THE MACCABAEAN
that we finally come to wars in which every fiber of a people is mobilized, not only its men and its money, but its press, its scholarship, its industries, its women, even its pulpits and its theological acumen.
Along comes the shallow reasoner and execrates nationalism for its mad excesses. To him the world war is proof indisputable that nationalism constitutes an intolerable bigotry and a blighting curse. As well, might we say—as has been said by shallow free-thinkers—that religion is a dangerous mental aberration, simply because cruel persecutions and bloody wars have been waged in its name. Among the several changes of popular opinion which the shifting course of the world war has brought about must be reckoned the consecutive attitudes towards nationalism as a factor in cultural progress. In the beginning of the fateful strife denunciation was general for what, then, seemed the blight of overbearing, unreasonable, intoxicated nationalism, a nationalism that seemed to mean principally conceited pride, purblind self-righteousness, jealous envy and unbounded capacity. Since then, after the devoted loyalties, the heroic sacrifices of the smaller nations, public opinion seems to have veered to the opposite direction, until it is felt, professedly, by all belligerents, not only that unhampered national unfoldment is an interest equivalent to the primary right of existence, but that the small nations must be safeguarded specially in the maintenance of these rights. In the strange irony of Providence it appears as if the desperate battle between the giants would firmly secure the safety of the dwarfs.
Yet there is, in modern Jewdom, this irrational split, which, from one side or the other, insists that, with us, religion and nationalism must walk along separate roads, each intolerant of the other. The reformer does not deny that religion and nationality were born together; the Orthodox believes that religion and nationality are to coalesce again in the Messianic future; but godless Zionist and anti-Zionist believer agree in denying that Judaism and nationalism can form, should form a harmonious unit.
In actual life, under the laws of human nature and of Jewish soul-life, neither can Jewish nationalism endure without the consecration of Judaism nor can Judaism maintain life, in the long run, without the aid of Jewish nationalism; just which of the two stands in greater need of the other, it would not be easy to say.
Jewish nationalism, on the one hand, is inconceivable, except as based on Jewish history, as a continuation of the evolution of the Jewish people. We can think of a Jewish people in a Jewish land which shares with all other nations and countries the drawbacks and degradations of twentieth century culture, along with its triumphs and achievements, its opportunities and its privileges. There is nothing really discouraging in the fact that Jewish nationalism has its decadents, its anarchists of the spirit, any more than in the historical record that it was vice and crime, idolatry and unbelief which wrung from our prophets their fieriest protests. In a reborn Palestine we cannot expect to become disembodied angels; but the core of the people, or at least a saving remnant, such as will constitute its real soul, that will have to be religious, will have to carry the Jewish spirit and the Jewish life, social justice and individual morality, ideals of peace and the atmosphere of spirituality to ever higher planes. To despair of Jewish nationalism in Palestine, simply because some Russian revolutionaries cannot at once change the mental habits
and moral outlooks of a lifetime, is to condemn whole epochs upon the passing ebullitions of the moment. By this time, in this country, we ought to know something of the taming processes of conservatism, such as the furious radical undergoes in piping times of peace and plenty.
The restored nationalism of a resurrected Palestine, starting from the traditions and inheritances of the Jewish people, will be a nationalism consecrated to religious and moral ends, to the redemption of mankind from its social diseases, to the elevation of the soul to higher spiritual levels. The new Jewish nationalism will espouse these aims, whether consciously or unwittingly, not because the Jew needs to justify his existence and continuance as Jew by proving his usefulness to mankind, when no other nation is called upon to demonstrate its rights to existence and unfoldment; but because the Jew stands pledged, by his history, by his character, by his professions, to these very tasks and aspirations.
If, however, it seems most unlikely that a Jewish nation in old Palestine will turn its back upon its dreams and yearnings of all the ages, it is proved utterly impossible, by the experience of the last century, that Judaism can keep itself alive for any great length of time without drawing strength from the roots of a national or quasi-national life. This fact has lately been set forth, unintentionally, yet with all the cogent clearness derived from personal observation, by one who refuses to be classified as a Zionist, yet who now subscribes, with all the honesty of conviction, to some of the fundamental principles of Zionism by no less a man than Mr. Schiff.
That not only American, but all western Judaism cannot maintain life, unless they are fed from some great reservoir of the Jewish spirit is the momentous fact which has forced itself upon Mr. Schiff's consciousness and which convinces him of the need for a great cultural center. Mr. Schiff, from his wide reading and extensive observation, is fully aware of those disintegrating processes of assimilation which are inseparable from our life amid highly civilized nations. He has emancipated himself, thank God, from that one hollow and chimerical contention of reform cant which tells us that dispersion among the nations has meant opportunity and zeal for spreading our truth. Mr. Schiff has the courage, a courage which pulpit-lackey and spread-eagle shouter never will command, of boldly facing an unpromising situation, instead of triumphing exultingly in the midst of religious desolation.
But Mr. Schiff cannot go, and probably never will go, all the way with professed Zionists. While he understands the need of a Jewish spiritual reservoir, of a cultural center in Palestine, while, thus, he is, more than nominally, in accord with the quest for a publicly, legally safeguarded home, he shrinks from the consequences of a recrudescent nationalism of which he cannot conceive as otherwise than evil. To him Jewish nationalism embodies all the strife, all the wickedness and godliness of our two ancient commonwealths; while the prophet and the psalmist to him, are phenomena for which Jewish nationalism does not deserve the credit. Presumably then, to him, in modern Zionism, atheist, agnostic, anarchist, decadent, represent the soul of the nationalist yearning; it is they, in his view, who will determine the policies and create the spiritual atmosphere of the new Palestine; it is his impression that "the great majority of Jewish nationalist leaders have absolutely no interest in the Jewish religion." How correct such a surmise may be,
(Continued on page 280)