THE MACCABAEAN
sword and by hunger; the thousands of families ruined; we see ahead of us the vision of a people reunited and reorganized, remembering the days of mourning only because of the virtues of patience, persistence and faith they symbolized.
THE WITHDRAWAL OF THE FACTIONS
THE Mizrachi and the Poale Zion withdrew from the Provisional Zionist Committee on the plea that they were not treated fairly by the Federation delegates to the constitutional convention. They say they are entitled to representation not only in the executive committee of thirty—which was agreed to; not only on the administrative committee—which was agreed to, they being given one vice-president each, who are members of the administrative committee; but also on all other important sub-committees that may be appointed in the future. Our contention was that, having given the two factions representation on the basis of memberships, not on the shekel basis, in the constitutional convention and on the executive committee of thirty, and having also agreed to give them two vice-presidents, who are also members of the administrative committee, we had given them all they were entitled to have on any principle of fairness and equity that may be suggested. We believe that on administrative committees and temporary or permanent committees that may be appointed from time to time to carry out specific instructions of the entire Provisional Committee, there should not be partisan representation, for once the Provisional Committee itself decides its policy the committee carries out its instructions, and with the Poale Zion and the Mizrachi represented on the entire Provisional Committee to the extent of ten members out of thirty, their rights are amply protected. The majority also has rights, which the minority is morally bound to respect. This seems to be a situation which many will regard as purely technical, and of no vital consequence. That would seem to be so, if our friends of both factions had not immediately used the occasion to issue belligerent statements, and bellicose threats. They abuse, they exaggerate, they threaten, and they do everything but use common sense. This does not bring credit to Zionism, and does not lead to harmony and good fellowship. It places obstacles in the way of future co-operation. For, granting that both the Mizrachi and Poale Zion are not represented in the Provisional Committee at all, as seems their desire now, that does not exempt them from obligations to the international Zionist organization, which they are not fulfilling, when they indulge in reckless attacks upon the "general" Zionists, treating them as if they were mortal enemies.
THE CONGRESS SITUATION
THE Convention endorsed the position of the old administration and approved of its intention to keep the agreement under which the Congress had been called. The vote was overwhelmingly in favor of that policy. A great deal of misinformation has been printed, giving versions of the motives of the administration and of the entire Zionist organization. It is hinted that we do not want the Congress
to consider the Palestine question. This is taken together with the postponement of the Congress to November 18th as an indication of our intention altogether to scuttle the Congress, and destroy it. Of course, this nonsense does not make an impression on sober-minded Zionists. We brought up the peace agreement and asked the Convention to approve of our declaration to keep to its terms, in order to avert the possible withdrawal of a number of national organizations, with whom the argument had been used by opponents of the Congress that we were breaking the agreement and at the Congress intended completing the fracture. We did not need a public declaration. But when the honor of the organization was impugned, it became our duty to-state our position in unequivocal terms. No one ever dreamt of tying the hands of Zionist representatives in the Congress. The peace agreement speaks for itself. Only persons who have not taken the trouble to read it will say that Palestine is excluded from the program. On the contrary, it is specifically mentioned in a way which indicates an intention to treat it as an unusual item on the program. It is our opinion that under its terms, a practical plan, or a plan calling for practical action on the part of the Congress executive committee, for the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine, can constitutionally be brought up at the Congress. Others may think differently, but it remains for the parliamentary authority to be selected by the Congress to decide the issue. As to the postponement 01 the Congress, it is easy for writers in the heat of July to erect a theory that seems formidable upon the basis of a simple fact, but all we can say is this: That in our judgment November 18th is a better date for the opening of the Congress than September 2d; as sacred as was the decision to open it on September 2d just su sacred was the decision to open it on November 18th. The “conspiracy” of the Zionists will result in there being a Congress worthy of the éffort put into the movement.