The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 9 · October 1917
72printed page
scan 11 of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

"Strangely enough, historians have overlooked one big fact in Jewish history. The contribution of Israel to the culture of the world was made when Israel was free, upon its own soil, and when it lived a normal life. Reading the annals of our people, one is struck by the contrast between their fruitfulness in the short period before the dispersion and their comparative sterility in the long Goluth. The history of Israel before that fatal crisis was a story of action, after it, one of suffering. Creation and self-preservation, bestowing and husbanding—these are antitheses of Jewish History."

Our group-life in the exile became static. We can trace the history of European morals by reading the story of what has been done to the Jews from the fall of Rome down to date. We have not developed in dispersion. The Polish Jew wears the Kaftan and Streimel, popular in Poland three centuries ago. The Portuguese Jews of Amsterdam on the Sabbath don knee breeches, the fashion of previous times. Some of our hymns on the holidays are the forgotten folk songs of France and Spain of previous centuries. Yiddish itself is a stunted growth of a German dialect. The Shulchan Aruch is an arrested development of our theology. When a people is dismembered, its growth ceases in religion and language. Ross maintains5 that a static condition or resistance to innovation is characteristic of all oppressed or minority peoples, who wish to maintain their identity. He cites Poles, Armenians and Jews as cases in point.

However, in spite of the stasis of the group, the individual seeking self-expression progresses, and soon there arises a tension between the demands of the individual and the claims of the group. This tension can cease only with the disappearance of the group which causes it, as Jewry in Western Europe or else by placing the group in such a position that it, as well as its individual members, can continue to develop along with the influences of the times, as is the case already in the Palestinian colonies.

All efforts to develop out of our static condition in the lands of dispersion produce unnatural results. On the one hand, the Reform movement endeavored, and properly so, to adjust medieval Judaism to a changed environment, hostile to the rights of minorities of any kind. The movement was therefore abortive in its results, for unwillingly and unwittingly it became an effective instrument in dejudaizing its adherents. On the other hand, the Hebraists undertook to reinvigorate in literature the dead forms of previous centuries. In Eastern Europe they soon evolved a decadent tendency. In every phase of Jewish life our adjustments, in an unfavorable milieu, are unreal. In Palestine, on the contrary, we see the beginning of a new life, normal in religious growth and holding out for the promise of a virile development.®

JEWISH PEOPLE NO LONGER TRUE TO FORM

In the loss of our normal reaction we cannot remain "true to form." Since the dispersion, we have lost the power to contribute as a people to the harmony of world cultures. The voice of righteousness among the nations is raised not by erstwhile spiritual Israel, in exile now, but by lamenting Belgium, on her own soil. We may have great men, but we produce no leaders. True, Zionism has given birth to representative Jews, who typify the renascent spirit.

It has produced Giordano Brunos and John Hampdens, men who stood for liberty of thought and freedom of action in Jewish affairs. Magnes and Heller preached Zionism when it required courage to do so. Malter, Margolis and Schloessinger acted as free men, in resigning from the Cincinnati Seminary rather than curb the expression of their convictions. But except for Herzl, the embodiment of Jewish national ideals, did one hundred years of emancipation produce any heroic figures? Belgium, not scattered for so long a time as the Jews are, still has its Mercier to speak its message to the world. Who is there to tell of the desolation of the Jewish people in Poland or Russia? Who, to voice its hopes? Isaiah prophesied in the Babylonian captivity of a similar condition (LI, 18) "There is none to guide her among all the sons she hath brought forth." Because we never have, except in emergencies, any common sentiments or common volitions, a leader cannot arise except to flash meteorlike for the brief moment of crisis. But no people can live a normal life on the peaks of suffering.

How will Zionism solve the problem? It was the first and only solution for the Jews down all the centuries after the destruction of the temple. In the oldest text-book on Zionism, Isaiah we read (XL, 2): "Speak ye comfortably unto Jerusalem, and say unto her that her warfare is accomplished, for she has received of the Lord's hand, double for all her sins." Amos prophesies (IX, 14): "And I will bring again the captivity of the people of Israel, and I will plant them on their land, and they shall be no more pulled up."8

The Zionist movement is the most dynamic force in Jewish life today. It is the only big issue. It involves the question of survival. It affects our existence in all lands. All other bases of division have vanished. In Herzl's time, there were Mohilever in Bialystok, Zadoc Kahn in Paris, Ruelf in Memel, and Gaster in London, all like-minded on the Zionist idea. Today in America, Stephen Wise and Mayer Berlin stand on the same platform. The movement includes every type of Jew except the avowed assimilationist. In its implications it concerns, even him, among all the parties in Israel.

The Basle Program states the aim of Zionism to be to secure for the Jewish people a home in Palestine guaranteed by international law. The great defect of a written definition is its virtue—it limits. A limited program is dangerous historically, for conditions change. President Garfield said of political formulae, "one may go to bed with a live doctrine and find a corpse at one's side upon arising." The unwritten English constitution has enabled Great Britain under the necessity of war to change her charter of freedom of a liberty-loving people into a decree of restriction rivalling the most despotic known. Our own written constitution has been saved from becoming a fetter and shackle, only by the most liberal interpretation of the word, far from any conception of its framers. The Zionist program demands reinterpretation and broadening. Zionism, in its aim and method, was clarified by opposition and discussion for twenty years.

Its program does not demand the settling of the entire Jewish population of the world in Palestine. The Jews, for centuries before the dispersion were dwellers in foreign lands. Even at the time of the first restoration there were only 42,360 that returned with Ezra (II,

4A. Rupin—The Jews of Today.

3 Foundations of Sociology by E. A. Ross.

1 David de Sola Pool —Palestine and the Diaspora.

' Chapter 40 to 60, Deutero-Isaiah.

" See also Psalm CXXVI and CXXXVII.