The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 8 · September 1917
55printed page
scan 18 of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

“More binding than a common blood in the veins is the blood that is shed in common.” Fusion into nationality may come through reason and love; and though nationalism (as distinguished from nationality) has its dangers and its evils, the laws of nationalities should be exploited. “The brotherhood of the Peoples is not barred through the plurality of patriotisms. It takes two men to make one brother. Internationalism so far from being the antithesis of nationality actually requires nations to inter- relate. . . . The group life with its specific ideals and self-consciousness, forms itself more finely out of international elements.”

Groups or nationalities, according to Mr. Zangwill, are produced through "contiguous co-operation," which is a more spiritual form of Kropotkine's "mutual aid." In Mr. Zangwill's opinion, even if they were not so produced, world government would have to create them. World government will have to create its units, and this being so, why not on lines already organic, rather than by purely mechanical partition?

"In a world of united Republics we may some day, perhaps when humanity grows up, verify Hebrew prophecy, Italian idealism, and German philosophy, the great vision of a League of the Peoples, and a Perpetual Peace."

This little volume is, on the whole, lucid and stimulating. It is marred by Mr. Zangwill's occasional indulgence in a meretricious cleverness, not justified in a writer of his great talent; but most of all by his flippant

dismissal of the idea of the existence of a national soul. The forces that make for “contiguous co-operation,” for the willing sacrifice of life and happiness and for heroic effort on the part of a people in a common cause and for the realization of common aspirations, do create the “soul of a people,” in the judgment of philosophers, sociologists and historians of all nations. Our own Hess, Smolenskin, Achad Ha’am and Schmarya Levin have brought the fact home to the modern nationally conscious Jew. Moses, Isaiah, Jehudah Halevi, Biaklik, all alike sive exnression to the soul of the Tewish people.

It is best after all, perhaps, to let our case rest on the existence of the national “Will-to-be,” expressed in the consciousness of a common bond shared by millions of our people scattered throughout the world and engaged in the effort to give and maintain spiritual significance to a Jewish nationality.

C. A. C.

BOOKS RECEIVED

"THE WORLD AT WAR," by George Brandes, Translated by Catherine D. Groth, New York. The MacMillan Co. Price, $1.50.Lessing's "NATHAN THE WISE," Translated from the German by Patrick Maxwell, edited with an introduction by George Alexander Kohout. Bloch Publishing Co. Price, $1.50."THE STORY OF ISRAEL," by Addie Richman Altman. Bloch Publishing Co."PALESTINE; THE REBIRTH OF AN ANCIENT PEOPLE," by Albert M. Hyamson, New York. Alfred A. Knopf, Publisher.

ZIONIST EDUCATION

CONDUCTED BY J. E. SAMPTER for the Board of Examiners

The Board of Examiners and Certifiers of the Federation of American Zionists has arranged the following questions as a test in Zionism for students wishing to qualify as Zionist Workers. The other required subjects, for which tests have been arranged, are in Jewish history and the Bible. Besides this, there will be required some specific fitness and some Zionist work efficiently done. These questions are so arranged as to be a basis for group study. They can be answered by individuals studying alone or under the supervision of a teacher.

The bibliography is the basis for study. Since the literature on Zionism in English is not extensive, it was thought better to give only titles of books which should be read, rather than sections for reference reading. In the case of a few books the chapters or essays which 216 to be read with each question are mentioned under that question. Almost all the books mentioned, and all those pamphlets whose prices are given, can be ordered through the office of the Federation of American Zionists, and many can be borrowed through the Hadassah or Intercollegiate Zionist libraries. It is not necessary to read the whole series. It is only necessary to answer the questions intelligently. \

Test Questions in Zionism

Test Questions in Zionism 1. a. Do you consider the Jews a nation, or do you consider them a religious sect whose members are incorporated in other nations as the Catholics are? b. What is the proportion of the Jews of North America, in numbers and in influence, to East European Jewry? To West European Jewry? 2. What is the effect of being a good Jew on the quality of our citizenship and loyalty in the lands of birth or adoption? 3. Why is Jewish history a unity, although the Jews have lived for the past two thousand years scattered in many lands? 4. Select four nationalist passages from the Bible. Give book, chapter and verse. 5. Would a close approximation between Christianity and Judaism in respect to creed eliminate the fundamental differences between the two? What are they? 6. a. What were the effects of Jew hatred upon the Jews themselves? b. What was the effect of the stagnation of legal development? 7. a. What might the effect of Reform Judaism be to cut the bonds uniting the Jews, and what is the effect of Zionism likely to be on Jewish unity? State your reason. b. What is meant by "Jewish Emancipation"? 8. a. Indicate briefly the rôle that the Zionist ideal has played in the course of Jewish history. b. Distinguish between the Messianism of certain periods of Jewish history and the recent Zionist ideal. c. What aspects of the Zionist ideal were emphasized by 1. Moses Hess? 2. Hirsch Kalischer? 3. Perez Smolenskin? 9. In what respect was Pinsker ahead of his time and of Hoveve Zionism? 10. a. What is the difference between Ho- veve Zionism and the Zionism of Theodor Herzl? b. What was the "Uganda Offer"?

Three-fifty-two
September, 1917