THE MACCABAEAN
Proletarian Jewish Factions in Russia
(Continued from page 254)
Seimists (looked upon it as the chief goal in the effort for national self-preservation of the Jewish people in the Diaspora. For them, territorial concentration was one of the many duties devolving upon Jewish nationalism. If once the Jewish people were everywhere nationally organized, it would in addition find ways and means to acquire a land for Jewry. But first of all the organization of the Jewish people was to be carried out earnestly and consistently, i. e., by means of certain compulsory measures in those countries where there are large numbers of Jews.
The Seimists adopted the theory of Dubnow, according to which the Jews can develop a normal national life even without a land, even in the dispersion, if only the necessary conditions can be created. Consequently, national concentration is a wish rather than an ideal.
What jis more, ‘the Seimists rejected the theory of the permanence of anti-Semitism. According to them, merely to maintain such an ethnic theory was to ‘sin against the humanitarian idea. The Jews continue to exist as a nation, not because they cannot be assimilated, but because they do not want to be assimilated.
But nationalism should not be confined to one land in which only a small part of the Jews would be concentrated. As far as the slow colonization of Palestine was concerned, it would have practically nothing to do with the realization of the larger national ideal. For this reason, the enthusiasm for practical work in Palestine (under former conditions) is no less than an abandonment of the Jewish People.
In the last decade these nationalist aspirations as expressed by the Seimists had no tenable basis whatsoever. The securing of a national organization of Russian Jews guaranteed by the Russian state, under the former régime, was no less an illusion than the securing of a charter for Palestine in the old days. But the recent upheaval in Russia will give these half-forgotten tendencies a new lease of life. Indeed, today, Yiddishism and nationalism as preached by these circles assume a political significance and will surely play a rôle in the approaching conflicts in Russia.
In addition to the Poale Zion and the Seimists, there was another active faction in the revolutionary "Storm and Stress" period from 1905-1906, which had also first seen the light in Basle, namely, the socialist Territorialists. Emphasizing as they did the theory of territorialism, they were more remote from nationalist aspirations in the countries of the Diaspora than any of the other proletarian factions. But although this party wielded a certain influence a decade ago, it is impossible to prognosticate a favorable outlook for it in the future. It cannot maintain itself in the form in which it made its début in 1906. The only "territory" under consideration for the Jews at the present time is Palestine, and any attempt at concentration in another land will meet with but a feeble response. Even the active Socialist Territorialists in Russia will not be able to avoid following in the wake of their American colleagues in bashfully agreeing to giving their qualified assent to Palestine.
As a matter of fact, the Socialist Territorialists were diametrically opposed to the Seimists as regards their ideology, for they laid even more stress on anti-Seimistism than the Zionists themselves, and accepted the existence of the Jewish question as the basis of their arguments. In this matter, they did not let themselves
