The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 6 · June 1917
82printed page
scan 40 of 70
Facsimile · scan 40 of 70
Scan of p. 82
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

any Jewish gathering in America. And thus the first $1,200 was raised, and gave the convention courage to have another collection at the banquet the following night.

Thus began the "appeal" which has become the time-honored custom at every Zionist mass-meeting and banquet ever since, and upon which, for a long time, the organization relied for the "sinews of war."

* * * * *

The next convention, in 1907, was held in Tannersville again, and then some of the bold souls in the movement decided that it was high time to attempt the conquest of another summer resort. This led to the Atlantic City convention following year—and the attempt to hold deliberative assemblies in a concatination of hurdy-gurdies, brass-bands, exhaust-valves of pop-corn and peanut roasters, the shrieks of the barkers and the howls of "eat-em-alive-Bosco," beating waves and skylarking week-enders. It was a continuous nightmare, with a full-fledged "insurrection" in the ranks of the movement.

But it marked the end of the "volunteer" system. Taking our courage in our hands, we determined upon at least one salaried officer, the secretary. And this one result alone makes that convention worth while, because with the introduction of a paid, responsible officer, the organization began to find itself and to cast about for means to meet its responsibilities without trusting to luck. (It must be noted that for a brief space we returned to the "volunteer" basis, but the precedent had been established.)

The next convention, in 1909, was held in New York City, and at its conclusion it was unanimously resolved "never again." The delegates were overwhelmed by the mass of spectators who ran things their own way, who crowded upon the convention floor, crowded the delegates out of their seats, participated in the discussions and dominated the situation. I doubt whether one constructive piece of work was done at this convention, the outstanding feature of which was a tremendous debate between the "practical" and the "political" Zionists. True, the "politicals" went down to defeat, but today they are standing by the organization, giving themselves and their lives to it, while the leader of the "practicals" has disappeared from our ranks.

* * * * *

All this time, however, we were growing in numbers, in strength, in coherence, in responsibility. The Achooza movement had been launched, "Dos Yiddishe Folk" founded, the MACCABAEAN rescued from the brink of bankruptcy, Young Judea organized, the Hadassah developed from a local society to a national organization, the Mizrachi fostered, the Poale Zion encouraged, the Bezallel School of Arts and Crafts made possible and the High School and Polytechnicum in Palestine established. Colonies were springing up in Palestine and Hebrew coming into universal recognition. So, with all of our haphazardness, we were straining toward maturity and responsibility. Yet, coming back now to the Rochester convention, a budget of $12,000, covering all expenses of the Zionist operation in America for the ensuing year—the year that was to prove the turning point of the movement—alarmed the delegates.

* * * * *

It was worth while living through the years of penury, through the years of "drang," worth all the sacrifices and all the suffering, to have arrived at the Boston convention, with Louis D. Brandeis the

dominating figure, flanked by Dr. Harry Friedenwald, by Stephen Wise, by Henrietta Szold, by Julian W. Mack; by Lipsky, de Haas, and Schmarya Levin.

Some of us have paid a heavy price for our devotion to the cause. But, whatever the price we have already paid, or what the future will yet extort from us for the sake of our people's rehabilitation and our land's reclamation, we shall pay it gladly. Meantime, we rejoice that the Baltimore Convention may be the greatest as well as the last convention of anticipation. God grant that if we may not say it for this year's gathering—then may the convention of 1918 be the convention of Realization.

Nationalism and Religion

(Continued from page 248)

I cannot say with authority; at least it is strange, under such auspices, that the present head of the movement in America should happen to be the most prominent of American rabbis, while every complexion of the American rabbinate is represented in Zionist councils.

But if we do grant that Judaism, not only American, but western, may even liberated Russian Judaism stands in need of a "spiritual reservoir" to save all these from extinction, have we not essentially admitted that our religion cannot endure without the aid of some factors of national living? By what superiority was Russian Jewry enabled to replenish our spiritual forces, and by what particular inferiority did our Judaism come to stand in need of such tonics? Is the Russian Jew congenitally more religious than his western brother or were his opportunities better for fostering his religion? It was the abolition of the Ghetto, it was the cultural dispersion of the Jews which gave rise to religious disintegration in the west; It was, on the contrary, the continuance of Ghetto conditions which preserved Russian Jewry as the "reservoir." And it is the threatened dispersion of the Russian pale which bids fair to rob us, in due time, of this fountain of Jewish rejuvenation, and the fountain itself of its Jewish and spiritual strength.

How are we going to create a Palestinian reservoir? By setting up another succession of assimilating processes for cultural and religious disintegration? Or by creating another woe-stricken Ghetto from which teeming masses of starved spectres shall religiously refertilize all the fading and paling Jewdoms of free, of rapidly assimilating cultures? No, we shall not cure our anemias of assimilation by perpetuating medieval islands of pious, oppressed Jewry; we shall redeem Israel by giving him back his identity, and strengthen Judaism by enabling it, in its own land, to create its own atmosphere, to unfold its congenial culture, to give body and color, to give courage, freedom and the capacity for religious genius, for creative progress back to our religion. We need a reservoir of cultural individuality, of religious intensity; the soil alone will not make it such, nor will numbers, nor would even isolation, if that were either practical or desirable. Only the sense of free, self-directing manhood will turn a purposeless rabble into a nation with aims and ideals and with the strength to realize them. Judaism needs nationalism for its root, as nationalism, with us, must have Judaism, in its highest, ultimate form, for its crown.

Max Weller