The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 6 · June 1917
100printed page
scan 58 of 70

THE MACCABAEAN

Driving Forces in Jewish History

(Continued from page 264)

is and what "ought to be," and in their powerful imagination they saw the yearned-for "ought to be" as actual existence. Hence the assurance and definiteness with which the prophets announce the future and describe its conditions.

If the prophets, although starting from the realities of life, had no relations with cruel reality, because of their viewing all things through the prism of their rigorous morality, what can be expected of the rabbis who did not even start from real life but from "abstract law?" As a matter of fact, the rabbi had the same end in view as the prophet and was like him uncompromising in morals and an ardent patriot; but he lacked the flight of genius, and instead of using his strong arm to execute a great work he sat down quietly and meditated upon the law and its ramifications, as though Israel was sitting under its own vine and fig tree.

While the prophet always thought of life, though of the future earthly life, the rabbi thought only of the book, of the law, of the Torah, and his mind always moved in abstract lines of thought, which had neither likeness to nor a basis in life. As it was, the rabbi applied himself as assiduously to the interpretation of the law, as the prophet before him had applied himself to the reformation of life. While the utterances of the prophets always have a definite and practical object in view, the rabbi spins long-winded theories which lead to nothing and have no earthly value, not even to his own science. In the Talmud it is often hard to tell after the discussion is ended

which is the established law and which the individual opinion. For the most part the discussion seems to be without end in more than one sense of the word. It is therefore quite clear that the rabbi giving his whole mind to the law had a much narrower view of life than the prophet. Moreover, the prophet was as much of a cosmopolite as of a nationalist, while the rabbi was wholly nationalistic. In the Talmud all things, God, life, and so forth, are nationalized, and only now and then we find a short maxim which reflects the universalistic tendency. And so we have the prophet and the rabbi, the two most prominent representatives of the Jewish mind, as types opposed to one another, and in some respects even mutually exclusive. This explains why the prophetic man of will and of a universalistic turn of mind became the moral and religious property of the whole civilized world while the rationalistic, world-estranged rabbi, whose view of life was narrowed by application to the law was bound to remain the property of the Jewish people only. The European, who is preeminently a man of will, views this rationalistic rabbi and therefore also the Talmud with little understanding and sympathy, and, on the other hand, opens his heart to the prophet and the Bible. But there is one thing which the European surely does not know, namely: that the thoughts and aspirations of the rabbi are just as naive and chaste as those of the prophet. But for this there would be no points of contact between rabbi and prophet.

The Jew, on the other hand, shows little understanding of the Bible. He is himself a creature of the law. The law has made him a rationalist, and

HUTZLER BROTHERS CO.

Two-ninety-eight
June-July, 1917