THE MACCABAEAN
46); the rest were apparently assimilated for there is no record of what they did or of what happened to them. The Isaiah® conception of the redemption was that a “remnant would return.” Similarly Jeremiah prophesies (III, 14): “I will take you, one of acity, two of a.family and I will bring you to Zion.” The aim of Zionism, then, is to give to the Jew his historic home. Here a portion of the people in an environment of its own creation will again fully develop, without hindrance or pressure. Zionism does not only desire a legally assured home in Palestine. It seeks more. It aims to preserve the Jewish people and to permit their further free development. As evidence, look not to formulae but to facts. Zionists are directing the Kehillah of New York City, Zionists are guiding its Bureau of Education, and doing its daily work as well.
The formation of parties is a surface expression of deep-seated influences that agitate the masses. A study of parties in Jewish history reveals the thoughts of the people in various epochs. Until recently all distinctions were theological, as between Pharisee and Saducee, Karaite and Rabinist, Cabbalist and Legalist, Chasid and Pilpulist, Orthodox and Reform. All these secondary divisions took for granted continued life, survival or preservation of the Jewish people. However, since the emancipation of the Jew, this primary assumption has been called into question by Jew and non-Jew alike. Would the Jewish people live through a period of toleration and liberalism as it survived persecution and oppression? Recent history seems to answer in the negative. As a result, a new and primary party formation has taken place. Reform and Orthodox, once names to conjure with, are now realigned. The test today is not “Do you believe,” but “Shall Israel live?”
Who constitute our parties? First, the assimilationist, who prefers “race suicide,” and who, therefore, may be omitted from any question concerning the continued existence of the Jew. Secondly, the status quo Jews, who want to let things alone, but have no program to offer. This party includes the passive wing, the apathetic and unthinking middle class, and the active wing, the misguided leaders of Jewish public opinion, who wish to preserve Israel, but whose economic interests impel them unconsciously to make any domicile the Jewish locus of preservation. The status quo Jews, Reform or Orthodox, have idealized the Goluth, and have created a philosophy of the dispersion. Thirdly, the Zionists who desire the return of a portion of the Jews to Palestine. The significance of Zionism to those who will not return to Palestine has not yet been driven home.
Strange to say, Zionism is of tremendous significance to the assimilationist Jew. It will afford him relief from the very conditions which prevent him from executing his purpose. To illustrate, since any group will always arouse itself, when assimilation, threatening its death, goes too far or too fast, the ever-present natural tendency to fuse is rendered nugatory for a -time, and postponed with each revival of the group spirit. If the Jewish group will have a home of its own for its normal self-perpetuation, the tendency opposing assimilation, outside of Palestine, in extra-territorial lands, will cease to operate, as it does in the case of the French or Germans in America. The
latter feel that there are great reservoirs of national life, self-perpetuating, and not depending upon any expatriated members. With them, as will be the case with the Jew, once Zion is re-established, the assimilant is not a renegade. Nobless oblige does not compel him to live and suffer against his will. He is not held to account for the misdeeds of his fellow nationals. He is a distinguished foreigner, and not a contemptible alien. With a center in Palestine, the Jew outside of it, will live with as little friction as the expatriated Belgian or Pole. Once these implications are driven home, we may look for the support. of the assimilationist Jew, as a measure of relief to himself, if not as an expression of sympathy with the ideal strivings of the stock which gave him birth. The thinking assimilationist Jew should be a Zionist.
To the status quo party, Zionism is of still greater significance. Its members desire to continue to live as Jews in the various lands. Zionism will provide them with a safety valve against prejudice.
The possession of an alternative course of conduct, even though remote, gives a sense of self-confidence, and creates the respect of the person you are dealing with. The knowledge, of a lack of an alternative, does not incline one’s adversary to offer more than minimum terms. And that is the most the Jew has ever received, or can ever hope to receive under the present homeless state of affairs. To attempt to persist permanently as a scattered people invites persecution. And to what purpose? Only to disappear for the pains, for the mission theory logically demands that we die out, when our hypothetical mission is fulfilled. Only with the disappearance of the wandering Jew, will prejudice disappear. Under Zionism, the status quo Jew, “the Jew overseas,” as the Briton might call him, will then be a citizen of a free, spiritual empire. The cringing attitude of the half-caste assimilant should change into a frank outlook and the repressed embarrassment of the status quo Jew, into unhampered activity. And if assimilation should then overtake the non-Palestinian Jew, as it ultimately must,’ he would feel less a renegade than a prudent acceptor of the inevitable. For at least one section of Jewry will, by his efforts, have been saved. Zionism offers the status quo Jew as a minimum program what he dare not otherwise hope to attain as a maximum—the preservation of the group. The Jew, drifting into the status quo group, by apathy, is of no account in a study in national survival. The status quo Jew by conviction, should be a Zionist.
To the Palestinian Jew, nay, to the Jewish people, Zionism means the restoration to a free environment with latitude for the development of any race endowments it may possess. The law of cultural crossfertilization gives hope of large achievement. After contact with the Egyptians, the slave people became free men, with lofty ideals. After contact with the Babylonians, the returned exiles, only a handful, built up a code of social legislation, in some respects, in advance of that of our own times. After contact with all the cultural wealth of modern nations, and with the great unsolved problems of humanity, dare we not hope that by the same token, Israel, on its ancient soil may again aspire to live a full, normal life, expressing itself. for the benefit of humanity.
9 X, 20, 21, 22.
