The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 6 · June 1917
71printed page
scan 29 of 70

THE MACCABAEAN

him appear mediæval and benighted in the eyes of many of his colleagues. You remember Herzl's friend who burst into tears after reading the "Judenstaat," because he thought the brilliant Herzl was unbalanced. That was the effect of Dr. Foerster's book on some of us; but it was thus and yet otherwise in the case of a reader in whom, after all, some seeds of self-doubt had previously been planted, and who began to wonder whether there were not more things in the world than she had dreamed of in her philosophy. Again her mind was thrown into turmoil. The thought that men were placed in the world in complete detachment from the Power that made them, without any word of explanation, without any means of access, seemed too ghastly to be true. Could they not demand of the beautiful world about them that it should present some revelation of God's will? As I was brooding over these things one evening, at sunset, suddenly the unhappiness and restlessness of the previous months settled into gray passivity. The state of Ecclesiastes at the end of his search for wisdom, resigned to a final no to all inquiry, had been reached. That very evening, though we did not know it, the Foerster party came to the village to a little house they had rented for a month. The next day, to our mutual surprise, we discovered that chance had brought us all together.

At our very first meeting, in the Foersters' villa at tea, the conversation bordered on questions of paramount interest. Once more Dr. Foerster began to talk about religion, touching in a desultory way on one point after another, and confessing that Christianity seemed to him the final expression of what men need. It was then that I asked him,—if he truly wished to continue to discuss these things with me, as I hoped he did,—to begin at the very beginning and to build up each new argument upon one previously understood. He agreed to this, with the result that in the course of the next few weeks we had many conversations that threw light upon the hidden world of consciousness within us that, once awakened, interprets the whole of life to us in a new way. We discussed, among other things, the consequences of unrestricted individual liberty of judgment, reverence for authority, the Reformation—its good and its evil effects in so far as the higher moral life of man is concerned,—"The world is too much with us, late and soon, getting and spending, we lay waste our powers;" the value of holy days; the Church's fear of science; the meaning of confession and atonement; the Church as an organization. "No organization can be perfect; it begins well, but error creeps in. Nevertheless, organization is necessary."

These conversations and letters received during the next few years brought before me the two ways of regarding religion that may be compared to the two ways of judging men. Note the difference between a friendly judgment of a friend and a critical estimate of the same person. The critical observer sees acts as they stand by themselves and as they appear to the mind; but the friend who judges, places these acts in relation to the character from which they proceeded, and while testing them with the mind, also interprets them with the heart of love that unlocks new gates for the understanding. Through conversations due to an accidental meeting in Switzerland, and through the correspondence that continued the discussions begun there, the opportunity was given to one who had heretofore tried and failed to explain religion by processes of reason, to secure a re-education along religious lines; and, strange as it may seem, there was so much

June-July, 1917

that was universally true in the new teachings that, though at the time they only extended her understanding of Christianity, they nevertheless prepared che way for the later entrance of Jewish ideas into her mind. As I reread Dr. Foerster’s letters of those days I find much that can be applied to Jewish problems. Here is an illustration. It seems that at some time I must have pleaded for tolerance of all human activities that are prompted by good intentions. To this plea Dr. Foerster replied that the greatest mischief is done not by purposeful bad intent but by short-sighted good-will. “There are good people whose optimism does not recognize the weaknesses of mankind. “He who does not see the dark will also not see the light, but will mistake all sorts of jack-o’-lanterns for the light.” Can we not apply this to the short-sighted benevolence of Palestinianism, and to those optimists who will not see the dark fact that to bring the Jews to Palestine without establishing them as a politically recognized nation among nations, would be only to court a repetition of their tragic history and a new dispersion? In another letter Dr. Foerster addressed himself to those who are perplexed about accepting the Gospels literally, urging them not to raise issues of casuistry, as to whether one must never tell a lie, never use force, etc., but to try to express the spirit of these books in positive action. When we read through the Old Testament we can relate this advice to corresponding questions. We need not trouble about inconsistencies or about the primitive ideas of morality contained in the first books ; all we need to do is to accept the Bible as the story of the evolution of a people’s knowledge of God, and concentrate attention upon expressing its spirit in our own conduct. Again, what Dr. Foerster wrote is true: “Was mit Blut und Thranen geschrieben ist, kann nicht mit der Brille gelesen werden.” (“That which is written with blood and tears, we cannot decipher by putting on spectacles”). At that time, however, no comparisons with Jewish ideas suggested themseves. It is a sorry fact’that educated Christians are not more ignorant of all that concerns Jewish life and theory than Jews brought up entirely under the influence of assimilation. ‘It was ten years after Herzl wrote the “Judenstaat” and two years after his death that, for the first time, some of us heard the word Zionism mentioned. It was in Holland, while we were visiting the home of a young Dutchman, who in recent years has, I believe, held high office in the Zionist organization. In those days he was still a student. He began to talk to us about a Jewish State in Palestine; one of our party ridiculed the idea; thereupon this young man spoke with earnestness and dignity of the obligation resting upon all Jews to regard Zionism with respect, whether they agreed with it or not. “One must not sneer at a cause to which great men have given their lives.” These were the first words to break through the ignorance of at least one of his Jewish listeners, who had not known that any Jews were working for a Jewish revival. It may even be that these words served as one of the many deterrents that kept Christianity from making a new convert.

It is indeed true that this record of a quest for wisdom is in large part the record of friendships. I had a friend, a wonderful girl, whom I had first met when, a Russian immigrant working in a sweatshop, she wanted to prepare herself for college. Later, she won a scholarship at Teachers' College. Though she was an atheist, she would not attend Saturday sessions, because to do so would have grieved her mother,

(Continued on page 300)

Two-sixty-nine