The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 6 · June 1917
79printed page
scan 37 of 70
Facsimile · scan 37 of 70
Scan of p. 79
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

group organized, adopted a constitution, was incorporated, and the American Jewish Committee was born.

The members of the new group were, in fact, much more active in the parochial affairs of American Jewry. They were responsible for many of the charitable and philanthropic institutions in New York. They had reorganized the Jewish Theological Seminary. They controlled the Jewish Publication Society, and other Philadelphia institutions. Members of the group were large contributors to Jewish enterprises outside of New York, and some of them were known to leading European Jews.

Soon Mr. Wolf ceased to be the sole Jewish spokesman and representative in Washington. He was not displaced, but he gave place to others on important occasions, and devoted himself more exclusively to the details of petty representations that had to be made to the government on behalf of Jewish immigrants. The sceptre of power slipped from him and his friends, and others decided the fate of our people.

The American Jewish Committee has acted as the Jewish Ministry for Foreign Affairs every since the Kishineff pogroms. At its annual meetings, pretentious claims were made as to its participation in Jewish events, but it was felt that should any occasion demand a large and liberal-minded policy, the Committee would be in a position to act for American Jewry.

Autocracy, however, destroys itself by so reducing the surface of responsibility that,’ finally, only a limited few are interested, and then only one or two give the word of command and make the decisions and issue directions. In absolute control of the Committee, there never was an effort made to enlarge the sphere of interest, and to bring in the forces of the people. By meeting in secret, it estranged the people from genuine personal interest in what it was doing or not doing. As an autocracy, it could nevertheless have become a popular autocracy, for a while, by riding into popular favor with a policy that reflected the ideals and aspirations of the Jewish people. But with a perversity which is inexplicable, the self-appointed leaders contrived at every critical juncture in Jewish life to speak exactly the reverse of what was in the Jewish heart. It was decidedly unpopular, not so much because of its undemocratic methods, but because it never actually spoke for those ideals that were becoming the ideals of the people, under the influence of the Zionist propaganda.

It had no faith in the competence of the Jewish people, and no confidence in the judgment of the rank and file. It treated the enthusiasms of the general run of Jews with disdain and contempt. It had no faith in the extension of Jewish life, but wished to restrain and fetter it so that it would fit exactly into its procrustean bed of dogma and book theories. Instead of inviting the expansion of Jewish life, it wished to keep it within the bounds of a definition. It did not believe in Jewish nationality not because the symptoms of nationality were not present, but because in its opinion such symptoms should be eradicated. Whatever should not be, must not be. It had notions of order, progress, taste, language, and all of these notions the Jews were expected to adopt, and if not adopted, they had to be remonstrated with until bullied into acquiescence. Not only did this self-elected leadership insist upon doing what it pleased, but it insisted that American Jewry must conform in its thinking to the thoughts of the leaders.

They were the weight that oppressed Jewish life,

preventing expansion, making impossible color, animation, interest, responsibility. Had they prevailed, there would not have been a Zionist movement resting firmly upon the masses of the Jews; there would not have been that widespread interest in Hebrew education, in the Congress, in every popular movement of the day. The Yiddish-speaking Jews would have been a cowed, submissive, broken-English group, minus a literature, a press, a theatre, and a national life. The American Jewish youth would have been servile, lacking initiative, looking for the patronage of the wealthy instead of seeking to make Jewish careers for themselves. Our life would have been an unimaginative, unprogressive, wholly contemptible survival of a people unable to combat the forces of assimilation, and practically doomed to extinction.

The policy of the self-appointed leaders had two forces to contend with. First, such a form of life could not endure in an American atmosphere, where freedom and democracy are ingredients of every phase of social life. To the American young men bred in the public schools and graduated from American universities, autocratic representation could not be endured. It was obnoxious to the spirit of the times. What is characteristic of the American spirit is its assertiveness, its refusal to subordinate itself to codes formulated by others. The American does not minimize his powers; it is more frequently brag than self-effacement. The constant reiteration of submissiveness, the denial of Jewish characteristics and talents, the segregation of Jewish life into only one form of expression, the obsequious and vapid claims to patriotic ardor, the seeking of justification for Jewish life, —all this the free American spirit could not swallow. The first to resist the control of the American Jewish Committee were American-born and educated Jewish young men, who were active in the Zionist movement.

Second, such a policy excluded from consideration the large, predominant element of Jews coming from Eastern Europe. A policy that refused to take them into account was doomed to failure. The Russian Jews knew what oppression and persecution meant, and contact with American institutions was bound to lead to a genuine respect for democracy. They increased in numbers so rapidly that they were compelled to establish their own institutions, unaffected to a large extent, by American methods. They established their newspapers and theatres, their asylums and charitable institutions, and clung to Yiddish long enough to enable that language to attain a fluency and an influence which gave content to their own national aspirations. Little respect was paid to the new settlers, and plans were made for improvement without consulting them. Gradually there developed, thanks to the tactlessness of the self-appointed leaders, a feeling of estrangement, a feeling that the leaders were not related to them in their conception of Jewish life, and there ensued a conflict in which the self-appointed leaders were challenged to produce their credentials. The new settlers produced their own leaders, many of whom were at once at first absorbed and smothered by the American Jewish Committee. But there were too many who refused to be "co-opted." They formed the nucleus of the revolt. The Yiddish newspapers, edited by radicals, directed their batteries against the Jewish government, until gradually, the prestige and influence of the Committee were reduced to such proportions that with the development of the American Jewish Congress movement, its power was taken from

(Continued on page 304)