THE MACCABAEAN
us we would triumph. And because of this faith, and by it alone, we have in twenty years, accomplished a value revolution in American Jewry.
To betray a dark secret, we occupied a more prominent position in Jewish life in America than we were entitled to, if merit is to be tested by numbers. Youthful, ardent, intensely Jewish, we were emboldened by our ardor, by our fanatic devotion to everything Jewish. We confused terms, we muddled issues, and we made the Zionist platform a forum from which we emphasized the Jewish point of view. Had our opponents been possessed of real sagacity, had they had the wit to make a real measure of our strength, they would have taken us far less seriously. But—and this is the irony of the situation, they mistook clamor for strength. The truth was with us, that is a certainty. Even though we phrased our thoughts violently, our criticisms were based on fact, and weak and inconsequential as we were, we have compelled a restating of Jewish viewpoints. The fight would have been harder if the "opposition" had brought to bear on Jewish life that ability which they give to material concerns. That is betraying another "dark secret"—the secret of why our opponents have forfeited the right to Jewish leadership.
* * * * *
For our main issue we were able to do what now seems precious little. Yet, how we rejoiced over each little accomplishment. For they made us feel that we were growing—becoming a real movement with a real public sanction. Our shekel collection was pitifully small, our National fund contribution smaller, and the chief problem that confronted us was not the reconquest of Palestine, but finding ways and means for meeting the trifling expense of our operations. Conventions busied themselves with the question of raising a budget of less than $5,000 a year, and executive committee sessions grappled way beyond midnight with the problem of next month's rent and printing bills.
There were no salaries to pay in those days, except for the lone stenographer. The organization was manned by volunteers who gave such time as they could steal from their regular employment. Some of us sighed for the impossible—an assured income of $50 a week from some miraculous source, said income leaving us free to devote ourselves to our ideal. Others of us longed for the day when some of the Jewish millionaires would be moved to see eye to eye with us, step into the movement and finance it. But God was good to us—and kept the millionaires in the "opposition."
We stood still with remarkable success. The rank and file were severe in their criticisms of the "leaders" who were themselves helpless, and demanded that something be done. But the means for doing the things that needed to be done to "conquer the masses" were not forthcoming, because there was no source from which these means could come. To speak of levying a tax on the membership was equivalent to speaking of wrecking the organization. At least we thought so, though in these past years the membership has been only too eager to meet every tax that may be levied upon it, and to pay the tax doublefold. It was dangerous even to suggest an increase of the Federation tax from 25 cents to 50 cents, and the Atlantic City convention was the scene of a battle royal over this very question.
* * * * *
But with each ensuing convention, we added to our years and to our understanding that words alone would not bring us to our goal or our goal to us. It was at the first of the series of conventions held
in Tannersville that we became practical, that we began to realize that money, much money, would be needed to make it possible for us to convince the Jewish world of the righteousness of our ideal.
Dr. Harry Friedenwald had already begun the long, valiant service to the Jewish Nation for which the whole Jewish people is his debtor, and for which it will some day find a fitting form to express its gratitude. He had assumed the burdens of the presidency of the Federation of American Zionists a year before. Reluctantly and with great misgivings, he had consented to have his name presented to the Cleveland convention for that office. Misgivings of his own ability and worthiness, coupled with doubts as to the power of the Federation to live. But the struggling young organization needed him if it was to live at all. It had become necessary, since the resignation of Professor Richard Gottheil, the first president of the Federation, that the headship of the movement should be just such as he, representative of all that is best in Jewish and American tradition. It was this that persuaded him at last.
Those who had engineered this came to Cleveland. in a state of exaltation. They had found the man who would save the movement from foundering. But to their dismay another came to the convention with “claims” upon the office and who demanded that we elect him our president and accept him as our leader. It was an unexpected dilemma, one that they had not even imagined as within the realm of possibility. We did not dream that there could be found one among us who would have “ambitions” for honors or offices. We were confronted with “politics.” Caucuses were held and midnight conferences; bitter speeches were made and attempts to placate and mollify. We did not know what the outcome would be, and it was not until the last vote had been counted that our misgivings gave way to rejoicing. The years have vindicated the wisdom of our course —have justified the bitterness with which we fought against personal ambition, yet the recollection of Cleveland is such that it adds to the pleasure of letting the mind run on to the following year at Tannersville.
* * * * *
That was a novel undertaking. We took the delegates up into the Catskill Mountains to a Jewish hotel, and there for the best part of a week we lived under one roof, and came to really know and understand each other. There was tremendous opposition to the project. The term "vacation Zionists" was coined by the Yiddish speaking elements, but the Executive Committee stubbornly persisted in the idea, with the result that those who came to denounce remained to praise.
It was at this convention that we came into contact with "real" money that is, "real" by comparison with the gaping void that had served us in lieu of a treasury in the years that had passed. It was purely accidental. One of the speakers at the mass-meeting, waiting his turn, agonized as one after another of the long list of orators robbed him of each and every one of his "telling" arguments, with the result that when he was finally allowed to say his say, he had nothing to say. Some one leaned forward and said to him: "Don't forget the National Fund"—and with this as the keynote, he made an appeal. Pausing for breath, he was thunderstruck when some one in the audience stood up and spoke the thrilling words: "I give a hundred dollars." That had never happened before at a Zionist gathering—possibly at