The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 5 · May 1917
28printed page
scan 6 of 24
Facsimile · scan 6 of 24
Scan of p. 28
Text · transcribed from the scan

Zionism and Reform

By DR. MAX L. MARGOLIS

WHAT is the relation of Zionism to Reform? and are the two compatible? The question has recently been raised again. I believe that it is capable of a cool, objective treatment. I for one see no reason for obtruding the personal equation. I have no axe to grind and no old score to pay. The little controversy to which I was once a party is dead and buried so far as I am concerned. I have no disposition to engage in theological feuds. I stand far removed from ecclesiastical politics. Through long. reflection, however, there has come to me clarity of judgment.

Reform started with the negation of future national restoration in Palestine. It builds upon the conviction that the dispersion is definitive, irrevocable. Zionism, on the other hand, pronounces it terminable. So did also Orthodoxy or traditional Judaism. But there is this difference. To the orthodox the dispersion is terminable at the will of God only. If Israel is worthy, the end may come sooner; otherwise it will come in God’s own season. To the Zionist the dispersion is terminable at his own will, at the will of the Jewish people. It is really a three-cornered fight. Reform and Zionism are both modern, unorthodox. Both sever the national or political and the religious or theological moments which form an inextricable tangle in the traditional Judaism with which they broke, both divide Church and state. Zionism takes up the one thread and becomes political, Reform the other and becomes churchly. If Zionism and Orthodoxy are at one in the conception of the destiny of the Jewish people, less remote to the Zionists and more distant to the traditionalist, Reform and Orthodoxy are much nearer to one another so far as the interim status of Jewry is concerned.

For there is an interim in the Reform construction of the Jewish hope as well. If we analyze the hazy and incoherent mass of beliefs and hopes associated with the “days of the Messiah” as they grew up quite unsystematically through the long centuries from the fall of the Northern Kingdom to the massacres of Chmielnicki, we shall find that on a soberer plane, as in the Torah and occasionally with the rabbis and 50 definitively in Maimuni’s Creed, the national element predominated; yet it was far from being secular. The dispersed were to be gathered and a national state set up in the land of the fathers, free from foreign subjection, but it was to be a new Israel with heart circumcised, obedient to the Law of God, and winning over mankind to the full Jewish truth. Then 111616 is the prophetic picture of the Golden Age Regained when nation shall not lift up sword against nation and man and beast be at peace with each other, when evil and weeping shall cease and death be swallowed up; but despite the new heaven and the new earth the new order of things is quite terrestrial, this worldly, or rather the other world is brought down to earth. In the apocalyptic and mystic visions the reverse takes place: the new order is lifted off the earth and becomes celestial, and the blast of the horn of redemption becomes the signal for universal resurrection, world-judgment, and the life everlasting with its angelic bliss. The popular phantasy naturally seizes upon the miraculous and other-worldly elements, and the Messianic movements in the past, we need only mention the “Turkish Messiah” in Zangwill’s description, had an antinomian touch which the guardians of true Orthodoxy, the rabbis, were not slow to perceive. Indeed, Orthodoxy was at all times suspicious of Messianic pretenders,

and so soon as one presented himself, it proceeded to wait for the one who was still to come. The medieval ghetto was the natural interim condition. And when in modern times it was broken down in the West and the Jew made ready to integrate himself into the nations and citizenship was conferred upon him, the old-fashioned, like Akiba Eger, remonstrated that the Jew had no desire to settle permanently in the dispersion, but the bulk of the people continued to pray for the gathering of the dispersed, the rebuilding of Jerusalem, the restoration of the Temple service, and the advent of the son of David; yet they looked upon the event as too far removed to affect their status in the present as citizens and patriots. There were Christians who held to millennial hopes ; why could not Jews? They would continue to abide in the dispersion “until then.” “Then” they might again form a national entity, but “until then,” in the long interim, they constituted everywhere part of another nation. Reform broke with the hope of national restoration completely. It denationalized Judaism in quite a thoroughgoing manner. It discarded the belief in the personal Messiah. But it clung to the “days of the Messiah,” an impersonal Messianic era in the abstract. Its advent was perhaps set at too near a date. “We recognize,” the Reformers proclaimed, “in the modern era of universal culture of heart and intellect the approaching of the realization of Israel’s great Messianic hope for the establishment of the kingdom of truth, justice, and peace among all men.” They pray for the day when Israel shall “step out into the world” and make way for “spiritual descendants.” The bloody Russian massacres have been named by a modern apocalyptic prophet “the throne of the Messiah,” the last convulsions of the satanic power, and recent events in Russia would seem to bear out the prognostication. Nevertheless, I fancy that Reformers will prorogue the “realization of Israel’s great Messianic hope” to a more distant future. For be it remembered that the formula of the “impersonal Messianic era” conditioned the continuance of the Jewish people as a separate entity in the dispersion. The “stepping out into the world” was meant for the millennium. Reform, therefore, has its own “until then.” Orthodoxy, looking upon the dispersion as brought on “by our sins,” and Reform, calling it a blessing, both are content to settle down to an interim condition. “Until then” we remain in the dispersion, says Orthodoxy. “Until then” we remain separate, avows Reform.

Orthodoxy can really maintain itself only in a ghetto, with every dwelling within walking distance from the Synagogue, and life hedged in by a multitude of provisions marking it off from that of our neighbors. Reform denies that there can be a distinctive Jewish life outside the sphere of religion. There is no such thing as a Jewish culture. The Solomonic Temple was built by Phoenician artisans; our traditional synagogue architecture is as little indigenous as is our traditional synagogue music; Jewish philosophy is but Greek philosophy in Hebrew; Judah ha-Levi’s longing for Zion is a reflex of the love of the Andalusian poets for the Arabian homeland; aye, biblical themes are importations from Babylonia and our very Hebrew is but the lip of Canaan. In all outward forms, whether in the life without or in the synagogue within, there must be de-Orientalization, assimilation to Occidental types. Just because of this yielding attitude to the environment, Reform, far more potently than Orthodoxy, challenges the Church

May, 1917