THE MACCABAEAN
provided in paragraph 4. Paragraph 5 was then amended providing for five members on the Administrative Committee; and paragraph 6 was amended to increase the number of officers from five to seven. With these amendments the convention then adopted paragraphs three, four, five, six seven and eight
The question of the Administrative Committee, as contained in paragraph nine, which provided for representation of the Federation, Mizrachi and Poale Zion, was vigorously opposed by both the Poale Zion and the Mizrachi. A number of amendments were offered intended to meet the desires of the opposition. A motion to table paragraph nine and the amendments was carried by a vote of 34 to 28, whereupon the delegates of the Poale Zion and Mizrachi left the convention. This action elicited the following statement on the part of Dr. Stephen S. Wise who was presiding:
“The Chair feels that he owes it to the organization over which he is presiding to make a statement which he regrets to make in the absence of the gentlemen who have now departed. I wish such representatives of the press as are here present to note that in the first place, this secession is altogether temporary. Within a half hour or twenty minutes, the gentlemen will have regained their reason and have returned. In the first place, the Chair desires to say that these gentlemen, who have now retired, will not be sustained by their constituents for the action which they have now taken. The chairman desires to point out that if these gentlemen, instead of marching out for their support, had remained for another ten minutes, they would have learned the following:
“It Is Resolved, That the Provisional Zionist Committee of thirty be selected by the three constituent parties—The Federation of American Zionists, the Mizrachi, and the Poale Zion, on the basis of proportional representation as follows: The Federation to be entitled to select 17 members of the Provisional Zionist Committee, the Mizrachi to select 7 members of the Provisional Zionist Committee and the Poale Zion to select 5 members of the Provisional Zionist Committee.
“The Chair claims that this is coalition. The only thing that this body refused to do at this time was so to tie the hands of the Provisional Committee as to say that some member of the Poale Zion and some member of the Mizrachi, must occupy a certain office in the actual management of the affairs of the Provisional Committee, whether or not he be fitted for that occupancy. We talk about a coalition. We have a coalition. Coalition in the English Government did not compel Mr. Lloyd George to name certain men representing every party to certain cabinet places. We are attempting in advance to decide whether the cabinet of the Provisional Government shall be designated in advance, and this body is absolutely within its rights in saying that party representation shall come second, and the interests of the Zionist Movement shall come first. This is the only decision which has now been taken. This body has decided that one problem here is not how to magnify the right of every constituent delegate in the Zionist Movement, but how best to perform our common duties, and our common tasks, and I say to you gentlemen of the press, that it is not secession at all. This is just a moment of unrest, and these gentlemen will return, and if they’ do not
return, they will be discredited by the bodies which they purport to represent, and they will never be sustained if they dare to maintain that in advance. Every cabinet office of the Provisional Government in Zionism shall be made so and so. We are simply declaring that we are bound together and we serve together, but we will use the delegates within our forces in such a way as shall best serve the interest of our great movement."
Evening Session
The first order of business for the evening session of the Constitutional Convention was paragraph 10, which was carried by a vote of 35 to 11. Paragraph 11 adopted unanimously, paragraph 12 was laid on the table. Resolution No. 13 was adopted in the following form:
“That, at the Constitutional Convention the three constituent organizations —-The Federation, Mizrachi and Poale Zion, shall each select its allotment of its representatives to the Provisional Zionist Committee, and that thereupon, the reconstituted Provisional Zionist Committee shall select all of its officers, except the Honorary President, who shall be chosen by the Constitutional Convention, irrespective of party groupmes.
At this point a delegation representing the Mizrachi and the Poale Zion entered the hall and offered the following :
“Whereas, The Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs must be the association of all the parties that have distinctive Zionist views and are recognized by the Zionist Congress, “Whereas, The various parties that enter into the formation of the Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs assume responsibility for its policies and activities, and
"WHEREAS, The Mizrachi and the Poale Zion parties represent respectively two important elements in Jewry, the Poale Zion representing the Jewish workingmen class and the Mizrachi, representing Jewish orthodoxy.
Be It Therefore Resolved, Unanimously by all the delegates representing the Poale Zion and the Mizrachi at the Constitutional Convention that their respective parties shall co-operate with the Federation of American Zionists in forming the Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs, only on the fundamental conditions that the representation in the Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs be on the basis of number of membership, and that the Provisional Executive Committee grant it representation on all other standing committees and on other committees of importance, as well as on the Board of Officers of the Executive Committee on General Zionist Affairs.
“The delegates of the Poale Zion and the Mizrachi furthermore unanimously declare that if the conditions set forth above shall not be granted, the Mizrachi and the. Poale Zion shall withdraw from the Provisional Committee and shall consider the Provisional Committee merely as a special committee of the Federation of American Zionists.”
This resolution was laid on the table, and the convention adopted the following resolution, presented by Mr. Avner, which was accepted by the Convention as an amendment to the resolution offered by the
representatives of the Poale Zion and the Mizrachi:
"WHEREAS, The Provisional Executive Committee for General Zionist Affairs is intended to be an association of all the parties that have distinctive Zionist views, and that are recognized by the Zionist Congress, and
“Whereas, The various parties that enter into the formation of the Provisional Executive Committee, for General Zionist Affairs assumes responsibility. for its policies, and activities.
"Therefore Be It Resolved, That the Provisional Committee for General Zionist Affairs be constituted on the fundamental condition that each of the parties to the association be represented therein on the basis of their respective numerical memberships."
The remaining resolutions were adopted. Mr. Lipsky then rose and said on behalf of the Federation that he agreed to put on record that the Order B’nai Zion is regarded by the Federation as one of the allied organizations connected with and part of it; and that the order is entitled to partnership rights in whatever rights the Federation possesses. Mr. Barondess announced that this statement was entirely satisfactory to the order.
The next thing in order was the election of officers of the Provisional Committee. Dr. Harry Friedenwald nominated Justice Louis D. Brandeis as Honorary Chairman. His nomination elicited a great ovation, at the end of which Mr. Brandeis was declared unanimously elected. Dr, Kallen then placed in nomination for Chairman, Dr. Stephen S. Wise. The election of Dr. Wise was greeted with cheers. In accepting the election, he made the following statement:
"[ came to Baltimore, as some of you know, determined to lay~down the duties of the office of the Chairman of the Provisional Zionist Committee. Some of the leaders among us have been earnest in prevailing upon me to reconsider and accept the chairmanship for one further year. If I had been in doubt, I am still in the same doubt as to whether to reaccept re-election. The decision was made for me tonight by a gathering of my friends. I promise you as chairman of the Provisional Committee I will do what I can in order to win back to loyal and whole-hearted support for the cause, every wing and faction of the American Zionists. There is no reason in the world why the Poale Zion and the Mizrachi should not remain earnestly and enthusiastically by our side. In calmness we will labor to the end that they shall return and be a part of us, and work sympathetically and loyally by our side. I accept the chairmanship of the committee and give you heartfelt thanks for the honor you do me, and I trust that I may be worthy of the honor which you have conferred upon me.”
