The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 10 · November 1917
86printed page
scan 1 of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

VOLUME XXX.

NOVEMBER, 1917
No. 10

Published monthly by The Federation of American Zionists, a corporation. Publication office, 44 East 23d Street, New York. Entered at New York Post Office as Second Class Matter. Subscription for one year, $1.50, payable in advance. All foreign countries, including Canada, $1.75. Single copies, fifteen cents. Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address. Board of Editors LOUIS LIPSKY, Editor-in-Chief; BERNARD G. RICHARDS and MEYER WEISGAL, Secretary.

THE MONTH

THE CONGRESS

THE postponement of the American Jewish Congress should not disturb the many who have been waiting patiently for the day when it would assemble in Washington. The delegates have been elected, and their election has been certified to by the General Board of Elections. Nothing can be done to go back on the record. In fact, the delegates are the Congress, and between them and their functionating stands only the Congress Committee, which must, sooner or later, fix the date when they are to take possession. In the meantime, the usual belligerent talk should be discouraged, for nothing is so effective in demoralizing public opinion as the whining criticism of chronic pessimists.

WELFARE WORK FOR JEWISH SOLDIERS

IT is hoped to raise one million dollars for welfare work among American Jewish soldiers. It is said there are already about fifty thousand of them. The boys in the camps will need special guidance by Jews. Col. Harry Cutler, of Providence, has taken the initiative, and is now working with several volunteer committees. As in all Jewish affairs, necessary Jewish work is left to be provided by accident. No attempt is made to place the responsibility upon the people themselves. Everything Jewish becomes at once charity or philanthropy. There is no use, however, quarreling with Col. Cutler, who is doing his best to cope with a difficult situation. The suggestion of Mr. Schiff that the million dollars needed be raised in conjunction with the relief campaign is not a happy thought. The relief work is bad enough as it is without coupling with it an enterprise which ought not to be regarded as relief.

"OTHELLO'S OCCUPATION GONE"

THE American Jewish Committee will go through the formality of an annual meeting on November 11th, and we have no doubt it will be a distinguished gathering. It is said that the committee is being reorganized upon broader lines by including a larger number of members more equitably distributed. This is what is called democratizing the committee, just as at the last convention of the New York Kehillah the introduction of a plan for a fantastic hierarchy of bureaus meant the democratization of the Kehillah. But it is idle to speak of this matter further in connection with the American Jewish Committee. That committee does not seem to realize that its occupation has gone, and that no movement it may make can deceive the public as to the futility of its existence as an organization. There is

November, 1917

nothing it can do for Russia; there is nothing it can do for Rumania; the relief work is not in its hands, nor is the Jewish welfare work in the Federal Army, and whatever there is to be done is reserved for the American Jewish Congress, to which the American Jewish Committee is bound. When the Congress is convened, it becomes the successor of all American organizations engaged in international affairs, from that moment until one year after peace has been declared.

RELIEF IN POLAND

THE American Jewish relief committees are to send a deputation to see President Wilson to ask that the civilian population of Poland be given relief from America in the same way as Belgium was relieved by an American Commission. Conditions in Poland are frightful. Mr. S. Farbstein, of Warsaw, has been in neutral lands in Europe, seeking food not only for the Jews, but for the general population as well. Food cannot be procured even for money. According to the report received by the Provisional Zionist Committee (which caused the Joint Distribution Committee to act), it will be necessary to send large amounts of relief in the form of food into Poland, if the population is to be saved from actual starvation. One of the hitches in the way of sending food into Poland is the fear of the Allied governments that the Teutonic powers may confiscate the food for military purposes.

ENGLAND MOVES FORWARD

THE British campaign on the Palestinian front is tantalizing. What is going on behind the Turkish lines? It is like a besieged city. Why are the English so slow? No explanations are offered. Some time ago they were reported as having taken Gaza. But that seems to have been a false report. Now they have taken Beersheba, but that is important only as indicating progress. Skirmishes are reported, but no decided headway is made. French troops, then Italian troops, are said to have joined the English. Knowing that the Allies have clearly expressed intentions with regard to Palestine, it is interesting to speculate what may happen should the Ottoman army be driven out of the Holy Land. Before peace negotiations are begun, it is possible that the Allies would set up a provisional government in Palestine. The taking of Palestine would open up at once lines of communication, enabling us not only to provide for the besieged Jewish population, but also to begin, if necessary, a movement to strengthen the Jewish settlements.

Three-eighty-three