The Test
ZIONIST EDUCATION
THE aim of all education is to prepare for service. When education is criticized as being too narrowly vocational, it is because a too narrowly vocational training is not the best preparation for a life of general human and social service. Incidentally, service means fulness of life. For to be a part means to have a share in the whole.
Zionist education has precisely the same purpose: Service. No doubt it enhances the life-service of the student, and it makes him happier. For Zionism gives far more to each of its adherents than he can ever repay with service, even with life itself. But we are only means; we are not the end. The end is the attainment of our ideal. And therefore when we teach Zionism—and all Jewish subjects pertain to this one subject—we are teaching it not for the good of the student but for the good of the cause. Incidentally, that is his highest good.
Zionist education cannot fail to enhance Zionist service. It cannot be wasted. At the most, it will help to develop to greater usefulness—or even actually to win for our work—those who are to do the organizing, collecting, teaching and writing for our cause, the propagandists. At the least, it will also develop propagandists of a less intensive sort by sending forth individuals who are qualified to present intelligently the Zionist point of view.
Zionist education was never more important than at this moment. If to-morrow Palestine were to be in Jewish hands, then to-morrow would be the day on which we should have to intensify our system of Zionist education. For what will we need? An understanding of the fact that every Jew must give financial support to Jewish enterprise in Palestine, and an understanding of the need for men and workers on our ancestral soil. And who will educate public opinion in these ways except those few who have come from Palestine and those whom we educate in our schools and clubs for that very purpose? Education underlies all group activity. This fact has been recognized by the workers in every field of social reconstruction, and we now have Suffrage Schools, Socialist Schools, Trade Union Schools to educate propagandists. But Zionism differs from all these in requiring far more knowledge for an adequate understanding. Though the aims of Zionism may be explained in five minutes—indeed, by a recitation of the Basel Platform—yet to be able to back that explanation with further explanations, to convince and to enlighten, requires a knowledge, an insight, which can be reached only by years of study. Zionism is not only a "movement" in the ordinary sense of that word. It is an acceptance of the facts of Jewish nationality, culture, group responsibility which colors the whole of life and of thought. Only a large number of such real Zionists can have the power to sway public opinion, to move others to become also Zionists.
A number of our Zionist societies have realized this need for educating their members for service, and have organized classes and study groups. I do not refer here to series of disconnected lectures by different speakers on a variety of unrelated subjects. These have been common to all Zionist societies and have lulled many a Zionist into forgetfulness of the true need. Such disorganized knowledge in pre-digested form may stimu-
late but cannot nourish. I refer here to classes with a definitely planned course, however, inadequate, in the history, theory or organization of Zionism, in Jewish history or literature, in Bible or organization or public speaking or even Hebrew melodies.
The Nordau Societies in New York, the B'nai Zion, the Mizrachi and others have organized occasional classes. Young Judaea, Hadassah and the Intercollegiate Zionist Society have taken up this question of Zionist education as a fundamental question, and have made a number of more or less successful experiments. The theory underlying the whole organization of Young Judaea is precisely that of educating Zionists from childhood to serviceable maturity, and recently it has also faced the problem of educating its own leaders and teachers and of rounding the junior work with a final test for adult service. The Intercollegiate Societies, only recently organized, have the best material to draw upon, as they deal with the college student, who is readiest for study, for insight and for service. Hadassah, dealing almost exclusively with full-grown girls and with women of every degree of education and intelligence, has had the most difficult problem. Possibly for that very reason it has contrived to maintain for the longest period of time an adult school and system of adult Zionist group education which has been steadily growing and developing for more than three years.
Outside of the Zionist organization, other agencies have more or less consciously furthered Zionist education. All Jewish education becomes part of the education for Zionism. For Zionism is only a name for Jewish consciousness and purpose plus the machinery of a modern organization. Hence every Hebrew School is our ally. Also the Menorah societies have brought us many recruits. However, there is danger in every educational agency financed by those who are non or anti-Zionists. Aside from the fine question of our own honesty in allowing their purposes to serve our ends, there is always the danger of a reaction to enmity on the part of those whom Providence so places that they must serve us against their own will. Still, from every such break there comes added strength to us—as in the case of the Technicum and the language struggle. The only true danger lies in our teachers selling themselves and, in the name of Jewish education, compromising forever their honor and their honesty.
It seems we have many agencies but no agency. Therein lies the chief weakness of Zionist education. It is all the more a weakness in these days when world events make it our business to bring home to every Jew and Gentile the fact that the Zionist organization alone can speak for Zionism. Centralization: that should be our watchword. Yet in education each Zionist society has its own system or no system, sets its own standard or no standard, as it chooses. Do all the students feel their relation and their responsibility to the organized Zionists of America? Can they be truly serviceable Zionists unless they do?
ZIONIST SERVICE
Even those who are most consistently opposed to compulsory military service are in favor of that of which military service is only a one-sided and exaggerated expression—namely, compulsory national service. If all vocational training were in the hands of the nation, and all young people during one or two of their formative