THE MACCABAEAN
of socialism the general views which persons schooled in the theories of Zionism had previously expressed.
Thus when the socialist Zionists of various nuances of opinion began to organize, they hardly differed as regards this part of their ideology from the other radical elements within the Zionist organization.
But the new and important step of the socialist Zionists consisted in their proceeding to fuse Zionism and socialism into an almost independent party, and in their gradually evolving the tenet that for the Jewish people socialism without Zionism is as menacing as it is impracticable.
The most consistent supporters of this opinion, the Poale Zion, did not content themselves with a schematic combination of the socialist and the Zionist ideal, but they sought to construct a homogeneous ideology therefrom. They maintained that the Jewish people in working for socialism without Zionism was guilty of a logical misconception of actual circumstances, for it lacked the premises for a complete class conflict and was bound to fail as long as the Jews had no land of their own. On the other hand, they asserted that the realization of the Zionist ideal without socialist tendencies was not only to be repudiated in itself for ethical reasons but was moreover an impossibility.
It is evident from all these theoretic considerations how great was the influence of the Marxian school on the Jewish youth as a whole. The desire to build up the future not on will but on necessity is uppermost. Zionism is to be socialistic not because socialism as such is a sublime ideal and in such perfect harmony with the sentiments and tendencies of ancient Israel, but in order to bring about its own realization. Therefore the following maxim, howbeit unspoken, held good for the Poale Zion: "Zionism will either be socialistic or not at all."
Thus it was not for universal reasons that the Zionists were to accept socialism, nor even because a general recognition of Zionism was tied up with a world victory of radical socialist ideas; no, each and every Zionist was to include socialism in his program primarily because the socialist Jews alone could be the most determined foes of assimilation, the most energetic exponents of the nationalist idea, and consequently the most self-sacrificing elements working for the realization of Zionism.
Succeeding events proved the claims of the Poale Zion to be at least partially justified, for it was really they who proportionately made the greatest sacrifices for the cause of Zionism. In Russia, they unhesitatingly underwent all manner of persecutions in consequence of their political acts and engaged in desperately dangerous struggles. In Palestine, they provided bands of men true to their principles and fired with sacred enthusiasm.
On the other hand, the assumption that socialist Jews were bound to accept Zionism has shown itself to be wholly unfounded. The Poale Zion themselves were not composed of half of Zionists who accepted socialism and half of socialists who had endorsed Zionism. ‘There were only a few who went over to the Poale Zion from the ranks of socialism. Most of them were former Zionists who had always inclined towards socialism and who accordingly sought to incorporate the socialist program in their own.
The tempestuous desire of the Poale Zion to take part in revolutionary activities in Russia met with the same obstacles as all other aspirations of a liberal nature. All the more did they devote their strength to collectivist work in Palestine, and all the more did they oppose political Zionism, especially in the years
preceding the world war. In their eyes, political Zionism was a non-political tendency which would cause mischief in the lands of the Diaspora, as well as in Palestine itself, and would lead the people astray. Because the political Zionists were Utopian and impractical, they would treat with the various governments in the vain hope of diplomatic success and would consequently allow themselves to take reactionary steps in order to attain their goal. Besides they were standing in the way of the organic development of Palestinian Jewry and of Zionism itself.
At the present time, it is surely superfluous to take up the cudgels for political Zionism, since even the opponents of political Zionism have recently done everything in their power to let their former opposition sink into oblivion. Here we shall reject only one of the premises of the former Poale-Zionistic manifesto as untenable, namely, the view that we Jews can "receive" Palestine only then when we shall have built it up. This principle was borrowed from the general colonial-political ambitions of peoples living in entirely different circumstances, although even they have not always acted in accordance with it. Even in recent times, it is not in all cases that lands have been acquired only by means of economic occupation; frequently the political domination of the country has preceded its economic conquest. But even if this principle could be carried out by powerful states, it was certainly not a law to be imposed on the work of the Jews in Palestine. What uncounted attempts at colonization came to nought in Palestine for the reason that political and judicial conditions made systematic work impossible! The creative work accomplished in Palestine gave us noble examples of our capacity for self-sacrifice and produced a tangible moral basis for our claim on our land, but it could not lead to results in proportion to the labor which was expended. It was of political value in that it gave us colonial strongholds, but it could not have led by "organic" ways to the realization of Zionism.
Whoever observed the wonderful occurrences in the spring of 1914, the flowering year of our Palestinian activities, open-mindedly, had to acknowledge that without a legal status, it was impossible to carry out a systematic process of colonization. Therefore it was always a sign of shortsightedness to deride the old Herzlian demand for a charter, and to stigmatize political Zionism as a theory premised on catastrophes. At the very moment when the world war revealed new vistas for humanity, the doctrine of an “organic conquest” of Palestine suddenly sank into the background, and Herzl triumphed anew. Then it was that the Poale Zion threw off their former tenets with remarkable elasticity and took refuge in the “catastrophic theory,” that is, the charter in its most far-reaching significance as Herzl conceived it before the first-Zionist Congress." Thus they gave practical evidence that will can be stronger than theory. ...
Far different in kind from the evolution of the Poale Zion was that of the Séimists. The latter, while they were at once with the Poale Zion in regarding political Zionism as-Utopian, went so far as to take the stand that the idea of Palestinian concentration should be bereft of its dominating significance. At the same time, they borrowed the doctrine from political Zionism that the most important task to be accomplished was the national organization of Jewry. But while political Zionism considered this primarily in the light of a means, inorder to consolidate the Jewish people to the end of acquiring Palestine. the
(Continued on page 305)
