THE MACCABAEAN
work, contributing to the movement more than any other section of Jewry. From a shackled Russian Jewry came the Yiddish literature, the Hebrew literature, Jewish learning, and support for the Zionist movement. What will come from a liberated Russian Jewry is best indicated by the fact that at the first convention of Zionists in Russia, with so many distractions, over six hundred delegates were present who discussed at great length their plans for the future. Needless to say, the Russian Zionists from now on may be depended upon to do more than ever before for our cause. We point with pride to the courageous, dignified, and uncompromising tone of the utterances at the Russian Zionist convention.
THE EXTREMISTS AND THE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION
REPORTS brought back here by the Root Commission to Russia implicate a number of so-called American Jewish socialists in the peace propaganda in Russia, which is demoralizing the government and bringing ruin to the Russian army. Among the so-called Americans is our old friend Max Goldfarb, who issued a manifesto as soon as he arrived in Stockholm, in which he told a waiting public exactly what American socialists thought of peace. There are many others, most of them men who had been sojourning in America, never emerging out of the Yiddish-speaking circles, and bringing into the American Jewish socialist movement their bundle of anti-national theories and principles. What right they have to speak for the Jews in America, no one knows, or for the Jews of Russia, who are competent to speak for themselves. These extremists, and their Russian co-workers, are placing in jeopardy not only the liberties won by the Russian people, but they are also paving the way for a wave of anti-Semitism, which will not be limited to Russian territory. This is the view of the actual leaders of Russian Jewry, who, at a meeting held on June 8th in Petrograd, adopted resolutions favorable to the Provisional Government, and opposed to a premature peace. Mr. Sliosberg, now a member of the Senate, came out strongly against the forces of anarchy. He said that the Jews are historically the enemies of anarchy. The Jews among the Maximalists, he said, were a feeble minority of the Jewish people. The great body of the Jews, the men and women who represent industry, commerce and finance, who have suffered through the era of pogroms, stand for law and order. Because they stood for law and order, they were found among the revolutionists, who wanted to overthrow the despotic government. Now that that government has been overthrown, they resent the attempts of insane extremists to kill the revolution by substituting for it an era of anarchy. This attempt, said Mr. Vinaver in a brilliant speech, meets with the indignation of the broad Jewish masses. The Jewish socialist press in this country which supports the extremists in Russia is not contributing to the welfare of the Jews in Russia; it is merely aiding in creating a spirit of lawlessness, out of which a Reign of Terror may emerge.
GERMAN FAVORS JEWISH REPUBLIC
AMONG the Allied nations, the Jewish problem is regarded solely from the point of view of Jewish national rights to Palestine. The Jewish state is freely discussed in English circles. It was the impression that Germany, for a variety of reasons not unconnected with self-interest, was not inclined to take this point of view. It has been careful not to be explicit as to its intentions with regard to Palestine and the Jews.
It could not, “with propriety,” at this time, speak freely on a matter involving internal affairs of Turkey. Recently, however, voices are being heard also in German political circles, where the Allied proposal is being seriously discussed. An interesting point of view is taken by Gustave von Dobeller, an economist, who, in an article in the conservative organ, Der Reichsbote, favors the establishment of a Jewish republic in Palestine, not only because it is in line with the interests of Germany, but in order to cut the ground from under the feet of the Allies. Beat the English to it, seems to be the gist of his argument. Herr von Dobeller thinks that a Jewish republic under Ottoman suzerainty would strengthen the empire internally, for with the aid of the Jews, the natural resources of Palestine could be developed. Interesting is Herr Dobeller’s grund principen. “We suffer from the Jews,” he says. “They are always strangers to the German people, no matter how patriotic they may be. The Jewish spirit unsettles everything. If they were to emigrate to Palestine, they would rid Germany of a burden upon its politics, its art, its press and its commerce.” It is not love of the Jews, or interest in their welfare, but a pure selfish purpose that animates this German’s plan. .
DJEMAL'S "BIG" TALK
WE wonder why Djemal Pasha, the military dictator of Palestine, deemed it necessary to issue a statement on conditions in Palestine in which he minimizes the importance of the Jewish settlement in Jaffa. We recall that during the early part of the war, Djemal visited the Jewish quarter of Jaffa and expressed his admiration of what had been accomplished by the Jews of that model suburb. We take it that he is fully informed by the fiscal authorities of the Ottoman Empire of the industry and enterprise of the Palestine Jews, which has made Palestine an asset instead of a Turkish liability. Perhaps Djemal anticipates an investigation of the evacuation of Jaffa, which he first denied ever had taken place, and now admits. If Jaffa is an insignificant city, what difference does it make whether it was or was not destroyed. It is impossible for us to know what is taking place behind the curtain at Gaza or in Palestine. Only driblets of news, often distorted and garbled, come to us from Egypt. We shall have to wait until the war cloud lifts or the English push their way into the land. Djemal is not serving his country effectively, however, by indulging in flippant talk at the expense of the Jews of Palestine. Nor is he winning the confidence and the friendship of the Jews in general by giving vent to bellicose sentiments toward a people that has, at no time, been unfriendly to the government he is expected to represent.
ZIONISTS AND AMERICAN PATRIOTISM
THE impression is being created that the Jews—especially the Yiddish-speaking Jews—are the prime movers in the pacifist propaganda in this country, and that our young men are avoiding the draft and otherwise interfering with the national determination. This is unfortunate. A few incidents that get into the newspapers are taken as representative of the Jews of this country, while the numerous and silent patriotic services of the many go by unnoticed. As every Jew knows, the large majority of our people here are actually giving freely of their service, and in a manner which deserves the highest praise.
Of course, the records are not yet at hand, but if unofficial reports count for anything, it is clear that in
