THE MACCABAEAN
the ages that it was somewhat difficult for them to understand that this new appeal should be differentiated from all other appeals; that for all other lands the Jews were being asked merely to make the Goluth bearable, but that in the case of Palestine they were being asked to maintain the nucleus of the Jewish destiny. The second method has only been employed under adverse conditions. It means the organization of the Jews through all legal methods, for the end in view. The resistance to the Zionist idea compelled the Zionist to fall back upon the task of organizing those who were likeminded in the Zionist organization and of establishing with their aid the agencies ‘which could serve their purpose. The attempt made in 1899 to bring the Jewish communities of Austria within the confines of the movement failed and the Zionists thereafter rested upon their own strength and developed their influence and power on interior lines. In this wise they created a strong organization, not as disciplined as doctrinaires might desire, but so much better ordered than anything that had existed in Jewry that it became a real force that could penetrate and did make itself felt in every Jewish activity. When at the beginning of the war it was felt that a trial of strength was needed the Zionist forces were tested in every conceivable manner, in every country, and events showed that if all Jews were not capable of concentrative effort for Zion, the over- whelmins maiority of Tewrvy was in svmpathv with it.
The attempt to gain the end by the employment of the third method, to strengthen Jewish national sentiment and national self-consciousness, being work carried on throughout the Diaspora, was better understood but being in some respects less tangible, was not unnaturally confused by the opposition with which the propaganda was met. National self-consciousness, aggressive in the face of this opposition, reacted, however, in every direction amongst the Jewish people. It was the expression of a tradition that had been weakened amongst the minority for less than two generations, and therefore the reassertion of Jewish national ideals carried with it the momentum accumulated during the centuries when there was no contrary conception amongst the Jewish people. Yet it is not the habit of the individual to reason out the proximate course of any effect. In other words, the Jews of all shades have become more distinctly Jewish during the last ten years, more interested in Jewish history, more conversant with Jewish problems, more familiar with Jewish literature, more apt to think as Jews. It has become more natural to assert the Jewish aspect of existence, even when the particular end in view is de-Judaization. Yet only the minority have understood what brought about this change in the general attitude.
As to the fourth means of obtaining the Jewish homeland by political negotiation, therein the Jews were hopelessly at sea. Hence, every Jew who might be convinced that some fellow-Jew might become a farmer in Palestine and might speak Hebrew while he was restoring the fertility of the soil could easily assume the attitude of declaring Zionism politically impracticable. The Jewish people have had practically no political experience. Exile, dispersal and the Ghetto were entirely against such acquisition. Without political experience there could be no political-mindedness. During the century of emancipation the groups of Jews who were enfranchised were more apt to support political parties that had aided them in their emancipation than to attempt to take the initiative in the political development of the states in which they lived. And so while a galaxy of great names can be produced of Jews who in the one century of emancipation have contributed considerably to world politics, almost without exception, if there be an exception, they lived and had their being, and expressed themselves outside of, independent of, separate from,