THE MACCABAEAN
By an irony of circumstances the Jewish Community which is most thoroughly assimilated and most completely denationalized—the Community of Paris—has hitherto played the largest part in the education of the Jewish population of Palestine, through the institutions of the Alliance Israélite. It was to remedy the economic evils and intellectual deficiencies which the educational system of the old Yishub fostered and perpetuated that the Jews of western Europe established a new kind of school in Palestine during the last century. A deep sentiment for the revival of Jewish life in the Holy Land moved the newly emancipated Jewries at the time. While the national consciousness was not yet softened by external freedom, the prosperous Jews of the West, under the influence of inspiring leaders like Crémieux and Moses Montefore, recognized that "All Israel is responsible for its every part," manifested a strong fraternal feeling for the struggling Jews of the East, and founded associations for their assistance. The Alliance Israélite Universelle founded schools for girls as well as for boys in Palestine, and in other parts of the Orient, which were conducted according to modern pedagogic methods.
As the teachers were sent out from France it was natural that the language of instruction should be French. It is true that the founders of the Alliance, Crémieux and Netter, had an intensely Jewish feeling, and were eager to foster a living Jewish culture in Palestine. No doubt that if the Alliance had continued to develop in their spirit, it could, in time, have become a source of life to the national-movement in Palestine. But their successors did not inherit their enthusiasm. The Mikveh Israel Agricultural School serves as an illustration of the tendencies of the Alliance. As far as the exterior appearance of this institution and its expenditures are concerned, it is interesting to know that the handsome buildings and cellars are situated on an estate of 650 acres, skilfully laid out with indigenous and foreign plants and trees. The school has an adequate annual budget of about $10,000.
_ At the outset the school was dominated by the strong Jewish sympathies of its founder, Netter, who was possessed by an ardent desire to bring the Jewish people back to its ancient land. But when he died in 1882, the enthusiasm died with him, and since that time the school directorate has opposed the national longing of the Palestinian youth. It has become more and more estranged from popular feeling, and less effective for its peculiar function. At one time, under a directorate friendly to Palestinian colonization, some pupils of the school actually became settlers in the colonies and the number of pupils rose to two hundred. The next incumbent changed the policy, and the attendance dropped to seventy-five.
It is interesting to read the opinion of one of the graduates of this school, one who retained his home spirit in spite of the foreign atmosphere which surrounded him while in Mikveh.
"Not one of my comrades was satisfied with the curriculum and policy of this school. The result of this dissatisfaction took a concrete form. Of the forty freshmen, my classmates, only fifteen remained to the end. Most of my fellow graduates immigrated to Egypt and engaged in commerce. In Palestine you cannot find one Mikveh graduate among the colonists. The explanation of this phenomenon is that the administration is demoralized and that all they do is futile. We had a smattering of everything and know nothing substantial. Two ideas have been implanted in the hearts of the Jewish boys: Assimilation, or rather self-effacement, and French patriotism. French was the only official language of intercourse, and
to speak or write in any other language was prohibited. When an attempt was made among the nationalistic students to form a Hebrew circle the administration suppressed it immediately. This policy of national degradation did not influence me. On the contrary its only effect was to make me more and more antagonistic to those who introduce foreign culture into the vineyard of Judaism."
The severest critics of the Alliance cannot deny that it confers certain benefits on its pupils. It has inculcated habits of discipline, order, and neatness; it has done much for the general uplifting of the girls, whose education has hitherto been almost entirely neglected, and whose social position was consequently degraded; and it has trained a large number of young men and women to useful occupations and saved them from the taint of pauperism and the demoralization of idleness. The trouble with the Alliance as with the other international Jewish philanthropic organizations is that it approaches Palestine with the same indifference to spiritual national needs and insistence on material considerations as it approaches the whole Orient, where it has its one hundred and ninety schools with an attendance of 40,000 pupils. In other words, it gives no consideration whatsoever to the world-wide national movement that has transfigured our people since the early seventies. In our national Fatherland, whether it recognizes it or not, the Alliance still maintains its international character in spite of the disapproval of the enlightened. Let us hear them speak for themselves: "It is true that the school [Alliance School] does not occasion an immediate change in the condition of the communities. But after a score of years real transformations are brought about. Young Jewry takes account of economic conditions near and far; it seeks to extend its relations and gradually emigrates to the more favored districts. Thus it is that the large groups of former pupils have not only organized in Europe and in America, but even in the far East. In the republics of South America one finds by the hundreds former pupils of our schools. In Morocco and Syria, in China, in the Indies, in Japan as at Bagdad, Paris, London, Manchester there are pupils from Syria, Constantinople, Jerusalem, and Allepo."
To shatter a house into fragments, to divide a household against itself, to scatter its children over the seven seas, to destroy the spiritual and national contentment of a happy little world, is an indelible stain on the history of the Alliance activities in Palestine.
IV.
The Hilfsverein der Deutschen Juden, or "Ezra," was established in 1901. Impressed with the significance of the Orient in the future of the Jewish people, it directed the greater part of its activities to the Jewish population of the Orient and especially to that of Palestine. It clearly expressed opposition to the spirit and policy of the Alliance Israélite Universelle; it began, particularly in Palestine, to work on the principle that it must adapt itself to the wishes and needs of the native Jewish population. In accordance with this principle its program for the Palestinian schools devoted more and more attention to the Hebrew language. It was aware that the Babel of languages prevailing in Palestine was a serious detriment to a good education, and that a single language of instruction was absolutely indispensable. It asserted that it found Hebrew to be the most fitting language for this purpose; that it was the living language of the people; that it was well adapted for use in the Palestinian schools and that it supplied the vital need for a single medium of intercourse among the entire Jewish population.