The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 6 · June 1917
52printed page
scan 10 of 70
Facsimile · scan 10 of 70
Scan of p. 52
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

the stronger. The Governments have already learned that their information on the Jewish problem hitherto has been one-sided, and that it has been contrary to the trend of Jewish development.

A recent move on the part of the Organized Active Assimilation has been that of the two aristocratic English Jewish organizations, the Board of Deputies and the Anglo-Jewish Association. They have been guilty of an act that will cover them with eternal shame and disgrace, and that will serve the Jewish people as a warning that the "enemy within the gates" is more to be feared than any foreign enemy.

A declaration was published jointly by these two organizations aimed against Jewish nationalism and Zionism. The declaration called out a storm of disapprobation in English Jewry itself. This storm will doubtless lead to a split, and the split to a bitter struggle to the end, when the Assimilationist clique now gathering its last forces shall be morally annihilated, and disappear as a political factor from the Jewish world.

The conflict will not be confined to England alone: it will spread over the entire Jewish world. The act of the English Jewish organizations, although committed on English soil, is a part of the internationally organized Jewish Assimilation, with its chief branches in England, France, and Germany.

The declaration of the English Jewish organizations was published in almost the entire Jewish press here, and I shall therefore discuss only the two main points contained in it.

The first point there made is that the Jewish Settlement in Palestine—meaning the future Settlement—must not have a recognized political character, because the Jewish people must have its religion as its main basis, religion being the only symbol of the Jew.

The second point is that if the Jews receive special rights in Palestine, it will be a misfortune for the whole Jewish people, which believes that all are entitled to equal rights.

We shall proceed to analyze the first objection. Many will ask: Why excite yourself over that? Do we hear for the first time that the Jews are not a nation, but only a religious community? Is not this view rooted in the teachings of the so-called Mendelssohnian school, and have we not heard this doctrine from our modern Reform preachers, from our great bankers and other Jewish leaders?

Indeed, we have heard this doctrine before, and we have held it to be false doctrine, and have fought it as false doctrine, as the product of servility, of ignorance, of denial of facts, of moral blindness. But we never expected that this senseless ideology would be used as a practical weapon to destroy the historic hope of our people at the moment of its realization.

In the present instance, it is not a question of theories, and the declaration is not theological, though it does speak of God and religion. We are here faced with a treacherous political act.

Assimilation feels that the national hope can now be realized. Great world governments are ready to help the Jewish people achieve its freedom as a nation among all the other nations of God's earth. Then it comes and says that this may not be. The Jews must not be granted the possibilities of national development in Palestine. And not only in Palestine, in no land should they be allowed such possibilities, because the Jews are not a nation, they are merely a people with the single function of religion. That is, Assimilation comes to the peoples

of the world and accuses the Zionists, the Nationalists and all other Jews who believe in the right of our people to exist as a national unit, and says to them: "Do not listen to them, do not believe them! They are fooling you, they are deceivers! They demand national rights in various countries, and they want Palestine too! That is a fraud! As for us, now, we tell you the truth. We are nothing, we have but one distinguishing trait common to us all, binding us together. For the sake of that single trait, you need not go to any trouble. Don't be too considerate of them. Show them the door!"

That is the true intent of their declaration, its purpose and aim.

Thus Assimilation has the effrontery to speak in God's name, and treason wraps itself in the mantle of religion. It is we who are the protectors of the Jewish religion, you half-baptized fathers and you wholly baptized children! You are the most hateful type that Goluth Judaism has produced.

The second objection is in line with the contemptibleness and the hypocrisy of the first. But it also has a virtue. It reveals the confusion that reigns in Assimilationist heads, the decay that the poison of Assimilation has caused in the minds of the leaders of the Assimilation. "If the Jews receive special rights in Palestine, it will be a misfortune for the Jewish people, which believes that all peoples are entitled to equal rights." More than equal rights for all peoples the Nationalists and the Zionists do not demand. In fact, all their demands proceed from the underlying principle of equal rights for all peoples. But to come at a moment when the fate of all subject and oppressed peoples is in the balance, when new strong and weak alike—are being sought, and to betray at that moment one's own people in the name of equality for all peoples—that is a psycho-pathological phenomenon. A sickly morale alone cannot excuse it. It is a matter for psychiatric science to explain.

The entire world is now becoming more democratic. The more democratic governments become, the more openly do they treat their problems. The democracy of the whole world now protests against secret international agreements. Our political life, too, has been full of secrets. Assimilation worked in the dark. The open combat that lies ahead of us will be our salvation. Active nationhood will enter the lists against the Active Assimilation, and measure forces.

And I believe that it is the good fortune of the Jewish people that circumstances have forced the organized Assimilation to step out of the darkness behind which it has always woven its nets, to throw off its mask and show itself to the world in all its nakedness. Let the non-Jewish world, too, see its lineaments—that will be of great service to the Jewish people.

We know now definitely just how far organized Assimilation is prepared to go, and the knowledge stimulates us. The game of Nationalism versus Assimilation must cease. Every individual and every organization will have to show their colors. To each the question will be put: "Art thou with us or with our enemies?" No evasion will be allowed, and the half-way Assimilationists will grow afraid. They will suddenly realize whither it has been proposed to lead them and they will hasten to the other side. That which is positive will triumph over the negation. The Renascence will overcome annihilation. The last battle will then be fought and it will appear how little support Assimilation has among the Jewish people. The Jewish victory will then be assured.