The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 9 · October 1917
65printed page
scan 4 of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

cowards and conspirators is what no friend of the Congress movement will indulge in, for it introduces demagogy and prejudice into the consideration of a serious question.

The Zionist organization favors the holding of the Congress on November 18th, but we are not so narrowminded and so wedded to dogma as not to allow for the holding of a contrary opinion by persons whose interest in the success of the Congress equals at least the interest of continuous performers in the Yiddish press.

THE JEWISH REGIMENT

THE formation of a "Jewish" regiment in England seems to have been abandoned. Opposition arose from a number of sources. That the anti-nationalists in England had a great deal to do with the killing of the project is revealed by correspondence in the London Jewish Chronicle. On the other hand, Dr. Moses Gaster, the well-known Zionist, was also opposed to it.

Shabotinsky’s plan was originated when war broke out, and months later reached England and found its expression in the Zion Mule Corps, that served so brilliantly on the Gallipoli front. The idea was resuscitated to meet the problem of the Russian Jewish alien in England who, not being under obligations to serve in the British army and under the circumstances could not be forced back into the Russian army, was provocative of prejudice and anti-Jewish feeling. The problem became acute in the large cities, especially in London, Manchester and Leeds. To meet this problem it was proposed to enlist the Russian Jewish aliens in a Jewish regiment, provided they were assured that they would be sent to the Palestinian front. This promise was slow in coming, but the intention was, as Lord Derby explained to a deputation of Jews, to form a regiment composed exclusively of Jews with regimental insignia and rights that would express its Jewish character: if possible, the regiment would be sent to Palestine. but it would have to be prepared to go wherever the needs of the Empire required it.

There was no indication that the formation of this regiment had any direct relation to the policy of the British government with regard to the future of Palestine. If the question had arisen of having the Jewish people contribute military forces in return for which their right to Palestine would be granted, a serious problem would have arisen. Nothing has so clearly revealed the helplessness of the Jewish people, so far as their national interests are concerned, as this world-war. Large masses of the Jewish people are citizens of states that are at war. They are under obligation to serve in the armies of their respective countries. Thus, practically all Jews of military age are, presumably, serving in the Russian army, and so too in Germany, Austria, England and France. They will soon be serving in the American army. It is known that in Russia they are serving out of all proportion to their numbers. To provide Jewish regiments to serve on the Palestinian front, regiments would have to be secured by withdrawing forces from the armies where Jews are serving as a matter of civic lovalty.

Our national demands do not rest upon our participation in the war, for all Jews are in service, and because they are in service, their national interests must be taken into consideration as one of the issues of the war. We emphasize the fact that they are serving on all fronts not with the idea of showing our civic patriotism to the respective countries where Jews are citizens, but because that fact reveals our inability, with justice to our civic obligations, to do anything more for our own national interests. Our national demands are based upon the inherent justice of our claims, upon the abnormal position in which we are placed and the fact that the righting of our national wrongs involves the peace, comfort and progress of the world. Because we are serving in all armies, and nevertheless there is a feeling that the Jews are not serving; because we have no national status, we are at tremendous disadvantage everywhere. National rehabilitation is due the Jewish people; this military problem reveals that need as clearly as do most others that impinge on Jewish contact with the world at large.