The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 11 · December 1917
33printed page
scan 23 of 26
Facsimile · scan 23 of 26
Scan of p. 33
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAN

the segregation of the Jewish people," says "H. B.," whose initials resemble those of Rev. Dr. Henry Berkowitz who is one of the formidable board of editors of that leading moulder of Jewish opinion. But whoever this "H. B." is or is not, he belongs to that ilk who sneer at and belittle the polity of the Jews during the period they were making imperishable history. Indeed this "H. B." would have us believe that "the political experiment twice made in ancient times by our people were not brilliantly successful. Should a third experiment be entered upon we shall be deeply concerned that it evade the dangers and disasters which inevitably follow when political ambitions override moral and spiritual aims."

ambitions override moral and spiritual aims. Curious, some of the mental reactions—worthy of the study of a Freud or a Lombroso. The Jewish Exponent is vexed with the British government for overlooking that there are half a million Jews under Turkish jurisdiction whose immediate interests should be carefully considered. But, of the main question, it graciously concedes that while “it will not accomplish all that the Zionists hope for it, it will render it possible to show what a considerable section of the Jewish people can do in the way of self-government and the realization of Jewish ideals.”

But the most amazing reaction of all is the utter silence in the columns of the American Israelite. We have scrutinized threc successive issues of this one-time fearless and unfailing exponent of whatever opinion it represents on matters Jewish. but all that has greeted our anxious eyes has been the same old ponderosity on the same old insignificances. But on this pronouncement which, according to the American Hebrew, “the Jewish people everywhere were thrilled with joy” not a single line of comment. It is in good company, this nestor of Jewish journals—in the very best. It is in the company of the anti-Jewish Yiddish socialist organ The Forward which is also silent. But if the Forward is silent, too, the the columns of the most radical of them all, Die Freie Arbeiter Stimme, which never before permitted one friendly word to appear in its pages, opens its columns wide enough for one of its con‘ributing editors, N. Tobias, to say: “This must be conceded by all, whether protagonists or opponents of Zionism. Opposition had a meaning only in the theoretic realm of agitation and propaganda, but not now, when it approaches realization. All opponents of Zionism, except the stubborn assimilators, must acknowledge that they were opposed to it, not because the thought itself did not please them, but because. they doubted its practicability.” And with others who, like himself, having been so remote from Jewish life have now become profoundly stirred to the deepest depths of their Jewish hearts he wonders why the Jews, and particularly the Zionists, are not indulging in jejune, immature manifestations of joy. He does not realize that there are moments in life, as there are moments in human history, when one feels too deeply for the conventional manifestations. Is not this very serenity the finest manifestation of the great and abiding peace that the declaration has given to the Jewish soul?

How thoroughly the secular press understands the present moment in Jewish history is shown by Cesare's remarkable cartoon in the New York Evening Post reproduced in these columns. The New York Evening Mail acknowledges that the world owes to Jewry "this splendid repatriation. It will follow with the sympathetic interest the efforts of statesmen and philanthropists to make the age-old dream of the Jewish race a fact," while the Watertown, N. Y., Times sees in it an "inspiration to the Jewish people, feeling that they had a home of their own, Jewish in language and religion." Money and brains and energy will make it again a land flowing with milk and honey, and the Albuquerque, N. M., Journal even expects "that the temple will be rebuilt in all its glory." The fact that the Jews are not the preponderating element in Palestine gives the Boston Transcript some concern, but it looks for an ever-increasing immigration to remedy that condition. The New York Times is so perturbed over the prospect that it discusses the possibilities created by the declaration with a remarkable degree of unclarity. In its opinion multitudes of Jews cherish the belief that the return to Zion is to be preceded by the coming of Elijah, while other Jews giving due weight to the influence of national feeling "acquired in the disapora" fear that the Zionist project "might involve the possibility of the recurrence of anti-semitism." Above all it

is a matter to be decided by cool judgment rather than the impulses of enthusiasm. It admonishes the Zionists to study other experiences in repatriation, and concluded with approval of the establishment of colonies under the protection of Great Britain, France and the United States —a suggestion, it gravely informs us, that has met with a good deal of favor among Jews who have given consideration to the practical side of the Zionist movement. But the real humor of this remarkably muddled bit of editorial profundity lies in the fact that the New York Times which has never before been able to find any but antagonistic articles “available” discovers the Jewish aspiration for its readers to whom it now solemnly imparts the information: “Zionism is the name which has usually been given to it.”

The political perception of the Brooklyn Daily Eagle goes far beyond that of its neighbor, the New York Times, and its assertion that the British declaration favoring the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine is of "world significance," is undoubtedly correct.

is undoubtedly correct.“Most prosperous Jews in England and in France, as in America, would never think of going to Palestine to live. They are satisfied with civilization’s full opportunities. But even they have a sentimental interest in Jerusalem and Palestine, which, independent and largely populated by members of the old race, would get a place in the sun. And hundreds of thousands of Jews in lands where oppression has hit hardest need only a little financial help to settle in Palestine, and restore its agriculture, as well as its general industries. If England is friendly the scheme is more than half way forwarded toward accomplishment.”

The New York Globe does not expect that all the Jews will return to Palestine (indeed, only certain Jews believe that to be the Zionist program) "but the remnant that was never dispersed and has survived centuries of oppression will have freedom."

reedom. Space considerations make it impossible to give the gist of all the fine things that have appeared in the editorial columns of the Jewish and secular press concerning the British declaration and the realization of the great Jewish aspiration. But this is clear—that if the Jews will translate their prayers into deeds. they will have the good-will and the co-operation of the entire world. Already, the British declaration has raised our status: it has given us back our self-respect, it has given us a place in the family of the nations. And this, too, is clear: When the final test comes—when the hour arrives for taking practical steps for the setting of one stone upon another in the rebuilding of our national edifice, even those of our people who are yet making a show of opposition, will join hands with us and do their share of the great task man-fashion. The unity of Israel, the solidarity of the Jewish people—that, also, will be given us as Palestine has already been given to us.

THE FIRST ENGLISH EDITION OF The Congress Addresses of Theodor Herzl Translated from the German By NELLIE STRAUS

The words of Herzl read like prophecy. The noblest portrait of the beloved Zionist leader is to be found in his addresses. Here his spirit breathes, his soul is revealed. His speeches stand at the basis of all Zionist thought, and in them he has indicated the path of the Jewish people.

With Introduction and Notes by Saul J. Cohen Price, 15 cents FEDERATION OF AMERICAN ZIONISTS 44 EAST 23rd STREET NEW YORK

Four-twenty-nine