The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 6 · June 1917
101printed page
scan 59 of 70

THE MACCABAEAN

FOR A

Grafonola or Victrola

Also Opera Records in All Languages

GO, WRITE OR TELEPHONE

Greater New York Phonograph Co.

310 Grand Street, New York

Telephone Orchard 3425

being without a proper cultivation of the will he remained a rationalist. Although the prophets did not antagonize the law, yet they did not make it the central point of Judaism. This has directed an undefinable suspicion towards them. Besides, the prophetic world view is too large and wide, and through its lack of purely legal elements too "concrete" to call forth in the formal "law-schooled" Jew a sympathetic and enthusiastic understanding. I do not consider it mere accident that even today there are so few Jews among the scientific students of the Bible. But there is still another reason why the Talmud rather than the Bible has remained the central point of Judaism, namely, because the Bible alone was unable to secure the existence of the Jewish people in the Diaspora. The prophetic view, in depth and breadth, is too enormous to have a determining influence in the daily course of events. Daily life requires a direct driving force, which the rabbinical law is able to supply but not the prophetic vision or idea. It was not without reason that the ancient Jew after the first great national catastrophe threw himself into the arms of the law. He felt instinctively that only the law could save his nationality from destruction, and the more he became uprooted from his native soil the more he yielded to the rule of the law. All those who rejected the rabbinical law, whether individuals or groups, had to separate themselves from the Jewish people and lose themselves in other nationalities. This is why the Talmud rather than the Bible remained the national book of the Jews. So long then as the Jews lead no real political life they will be held together as a people by means of the Talmud. He that today cuts himself loose from the Talmud on principle, will sooner or later cut himself loose from the Jewish people.

The Talmud, however, retains its primacy only where the conditions of life are still of a primitive nature—where there is no real life at all—or where the state excludes the Jews from full participation in life. This will give an idea of the future of the Talmud and of the western European Jews. The cry: "Back to the Bible" (which means away from the Talmud) which was raised by the so-called reform Judaism in western Europe has proved to be a subsequent invitation to baptism. The Talmud is a growth of the Diaspora, and the Judaism of the Diaspora will be either Talmudic or nothing.

This slight digression was needed for the right understanding of rabbinical Judaism. At the close of antiquity, as at the present time, the rabbi was the only cohesive and, for the continued existence, the only indispensable force. The essence of post-exilic Judaism is the Talmud, and the essence of the Talmud is the rationalistically formulated law.

Thus the mind of the ancient Jews was transformed, from the will to the intellect, from the deed to the book, from life to law, from synthesis to dry analysis, from intuition to discussion. This transformation, however, was already determined by the original essence and structure of the law.

At rare intervals and in isolated cases, however, the ancient Jewish spirit bursts forth in all its pristine greatness. Such was the case with Baruch Spinoza, one of the greatest Jews of modern times.

A BALTIMORE LANDMARK

The most unique tailor shop in America is the House of Schloss—where gentlemen's clothes are built—Five East Lexington St. Anyone interested in seeing the House of Schloss is welcome at any time

June-July, 1917

Two-ninety-nine