The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 10 · November 1917
88printed page
scan 3 of 24
Facsimile · scan 3 of 24
Scan of p. 88
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

the pioneers, the first out of the Goluth, and the first in Palestine—may not realize that his advent is near. To think of it is enough to make every sincere Zionist tremble and fear for the future.

We call upon every organized Zionist, every one to whom Zionism is dear, not to allow the time to pass in fruitless dreaming, in futile discussion, and in useless sentimentalizing. The time has come for action. The action is simple and direct. It is the duty of the Zionists to secure the enrolment of a large majority of the Jews of America in the Zionist organization as shekel-payers. These shekel-payers will be tied to the Zionist movement, first, by their endorsement of our aims, and, second, by their initial per capita payment. They will indicate as nothing else can at this time, the man and woman power of the Zionist ideal. Success in this direction will demonstrate, as nothing else can, at this time, the self-sacrificing zeal and influence of Zionists. We shall be able to show that during this great war, with so many subsidiary interests tugging at us, we Jews have managed to rally in support of the Zionist cause thousands and thousands of Jews who, in times of peace, were not with us, but who, sensing the victory from afar, showed their confidence in victory by joining our ranks.

THE MENACE OF PACIFISM

MANY are misled by the question, Do you believe in war or peace? There are few who would answer that they believe in war, and therefore they take the other horn of the delimma, and say they believe in peace. But the idea of peace involves, first, that the believer himself does not believe in aggression, and, second, that he condemns aggression in others. It is an open question, however, whether it is relevant to the present situation to be either for or against war.

All parties to the conflict have wandered away from the original cause of the war. If it were asked of Germany to take as its profit out of the war, what Austria tried to get from Serbia, she would certainly refuse to be satisfied with it. So, too, England rushing to the defense of Belgium, would not, under present conditions, agree to be satisfied with the evacuation of Belgium. The war has created new conditions and new issues. It has confused and altered all peace terms. To speak now of peace, a negotiated peace, or a peace through war, is to speak of something that has absolutely no relation to the abstract notions that are involved in the terms of peace or war. Every one of the fighting nations is earnestly in favor of peace, but the question uppermost in their minds is: What kind of a peace do you mean?

It is clear that unless simultaneously, throughout the world, there is a general uprising, and government is taken out of the hands of the governors, and unless the people involved in the general uprising are all of one mind as to the terms of peace, peace must come through conflict, and only when the conflict has brought about a different state of mind in one or the other of the belligerent powers, will there be prospects of real peace.

: A pacifist movement, under present conditions, in any one country, whether so intended or not, inevitably undermines the determination of the nation in which it develops, and renders that country weaker in the face of the resolute enemy. So, pacifism in England is regarded as disloyalty to the national interests. In Germany, pacifism is used only to weaken its enemies, but when directed against its own aggressive policy, becomes disloyalty, its Liebknechts being thrown into jail.

Therein lies the difficulty for Jews. Regarded, as of old, as more or less alien in spirit, for any large body of Jews to identify themselves with the pacifist movement is to arouse against them the hostility which the large body of the citizenship has in general against pacifism, because it is a national menace, and also the latent anti-Jewish feeling, which has not been eradicated in any country because of the anomolous position of the Jews the world over.

If this were a matter that affected only the position of the Jews in any one country, it might be treated as a sectional problem of the Jews living there, but inasmuch as the interests of the Jewish people as a whole are (unless a simultaneous international revolution takes power from government and takes control in its own hands, by international agreement), bound up with the interests of government as it is at present constituted, acting through established institutions, and according to present law, then the identification of large bodies of Jews with pacifism becomes a menace to the realization of Jewish national aims. If, under the present system, governments are to negotiate peace—even under the goad of pacificism—the fact that the large masses of Jews are found in every country under the banner of pacificism—a fact which we for one moment will not concede—then governments will certainly reckon with the fact, and regard the Jewish problem as an evil, which is to be dealt with in a summary manner.

It is unfortunate that in the Jewish press this point of view has not been sufficiently elucidated, and that so many Jews, forming their opinions purely abstractly, and from their own individual interests, are found fanatically favoring the various pacificist movements in this country. Especially regretable is it that they should have become parties, to so large extent, to peace movements that are, on their face, identified with pro-enemy propaganda.

THE MONTH383
JEWISH EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS IN PALESTINE386
POSTPONEMENT OF THE JEWISH CONGRESS390
UPTON SINCLAIR ON ZIONISM391
HOW THE "BASLE PROGRAMME" WAS MADE392
SISTER (A Poem)394
VOLODIA (A Story)395
SOLDIERING AT YAPHANK397
BOOKS—NEW AND OLD399
ZIONIST EDUCATION401
THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT402