man or woman who is not convinced of the validity of Jewish nationalism by the British declaration, which projects a business agreement with the Zionist organization, will not be convinced by arguments no matter how logical or powerfully presented. The man who at this time rushes to the press to protest that for his own puny
self he wishes to dissociate himself from the Zionist cause, from the liberation proposed for the Jewish people, with the hope that by his performance the attention of the world will be focussed upon him, will best be served by Zionist concern about his views, and only thus will he feel inspired to continue his opposition. To ignore such persons is the only charitable and economical thing to do. Our Zionist obligations are too pressing to allow of such diversions.
NEIGHBORLY GREETINGS
ONE of the most gratifying accompaniments of the British declaration has been the whole-hearted and sympathetic congratulations conveyed to the Zionist organization by Armenian and Arabian organizations. The Zionist organization will know how to express its appreciation of the good wishes of the representatives of these two nationalities, who are destined to be neighbors of the New Zion. It will certainly express its appreciation in acts of brotherhood and fraternal good-will wherever possible. Our interests run parallel and at certain points meet. We are glad of the prospect that confronts the Arabian and the Armenian peoples of having their national life established upon the basis of justice and fairness, and if it devolves upon us to be helpful in the realization of the aims of both these neighbors of ours, we shall certainly be found working shoulder to shoulder together with them in the field of nation-building. The New Zion is to be established in justice and it will be dedicated to the ideals of justice, fraternity and progress. Within the purview of Jewish law, of Jewish tradition, and of Jewish aspiration, there is a warm welcome to all nations that are struggling for self-expression and self-determination. The Jewish people will always be found on the side of these ideals, especially when they affect peoples who have taken the first opportunity in the process of our liberation to extend the hand of friendship and fraternal good feeling.
"DER SEIDE"
THE grandfather of Yiddish literature passed away this month at the good, old age of eighty-two, and his death is mourned by all who know of the rare contributions of Mendele to the literature of Yiddish and of Hebrew. Mendele was a product of the Haskalah, and himself one of the chief figures in its development. To his Haskalah turn of mind is attributed a good deal of his uncanny sarcasm, his irony and wit. He was a writer who indulged in caustic criticism of Jewish life,
