The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 11 · December 1917
15printed page
scan 5 of 26
Facsimile · scan 5 of 26
Scan of p. 15
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Road to Victory

By JACOB de HAAS

THE aspiration of the Jewish people for restoration to Palestine passed from the state of unquenchable yearning to the condition of practical realization on November 2nd, when the British Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, the Honorable Arthur J. Balfour, issued the following statement on behalf of the British war cabinet:

“His Majesty’s Government views with favour the establishment in Palestine of a National Home for the Jewish people and will use its best endeavours to facilitate the achievement of this object it being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country.”

Since it can be safely assumed that this declaration has the good-will and support of the Entente Powers, and, at the same time, expresses the judgment of the government of the United States, this declaration is the most impressive incident in Jewish history since the fall of Jerusalem. Indeed, after 1900 years it proposes to reverse the decision then effected by military power. The destruction and the capture of the ancient capitol of Palestine destroyed the political Jewish state. The human beings who had held together as a political entity were either massacred or forced into exile. That exile was followed by an ever-widening dispersion of the Jewish people. Their disintegration and final destruction through the many crises that they have gone through was only prevented by a desire for Y ations? reintegration.

During the last century, when the political emancipation of the Jews seemed to set the seal of permanency upon the ever-widening dispersal, there naturally came into existence a philosophy that accepted the statu quo and, following the rules of logic, abolished the theory of reintegration and looked for the culmination of emancipation in an eventual complete assimilation of the Jews as a people, leaving, however, the individual Jew with a varying attachment to that Mosaic code which has been the way of life to the Jews for centuries. Accepting for a moment the dispassionate views of those who cannot understand the positive sentiment for Jewish national revival, it is broadly true that no attempt to destroy a tradition—social, political or economic, religious, literary or local—could be carried out without a challenging protest. It is therefore a matter of natural evolution, from that standpoint, that the attempt to enforce the doctrine of assimilation provoked a reaction in favor of the traditional attitude and materially aided the Zionist ideal. Coming, as it did, towards the end of the nineteenth century, accelerated by increased sufferings for which no palliative had been found, this reaction took an organized form. Individual desires and viewpoints were joined together and produced the Zionist movement. The creation of that movement, that is the replacing of the Jewish chaos by order, discipline, and a definite and avowed purpose, was, in itself, the first real step toward the realization of Jewish national aspirations.

It is of course clear that in a period in which congresses became the order of the day, when human beings were getting together on all manner of subjects, when, having abolished the theory of autocracy, they felt that the only road to accomplishment was through public assemblies, the holding of the first Zionist Congress in

August, 1897, was merely an incident in the day’s happenings. And whoever was most strongly impressed by the distance, in time and in space, between the Jewish past and the Jewish present, could not but feel that those who came together to shape an undated Jewish future were, neither more nor less than zealots, with whom the wish was father to the thought. Those opposed to that congress, to whom the mere coming together of the Jews to take council and decide upon a policy was in itself an unthinkable act, would not permit themselves the reverse thought, that if that congress was possible of achievement, then all the consequences that should flow out of it were also possible. And it is because there are still thousands of Jews who have not been moved by the first achievement, that the natural consequences involved in the declaration of Great Britain comes as a surprizing, unrealizable and unthinkable idea. Therefore, as the curve of progress is a very simple and continuing one, in order to understand the implications of this declaration we must go back to the base from which that curve springs.

Dr. Herzl predicted his belief in a Jewish state in a pamphlet which he published in 1896 upon this simple doctrine: "We are a people —one people." Those who in 1897 believed it sufficient to make that doctrine the active motive for existence met at Basle and defined their common aspirations in the Basle Program, which in its entirety reads:

“The aim of Zionism is to create for the Jewish people a publicly legally assured home in Palestine.

"In order to attain this the Congress adopts the following means:

“(1) To promote the settlement in Palestine of Jewish agriculturalists, handicraftsmen, industrialists, and those following professions.

“(2) The centralization of the entire Jewish people by means of general institutions, agreeable to the laws of the land.

“(3) To strengthen Jewish sentiments and national self-consciousness.

“(4) To obtain the sanction of governments to the carrying out of the objects of Zionism.”

Those, who for one reason or another, set themselves up against this request for a home in Palestine, voted it impractical and impossible, paid no attention to the means of accomplishment outlined in the four paragraphs defining the methods of action. They were still thinking in the terms of Jewish chaos and did not realize that in so tremendous a chaos, any real organization reacting from the wishes and earnest efforts of patriotic elements scattered throughout the world could accomplish a good deal. But the Zionist organization, lifting itself above the chaos and seeking in every direction to utilize circumstance to gain its well-defined purpose, proceeded to achieve its end by the means indicated in the mandate given it.

So there grew up, practically unseen, the new settlement in Palestine, with its organized life and its Hebraic culture and its various experiments in practical settlement and colonization. This new Yishub, which was as a poetic oasis set in the wastes of the Orient, did not really make its existence known consciously to the mass of the Jews until the outbreak of the war. Then its achievements created a need, which having to be met with money, impressed itself upon the Jewish mind, and even in this we were somewhat unfortunate; for the Jews have been so accustomed to the cry for help throughout