“WITH MALICE TOWARD NONE”
Dollarland Spirituality
By DR. MAX HELLER
THOSE who have, in one way or another, adverted to the unofficial-official sermon on "Israel, the International People," which, as one wishes to take it, merely preceded or opened the Baltimore Council of Reform Congregations have overlooked an important point in that Anti-Zionist pulpit which calls for more than passing attention.
One ought, of course, to go a little deeper into the no-
tion of an "International People" which would have been fine grist for the Anti-Semitic mill, could any GermanJew of standing ever have been brought to the ineptitude of using it. "International People," "Cosmopolitan Clique," "Conspiracy of the Homeless," there is not much of a step from one to the other. Now an international religion, an international language, international science, art, charity, all these sound respectable; but an international people is the kind of insincere juggling that could only be matched by an undenominational sect, an intercentury age, an interstyle architecture or any other verbal monstrosity. To some people, of course, international sounds well, no matter in what connection, simply because it seems to negate the national, though, of course, it does not even do that.
But this is really beside the point. The statement which seemed to call for special comment by reason of its delicious naiveté, its unconscious disclosure of the underlying spirit of some kinds of Anti-Zionism, is to be found almost at the beginning of the address. We are there informed that “the center of gravity of Jewish life has shifted to America.” We wonder how this assertion is to be made good; whether we are to be shown that Jewish scholarship is flourishing, with us, beyond any other country on the globe or that our Jewish laymen are either the best informed or the most deeply interested in Jewish knowledge; or whether it is Jewish charity that has attained its purest forms or its greatest popularity here; or whether, to hew closely to the mission idea, it is the American Jew who is most deeply religious, who is the most active and self-sacrificing missionary, to the non-Jewish world, of ethical monotheism; whether it is the American rabbi who stands forth among the ministry of the country as the beau-ideal of intense religiousness, of fervid spirituality; the American synagogue which, by all nations, is called the typical,
irresistible house of prayer—none of these! No, ye people, hearken to the gospel of those who have no mission for the Jew, except the teaching of religion, to whom our nation has no raison-d'être, except that of being a kingdom of priests, a holy people, who repeat, in season, out of season, that religion is the be-all and end-all of Jewish life, that there is no Jewish spirit, except the religious spirit, hear them “talking out of the mouth of their simplicity” to use the picturesque rabbinical phrase: “In the plan of Providence the blessing and prosperity which are ours here in America are to become the instruments of salvation for our brethren. This is the latest chapter in the marvellous story which began in dim antiquity,” etc., etc.
Delicious! The most biting sarcasm, the bitterest irony could not have improved on this ingenuous morsel of smug Philistinism. "The blessing and prosperity which are ours," here is Providence's instrument of salvation! How finely unctuous! Heretofore our ears have reverberated to such solemnific and grandiloquent turns of bombast as: "the duty which is ours," "the opportunity which is ours" and similar trumpet-blares of vapid, vacuous, verbose pomposity; but "the blessing and prosperity which are ours here in America," there is a good oretund mouthful for you! One almost sees the placid stroking of domelike stomachs, the radiant gloating over inflated self-estimates that goes with such soothing, self-approving explanations of the discreetly bestowed favors of Providence.
“Blessing and prosperity are to become the instruments of salvation.” What a fine gospel from unctuous pulpit-lackey to beatific millionaire! In other words, we are the richest people on the face of the globe, therefore, to put it pompously, “the fitness is ours” to be the center of gravity, the spiritual focus for Judaism. These are thy gods, O Israel, that have led thee forth out of Egypt! Our millions will bring back the faded Jewish life; our prosperity will cure our snobbish attitude towards Jewish history, Jewish literature; our scientific charity will resuscitate Jewish manliness; the gorgeous temple will bring back Jewish fervor; presumably the high cost of living, for the poor, coupled with the dizzy extravagances of the rich will result in a revival of the fine democratic ways of old-time Jewry.
For once, this is a genuine Americanism, on its repelling side. It is treason, of course, to admit that there are repulsive phenomena in American life; but the Zionist feels himself safe enough in his simon-pure Americanism, in his attachment to all that is finest about American principles and American ideals, to indulge the luxury of recognizing and confessing that there are weak spots in the American life. America, justly or unjustly, has been called Dollarland; we have ourselves coined the unpleasant phrase of "the almighty dollar." Of course, the genuine American knows how to rise above the dollar-consideration; at the same time, there is, beyond all doubt, too much of
