THE MACCABAEAN
autonomy. The leaders of the Bund were not at all clear in their minds as to how they were to put their nationalist resolutions into practice.
Medem, the well-known leader of the Bund, when asked "What are the duties and aims of the Jewish nation? In what direction should national development be guided?" made the drastic reply, "We are not nationalists; neither are we assimilationists—we are neutral."
In the socialist camp, the Bund waged many a hard and instructive conflict because of its separate existence. The time had not yet come when international as well as Russian socialism were to recognize the existence of a Jewish nation.
As early as the end of the year 1897, that is directly after the founding of the Bund, the Polish Socialist Party (P. S. P.) passed a harsh resolution against its sister organization in which it declared that "the distinct character of the program and organization of the Bund placed it in the position of an enemy of the Polish socialists."
At that time the nationalist Polish socialists could not understand why it should be necessary for the Jewish masses to have an organization of their own, even though it were of a socialist nature, and fired the first shot against the new group, notwithstanding the fact that the Bund was at that time miles away from any nationalist leanings whatsoever.
Even the general Russian Social Democratic Party, which had not yet been organized when the Bund came into being, and which, after its organization in 1898, existed merely on paper for some time, took a hostile attitude toward the independent existence of the Bund, in spite of its own initial weakness. The Jewish assimilationists within the ranks of the Russian social democracy sounded the alarm against the new nationalist danger and influenced their Russian associates to deny that an independent Jewish socialist organization was necessary, on the ground that it was not the task of socialism to preserve “dying nations.” This attitude toward the Bund was maintained with peculiar harshness when the Russian social democracy began to gain a firm footing and to play a prominent role. (1903)
After long and hard struggles waged against the Bund, in particular by the Russian paper Iskra, published in Geneva, the Jewish Arbeiterbund withdrew from the Russian social democratic party. This occurred at the end of the year 1903, after the second convention of the Russian social democratic labor party had rejected the offer of compromise of the Bund, and had adopted an organization system which was bound to bring about a slow but sure disappearance of the organization of the Jewish proletariat" (Report of the Jewish Arbeiterbund for the International Socialist Congress of Amsterdam, Geneva, 1904). This separation lasted until the beginning of the eventful revolutionary year, 19051906.
When the Jewish Arbeiterbund finally became reunited with the Russian party it had not succeed in attaining its direct claims, and had to content itself with the general attitude, according to which every nation had the right to determine its own destiny, a standpoint which might eventually prove beneficial to the Jews. From that time on the Bund, as a more or less autonomous part of the Russian Social Democratic Party, began with its large following (according to its official report of the year 1906, it had 33,890 members) to occupy an important position among the Jewish proletariat.
Among the conditions stated by the Bund in 1906, upon its uniting with the Russian
Social Democratic Party, was the demand that in the matter of its attitude to the national question, it should have the right to keep to that program which it had adopted of its own accord at its sixth convention. This included (1) The demand that the Jewish population should officially be accorded the use of its own language in its relations, with the judicial bodies, with the Government institutions and with the local and provincial administrative bodies and (2) the resolution relating to national cultural autonomy, which stated that all cultural functions (education, etc.) should no longer be the concern of the state and of the local and provincial administrations, but should be given over to the nationalists to be administered by special local and central bodies elected by popular vote.
The conflict between the Bund and the Russian social democratic party, which turned a cold shoulder on such aspirations, did not cease even later, in the succeeding period of political storms. Even before, the well-known socialist leader, Plekhanov, said of the apostles of the Bund that they were “Inconsistent Zionists,” Zionists who “feared long journeys.” It was accusation of this sort which served to spur on the Bundists, never ardent nationalists at best, to violent hatred of the Zionistic proletarian factions. But Zionism, thanks to its influence with the public, indirectly compelled the Bund to stand firm by its attitude toward nationalism. A significant word on this subject was uttered by Lieber, one of the chief leaders of the Bund, at the seventh convention (held in Liepzig in September, 1906): “W. says that. in order to combat Zionism it is necessary to unite with the general Russian organization. I admit the truth of this statement, but I draw entirely different conclusions therefrom. We shall lose the fight against the Zionists if we unite with the Russian party on terms such as will cause us to lose our independence.”
During this struggle, waged on two fronts, the Bund made frantic efforts to be considered the "only representative body of the Jewish proletariat" by the Russian social democrats, in order to bring about the exclusion of other socialistic Jewish organizations from the international socialist Congresses.
This was an unheard-of perversion of the true situation, and an incredible misuse of the position which the Bund had achieved through its priority. For even if no one of the three more recently organized socialist Zionist factions (the Poale Zion, the Socialist Territorialists, and the Seimists) had such large numbers of organized members as the Bund at its command, nevertheless, at the time of the revolution, they represented considerable groups whose combined influence was but little less than that of the Bund.
III The former Russian government took good care that the tree of Jewish nationalism should not reach too great a height. Even most unassuming wishes and decisions of the Jewish political parties appeared to it to be fraught with criminal audacity, and were suppressed without further ado, let alone such bold projects as that of a national assembly as conceived by the Association for the Granting of Equal Rights to the Jews, or the demand of the Seimists for a Jewish parliament (see MaccaBaEan for May,.1917.) As soon as Stolypin had taken the reins of government in his hands, he used all the means in his power to combat nationalist as well as socialist aspirations, and especially those organizations which stood for both tendencies. It was he who had a special law passed. according to which every associa-
(By Appointment)
Miss E. ROSA FRANZ
Gowns
1213 LINDEN AVENUE BALTIMORE, MD.
MILLER BROTHERS
Restaurant
A Good Place to Eat
117 W. FAYETTE ST. BALTIMORE, MD.
Phone, St. Paul 6489
ROBERT SEFF
Real Estate Investments 215-17 COURTLAND STREET Baltimore, Md.
DR. CHESTER E. MILLER
DENTISTbegs to announce that he has removed from1605 East Baltimore Streetto142 North BroadwayBaltimore, Md.
Phone, Wolfe 864 Open Day and Night
JACK LEWIS
Member Dr. S. Levin Camp No. 68, O.S.Z.
Undertaker and Embalmer
Carriages, Taxicabs, Touring Cars and Limousines. Private Ambulance at Short Notice
1411 E. Baltimore St. Baltimore, Md.
The Nordau Zionist Society
extends its hearty congratulations and most sincere good wishes to its fellow Zionists .
