THE MACCABAEAN
must the newer Judaism manifest itself. The fountains of Jewish originality must be made to well up again that the eivear af Iswing watere mary oladdan tha rity af Cad
If Reform seeks contact with the prophets and the times when Orthodoxy was not yet, Zionism links itself to the periods of our nationhood when the dispersion had not set in or, as in Roman times, when the Jew had many fatherlands, but one mother country. The objection often raised that the Zionistic state will endanger the status of the Jew in the dispersion reveals itself as futile. The struggle between the Messianists who undermined the state that the golden age might be built upon its ruins and the nationalists who would safeguard the life of the nation by turning to good purpose political constellations is an old one. The Maccabees were not content, like Daniel, to look to the clouds for the advent of the kingdom of the saints ; they won independence by dint of heroism and diplomacy. Spinoza, who had broken with the religion of his fathers and wondered what kept up the Jewish race, was led by the Messianic commotion in the Jewry of his day to the cool observation that the Jews might succeed in repatriating themselves. And farther back, those who founded the second commonwealth were the eminently practical men who obtained from the Persian rulers autonomy for the re-occupied land of the fathers, while the Messianists were dreaming of a transfigured Jerusalem and waited for Elijah to reconcile the old and the new. Herzl’s Zionism was a thinly disguised territorialism, but the territorialist Zangwill has rejoined the Zionist movement, for Palestine seems to be within the grasp of the Jewish people. Cultural Zionism cannot dispense with political Zionism, just as culture must rest
upon a home, and a home must needs be autonomous. The unorthodoxy of Zionism is only an apparent one. If the Jewish people wills to terminate the dispersion, its will is directed by God. The orthodox have found no difficulty in espousing Zionism. Life prevails over logic. And orthodox legalism can always find a precedent to quote. Rabbinical authority is not wanting to show that ere the Messiah will come Jerusalem may be rebuilt and Palestine re-occupied. Reform and Zionism, both instinct with the modern spirit, may well go together. No doctrinaire ban will dislodge the Zionist from Reform pulpits. Probably Reform may have to be reformed. Surely the Hamburg Temple platform is not more immutable than the Torah in Maimuni’s Creed. Reform will have to abandon its notion that the dispersion is final. In England it calls itself by the name of Liberal Judaism. If it can thrive in London, why not in Jerusalem? In all likelihood it will be modified by the Palestinian environment. Orthodoxy is the creation of the dispersion. When the Jewish home in Palestine is fairly under way, life will inexorably modify religious practice. But the reforms will be effected by a Jewish life, it will be a Jewish reform in truth. The present-day Reform which ne- ‘gates nationalism and the present-day Nationalism which thinks it may start with a clean slate on which religion shall have been effaced, are both transitory. If we heed the one, we shall go to certain death in the dispersion; and if we are led by the other, we shall go to the devil in Palestine. Orthodoxy, Zionism, and Reform must come to terms. The hour calls for a united front. The destiny of the Jewish people is paramount, and it rises superior to creed, doctrine, and platform.
HOMEWARD
A Jewish land, a Jewish home, No longer all wide world to roam; No longer all the earth to tramp, No longer bear the servile stamp; No longer hide my Jewish face, For fear of torture and disgrace; No more expose my soul for sale And buy the air that I inhale. A Jewish land! my earth, my ground— How wond'rous sweet these tidings sound! Two thousand years pursued and wronged My forbears hoped and pined and longed,
And every day three times did pray That God may send that glorious day. A Jewish home, a Jewish land, Still firm of foot, stil] strong of hand. We answer, mother, to thy call: We go, we come, thy children all! From North and West and South we go Thy towns to build, thy fields to plow; Thy wounds to heal, thy shame to drive, That you and we may both revive. That you and we forget our woe— O motherland, we go, we go!