The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 7 · August 1917
31printed page
scan 18 of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

grandeur of the opportunity no less than by the magnitude of the responsibility and duty which rests upon us. The blessing is fervent upon my lips that we have been kept in life, that we have been preserved, that we have been enabled to reach this period! Let us hope that we may be worthy and strong to serve our people, to solve and to end the greatest tragedy that any people has been forced to play upon the stage of history. May that end come in our days."

in our days. Mr. Bernard A. Rosenblatt, Honorary Secretary of the Federation, then read a number of telegrams, sending greetings to the Convention, among them a telegram from Jacobus Kann, of the Actions Comite. After the reading of the telegrams the chairman proceeded to the appointment of a committee of nine to recommend to the Convention the names of all Convention Committees.

Committees.The following were appointed: Morris Neaman, Chairman; Dr. Benj. Gordon, Dr. Ch. Wortzman, Dr. Horace Kallan, S. Goldenberg, Max Shulman, Louis Kirstein, Allen Davis and Isaac Carmel. The meeting adjourned at 5.45 P. M. to reconvene on Monday afternoon.

Second Session, Monday Afternoon

The second session of the Federation Convention was devoted to the report of Mr. Louis Lipsky, Chairman of the Executive Committee of the Federation. In an explanation of the report, a printed copy of which had been handed to the delegates on registration, Mr. Lipsky counselled strict adherence to the Congress agreement. The “Peace Agreement,” he pointed out, does not preclude the discussion of the Palestine question at the Congress.

"A breach of the agreement," said Mr. Lipsky in his report, "would break the authority of the Congress and enable those who are lukewarm in their allegiance to use it as a justification for secession. Having all such organizations within the iron ring of the peace agreement, they cannot, without discredit to themselves, withdraw. By thus adhering to the peace agreement the Zionists have the moral advantage of all who may even now be seeking to undermine the authority of the Congress, and, at the same time, give moral strength and prestige to its deliberations."

Speaking on the problem of organization, Mr. Lipsky pointed out that there were too many varying groups and societies in the movement and urged that uniformity of method of organization be adopted and individual allegiance and responsibility sought for. Individual affiliation should be the primary allegiance of the organized Zionist, he declared. The report also dealt with the relations with fraternal orders, the problems of the shekel, periodicals and literature, the affiliated organizations, etc.

All indications pointed that the afternoon session would be stormy and result in a division of the delegates. But the discussion following the chairman's report took a relatively quiet course. The discussion on the report was opened by Dr. Melamed with a brief address. In his address, he pointed out that the mutual suspicion existing among the members of the Administration and the so-called "opposition" would serve no other purpose but to undermine the Organization.

Dr. Melamed was followed by Isaac Carmel, Allen Davis, of Pittsburgh, I. L. Brill, Dr. Wortzman and Solomon Goldenberg. They held that there should be voiced in the Jewish Congress an unequivocal demand for a Jewish Homeland in Palestine, regardless of compromises and

peace agreements. Others pointed out that they had not had time to read and properly digest the report and were in no position to vote intelligently upon it. Some objected to the policy of the administration in the Congress election in New York, declaring that not enough attention had been paid to the Zionist candidates in the metropolis.

the Zionist candidates in the metropolis. Dr. Charles A. Cowen spoke in the defence of the Administration and said that though the Administration may have been guilty of committing errors, such as are unavoidable, but it deserves the confidence and the support of the delegates.

and the support of the delegates. Mr. Lipsky, in his reply, pointed out that the many demands made upon the Administration during the past year made it impossible for it to cope with the entire situation without being guilty of some default. Its entire interest was absorbed in the Congress movement which necessarily compelled the Administration to disregard other matters which it might have done under ordinary circumstances.

Ordinary circumstances. Before the report was voted upon Mr. De Haas called the attention of the delegates that the acceptance of the report implies an expression of confidence in the Executive Committee, whereupon the report was accepted with but five dissenting votes.

votes. Professor Nahum Slousch, of the University of Paris, who was a guest at the convention, greeted the delegates in behalf of the Central Zionist Committee of Paris. The following telegram was then read from Nahum Sokolow:

“I have just returned from France and Italy with a fresh impression of our triumph and with the realization of the 7766 new progress which our movement has made in the principle centers of our work, here and throughout Europe.

"I convey my homage to you, my brethren and sisters, and to your splendid achievements as an organization, to your enthusiastic spirited sacrifice and initiative. I convey to you also affectionate wishes .for the success of your deliberations.

“May the present convention open a new and a great chapter in the history of your glorious activities for our national homeland in Palestine.”

It was about six when the chairman called the attention of the delegates that they were scheduled for an automobile ride through the city. On motion the meeting adjourned to reconvene tomorrow at 1 P. M.

"London. June 23. 1917.

Third Session, Tuesday Afternoon

This was perhaps the stormiest and most exciting session of the entire convention. Determination on the part of the Administration of the Federation and an overwhelming majority of the delegates to the convention to stand by the so-called agreement in the Congress, which was regarded hy them as sacred, notwithstanding the fact that several groups have broken 8 agreement by the act of their secession from the Congress movement, was the cause of this stormy session. CO

By an overwhelming majority it was voted against either abrogating or even attempting to read any new interpretation into the agreement which was the basis for the call for the American Jewish Congress. The entire Administration, stood squarely in back of the resolution presented by the Committee on Congress, headed by Judge Hugo Pam of Chicago, to ratify the agreement in categorical detail. The resolution read as follows:

Three-twenty-eight

“Your Committee on the American Jew-

ish Congress begs to report that it has considered the report of the Executive Committee on the American Jewish Congress, and that it is in hearty accord with the principle announced therein. We therefore ask all Zionist delegates to the American Jewish Congress to loyally observe the terms set forth in the call to the Congress.”

terms set forth in the call to the Congress. The language of the resolution was bitterly opposed by a block which demanded that the phrase of Jewish rights in Palestine should be interpreted as including a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

Jewish homeland in Palestine. The opposition, led by Ephrium Ish Kishor, maintained that other Jewish groups had violated the contract and that there was no particular reason why the Zionists should adhere to it. He wanted the Zionist delegates to be instructed to call upon the American Jewish Congress officially to demand that Palestine be handed over by the nations to the Jews as a homeland.

a homeland. Dr. Friedenwald in reply to those who opposed the resolution, said that he would not submit to the convention a motion or an amendment, which "in the slightest degree would indicate that the Zionists repudiate the terms of the agreement."

pudiate the terms of the agreement. Mr. Louis Lipsky said that this would be unfair, since it was not stipulated in the peace agreement. He also feared that such action might lead other elements to withdraw and thus endanger the whole Congress Movement.

The Chairman was first inclined to prevent any discussion on the question whatever, taking the stand that the Federation was in honor bound as one of the parties to the agreement. Dr. Friedenwald was prevailed upon to permit a free discussion.

Dr. Harry Friedenwald was so exhausted by his endeavor to keep in check the bitter insistence on the part of members of the block, led by Mr. Solomon Goldenberg, of preventing to take a vote on the resolution, that he was compelled to yield the chair to Judge Pam. The bitter struggle was a struggle for principle, in which no personalities were involved. The final vote on the question showed 210 for, and 44 against supporting the Peace Agreement.#

The first order of business of this session was the report of the Credentials Committee. The report of the Credentials Committee showed the presence of 435 delegates.

By unanimous consent, the convention also seated as honorary delegates: Dr, Schmarya Levin, Leo Motzkin, Dr. Ben Zion Mossinsohn, M. M. Scheinkin, Israel Belkind, Litman Rosenthal, and Rabbi I. Leventhal.

This was followed by a report. of the Committee on Rules, for the government of the remaining sessions of the convention. Immediately upon the adoption of the rules, a motion was carried to proceed with the elections on the same day. The floor was then given to Mr. Abel to make a report on shekel work during the past year.

Owing to the illness of Mr. Rubin, Secretary of the National Fund Bureau. Mr. Abel offered the report for that activity. A motion was made that a telegram be sent to Mr. Rubin wishing him a speedy recovery. 0

This was followed by a report from the Committee on National Fund, offered by the chairman, Dr. B. L. Gordon, of Philadelphia:

“On behalf of the National Fund Committee, I beg to submit the following report:

The Committee on National Fund sat on June 26th and considered the report of the National Fund Bureau for the past

August, 1917