THE MACCABAEAN
voluntary forces which would often clash with the law there lived also the poetic and religious spirit. Religion and poetry are sisters. In the Bible we find by the side of Deuteronomy the book of Psalms, a book full of fervent religious lyrics. Law and religion (religious aspiration for which there is no room in the Law) existed in the earliest times either side by side or opposed to each other—in either case they constituted two parallel tendencies which often inter- acted. But the law, being absolute, could not tolerate any other power by its side and always contended for first place. This tendency resulted in manifold convulsions from which the law always came forth victorious. When at the close of antiquity life had grown more and more complete and the law had found new spheres of activity, the other forces were pushed back more and more, until finally it was extinguished altogether for a time, although at certain periods it would reappear and explode with much greater force. When this happened there appeared either the flaming spirit of rebellion or widespread mysticism in grotesque forms. Such outbreaks menaced the existence of the people. The rebellious spirit weakened by itself, and the mysticism was the easier downed by the law, inasmuch as since the destruction of the state the law was the only powerful factor in the life of the nation. In some instances mysticism was cut off and put beyond the pale of Judaism. It then became the leaven of the newly arisen Christianity. Whatever of poetical force there remained in the people found in the Hagada and Midrash a thoughtful but styleless and formless expression. And even this creation of a faintly quivering psychologism was bound to ally itself with the Halachic rabbinism, for the Hagadists were for the most part also Halachists. The few Hagadists who did not participate in the Halacha, as Pinchus bar Joir, Samuel bar Nachmoni and others, were officially called rabbanan deagata, i. e., Hagada-Rabbis. Now it is interesting to see how the original equality between Halacha and Hagada was followed by a gradual pushing back of the Hagada until at the period of the Gaonim the Hagada had lost its dignity and importance and the Halacha was the decisive factor. In other words: The higher the law rose as a factor in life, the more were the other tendencies of the mind pushed to the background.
This decline from life to the book, from the will to “reason,” can be traced back to the early beginnings of Jewish history.
The biblical account of Moses is full of action and heroic deeds. The whole life of this man without whom one cannot think of Jewish history is one long unceasing battle carried on against the Egyptians and their king, against a people debased by slavery, against the great and powerful God who, despairing of this people, would destroy it, and against numerous anonymous forces of life that block His way and hinder the great achievement of the creation of a nation. Few of the great men in the history of the world faced so many new and dangerous situations and problems as did this man, and few achieved so much that endures, because he was a genius of will and actions. Moses was succeeded by judges, priests and kings, none of whom was active in his own way. The chronicles of their times tell of war and its heroes, of internal strifes and the display of powerful passions. As yet the law played no important part. Free and unbridled was the sensuality of the young people, and frequently it would in its light-heartedness run after strange gods but soon, repentingly, return to the one God. In short, it acted, moved about,
sinned and repented—it lived. But the “religious law” was at the same time the moral law and the people—a Semitic race—with its tendency to go to extremes was in danger of losing its moral integrity. The priest was powerless to prevent the waywardness of the people and to bring definite rythm into the course of life. Nor could politics do this, because it had from the beginning to follow forces which have no basis in life. At the time of the greatest political, moral and religious calamity the prophet, strong of will and intellect, appeared on the scene. They talk about the development of Jewish prophecy. I believe that is all wrong. The “schooled” prophets were the very ones who were false prophets and aided and abetted the low life. The great prophets who mark the highest development in Judaism and make the immortality of the Jewish people secure are the “unschooled” prophets, men of all ranks and conditions of life. They arose as suddenly as did Moses before them.
Prophecy is not an economic vocation, a conferred dignity, or a political office. Everybody who had in him the desire to proclaim the good and the true could be a prophet. The prophets were neither interpreters nor professors of law, but independent tribunes of the people, who proclaimed the unvarnished truth, without giving thought to their own personal welfare. Their courage is unexampled. In proclaiming the truth they were not afraid of the caprice of the despot nor of the whim of the people. Regardless of their personal safety they exhorted the people and warned them of the impending disaster. Not only the duty of obedience to the divine call but also the anxiety for the people’s future, which only the realization of the good and the true could make secure, impelled them to go out to the turbulent masses and work with superhuman perseverance for the accomplishment of their mission. They were neither ascetics nor mystics, but men of wide vision and of infinite love for their people, whose moral perfection would bring about the moral salvation of mankind. They spoke in the name of a God who demands morality and who is himself the essence of morality. Their whole soul-life was absorbed in this one single thought. In consequence of the concentration of their whole inner world upon the moral thought their world view became rather one-sided.
But they fought with the whole power of their strong-willed personality for the realization of their moral idea. They projected their own moral personality into the outer world, and did it with such elementary power that it could not fail to make an impression, the more so as they gave utterance to their prophecies by an almost grotesque peculiarity and a powerful poetic pathos. Though all the prophets had their feet firmly planted on intellect, yet the outpourings of their mouths were not of the intellect but of the will. It was from the prophets and not from the Talmud, that the waves of thought radiated which travel on and on as a living force.
Although the prophets were active men of strong will and contemplated with the broad outlook of a genius all the great movements of their age, they were, nevertheless, only great dreamers; for they were severe, uncompromising men. They were too one-sided to keep in touch with the realities of life. As their efforts bore no fruit they were led to a negation of life, to a breaking with the present reality for the sake of creating a future reality after their own hearts. They failed to discriminate between what
(Continued on page 298)